SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Here’s what happened when this guy tried a Costco blind date

Oct 7, 2016, 9:16 AM | Updated: 11:45 am

Costco blind date...

Susan and David Barrow celebrated their two year anniversary much in the same way they first met, in front of mustard in Costco. (Contributed)

(Contributed)

It was a match made in Costco. Susan and David Barrow celebrated their two year anniversary much in the same way they first met — with mustard.

“We met in Costco in the mustard aisle,” Susan told KIRO Radio’s Dori Monson. “It was the Kirkland Costco, aisle 38.”

Why Seattle women are such big drinkers — men

That was in March 2014. It was a Costco blind date. The mustard-themed meeting was a good blend. The pair were married six months later.

So this month, the couple decided to celebrate their wedding anniversary by touring Costcos in the area dressed up as Mr. and Mrs. Mustard. Their tour made the news. Susan said that there has been so much depressing news lately, she wanted to do something fun.

A Costco blind date

David got Susan’s phone number from a friend and the two started chatting on the phone. They hit it off. So David decided to take it to the next level.

“I wanted to ask her out on a date, but I wanted it to be very normal … so I invited her out to Costco,” he said. “I think she thought I was a bit crazy.”

She didn’t think he was crazy.

“I thought he was either really cheap,” Susan said. “Or, because I’m a single mom, maybe he was going to fill a basket and bless me with a whole bunch of food.”

“I got neither of them,” she noted. “I got free samples, though.”

Susan headed into the blind date with an open mind. She didn’t know what the guy on the phone looked like, though David had her business card with her photo on it.

“I’m waiting there by the mustard and anytime someone came down, I was like, ‘Is this him, is this him?’” Susan said. “There was this lovely lady named Doris having a difficult time deciding if she wanted to buy mayonnaise or not. And she was distracting me, and I was like, ‘Listen, lady, I don’t have time to talk with you right now because this could be the date of my life.’ He turned the corner then, with a smile, and I figured that was him.”

“In person, she was much prettier than her business card,” David added. “I asked Doris to take a picture of us. That was the beginning of us becoming Mr. and Mrs. Mustard. The mustard was in the background. We walked around getting free samples and talking.”

As it turns out, Costco was a good date idea, but David did make one misstep that day — forgot to buy Susan the hot dog he promised her. On their anniversary, he fixed that. The two ate a hot dog together, starting at each end and meeting in the middle.

FILE - The National Guard and other uniformed members of law enforcement from federal, state, and l...

Associated Press

Louisiana National Guard ends deployment in New Orleans after eight months patrolling French Quarter

NEW ORLEANS (AP) — The Louisiana National Guard is ending its eight-month deployment patrolling the streets of New Orleans, and troops will be withdrawn from the city by the end of the month. The 120 remaining troops completed their final patrol Monday and are set to conclude their mission in the city on Aug. 31, […]

14 minutes ago

Cars line up outside a gas station in Tehran, Iran, Tuesday, Aug. 25, 2026. (AP Photo/Vahid Salemi)...

Associated Press

There are gas lines in Iran, but no sign yet that its leaders will bow to US sanctions

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates (AP) — Lines have grown outside gas stations across Tehran in recent weeks as the United States has tightened its blockade and threatened more severe sanctions, with some people waiting for two hours or more to fill up. The uncertainty deepened on Tuesday, after U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent vowed to […]

16 minutes ago

seattle diner restaurant best...

Jason Sutich

Japanese-inspired Seattle diner named among best new restaurants of 2026

The Wayland Mill, an American diner in North Lake Union, earned national recognition when Bon Appétit ranked it among the best new restaurants of 2026.

16 minutes ago

Associated Press

Watchdog files bar complaint against Jeanine Pirro over bid to indict 6 Democratic lawmakers

WASHINGTON (AP) — A legal watchdog says it filed bar complaints on Tuesday accusing U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro and two lieutenants of violating their ethical duties in seeking to charge six Democratic lawmakers with federal crimes for appearing in a video that called on troops to resist unlawful orders. The Legal Accountability Center’s bar complaints, […]

18 minutes ago

Minister of Finance and National Revenue Francois-Philippe Champagne speaks at a news conference on...

Associated Press

Canada targets steel, fish and hundreds of other goods as Trump trade war escalates

CHICAGO (AP) — Canada has pledged to roll out “dollar-for-dollar” countertariffs on scores of U.S. goods next month in response to President Donald Trump’s latest import taxes, which have plunged the North American neighbors deeper into a bitter trade war. Ottawa released a list of more than 700 targets Tuesday. Starting Sept. 8, Canada’s government […]

31 minutes ago

vision zero seattle katie wilson...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

Jake, Spike questions Vision Zero’s effectiveness: ‘No way to achieve zero if you still have cars and people in the same space’

As Vision Zero in Seattle turns more than a decade old, Mayor Katie Wilson signed an executive order Friday directing SDOT to accelerate priority safety projects.

34 minutes ago

Here’s what happened when this guy tried a Costco blind date