SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Dori: Puyallup crash shows we should not give licenses to 16-year-olds

Jul 31, 2019, 5:15 AM

Puyallup crash...

The scene of the Puyallup crash early Tuesday morning that left a 16-year-old dead. (Puyallup Police Department)

(Puyallup Police Department)

For those of you who have teenage kids, this every parent’s greatest nightmare. Your kids are out — you’re not quite sure where or with whom — and you hope they make good decisions. Then you get a call in the middle of the night.

If you’ve seen the photos of the Puyallup crash that police had to respond to early Tuesday morning, you know what I’m talking about. Parents got that call in the middle of the night; that their 16-year-old was dead. The three other teens were badly injured.

Here’s what we know about the crash. There were four people in the car and the 16-year-old was driving (if it was within the first six months of the teen getting his license, this was already illegal). Police found an empty bottle of Bacardi rum next to the vehicle. It was going at a very high rate of speed, left the road, and wrapped around a tree. It looks like the driver’s seat received the greatest impact. In the photo, the tree is where the driver would be sitting.

1 dead, 3 injured after violent crash into tree in Puyallup

As I was thinking about the nightmare of this Puyallup crash for these kids and their loved ones, I was reminded of a question I’ve asked many times before, as a former 16-year-old myself — why do we give 16-year-olds driver’s licenses?

I’ve only been involved in one car crash in my lifetime. It was my fault. It was when I was 16. And it was because I was being a moron. I was by myself, trying to go over a hill way over the speed limit so I could get that roller coaster feeling in my stomach. As I crested the hill, there was a car stopped right in front of me to make a left-hand turn. I went sliding into the back of that car. Nobody was hurt, but my car — which I had bought the day before my 16th birthday — was completely smashed.

When my girls got to their high school years, we stressed that they had better not have any passengers in their car until that six-month restriction was lifted. Otherwise, they would not have had a license or car until age 18. But then, you always have to hope and pray that your kids make good decisions not only about their own driving, but about whom they choose to get in a car with.

We hear from everyone in our society that we need to take guns away from 18, 19, and 20-year-olds because their brains are not sufficiently developed. But those same people want to lower the voting age to 16, and give the power of the vote to brains even more insufficiently developed. Why? What is the trade off for society?

It’s just a fact of the matter. The statistics are quite compelling that those are the ages when it’s most dangerous to be on the road. It’s not just because those are the newest, most inexperienced drivers. It’s because 16-year-olds can make horrible decisions. Even the good kids can make life-ending decisions. I know it’s a hassle for mom and dad because it would mean you have to pick up and drop off your kids for an extra couple of years. Of course, we’re never going to raise the driver’s license age to 18.

It’s heartbreaking. It’s absolutely heartbreaking when you see yet another story like the Puyallup crash. We continue to put these death machines in the hands of insufficiently-developed minds. And again, I was in that category myself.

des moines kill sunday...

Frank Sumrall

Man shot and killed in downtown Des Moines early Sunday, suspect at large

Police are looking for a shooting suspect who killed a man in downtown Des Moines early Sunday morning.

29 seconds ago

A worker waters plants on the North Lawn of the White House Monday, Sept. 21, 2026, in Washington. ...

Associated Press

The Latest: CNN, MS NOW and Politico say they’re suing over denied White House access

CNN, MS NOW and Politico say they’ve notified President Donald Trump’s administration that they’re filing a lawsuit over being denied White House access. Reporters from the three major news organizations were blocked from the White House on Saturday, a day after Trump said he was barring them because of reporting he found to be “fake […]

11 minutes ago

FILE - Former Vice President Kamala Harris speaks during the National Action Network Convention in ...

Associated Press

Kamala Harris launches into the 2026 midterms as her 2028 decision looms

As Kamala Harris mulls whether to run for president again, she’s throwing herself into the midterms by campaigning with fellow Democrats, starting with a Tuesday trip to Michigan on behalf of Senate nominee Abdul El-Sayed. It’s an especially notable destination for the former vice president. Michigan was one of seven battlegrounds she lost to Donald […]

11 minutes ago

burien gas station robbed...

Jake Chapman, KIRO 7 News

Burien gas station robbed 3 times in 3 weeks

The gas station owner, Atinder Dahb, said this is the third time the store has been targeted in three weeks.

15 minutes ago

Paul Peterman of National Association of Letter Carriers checks his notes as he canvasses on Saturd...

Associated Press

Republicans target Las Vegas congressional district with help from Trump’s ‘no tax on tips’ policy

LAS VEGAS (AP) — Susan Gonzalez plans to pay off her credit card now that she no longer needs to pay taxes on the dollar bills that she stashes away at the end of long shifts pouring beers and mixing cocktails in a smoky sports bar. Thanks to President Donald Trump, “there’s more money in […]

38 minutes ago

FILE - This image, contained in the indictment against former President Donald Trump, shows boxes o...

Associated Press

Trump’s ‘grand conspiracy’ probe presses on with subpoenas after the lead prosecutor’s exit

WASHINGTON (AP) — Before taking over the sprawling Justice Department investigation into foes of President Donald Trump, Joe diGenova decried the lack of progress in bringing indictments. Five months later, diGenova has left his position without charging a single case, clouding the future of an investigation that has animated right-wing commentators eager to prove an […]

1 hour ago

Dori: Puyallup crash shows we should not give licenses to 16-year-olds