SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Is Rush Limbaugh right about weather conspiracies?

Sep 11, 2017, 5:15 PM

Irma...

This photo shows a home destroyed by Hurricane Irma in Ponte Vedra Beach, Fla., Monday, Sept. 11, 2017. (Gary Lloyd McCullough/The Florida Times-Union via AP)

(Gary Lloyd McCullough/The Florida Times-Union via AP)

Rush Limbaugh took a lot of heat this week for calling out the media on how much they hype extreme weather like Hurricane Irma. He called it part of the Liberal agenda on climate change.

Then he looked at the radar from the National Weather Service and promptly evacuated his Florida compound.

So who was right? At least at the eye of the hurricane?

RELATED: In defense of meteorologist – don’t get mad at forecasts

As many of you know, my parents live in Naples, Florida. This is their 20th hurricane season down there, and they rarely evacuate. For Irma, it initially looked like it was going to hit Miami, so their plan was to stay put. By the time its path shifted west, all the shelters were packed, and it was too late for a couple in their 70s to risk the drive north.

I obsessed in front of the Weather Channel all weekend doing the mental calculations of what a 12-15 foot storm surge would look like in their neighborhood. I had lived through a 22-foot surge during Katrina, and it wiped the town of Bay St. Louis off the map.

But the surge from Irma never came. It wasn’t even close to 15 feet.

Was Rush Limbaugh right? Is there a weather conspiracy that caused hundreds of thousands of Floridians to buy gas and food and water and hotel rooms? Did the shadowy left wing elites win again?

Would it have been better if the media was like, “We usually get these wrong, so Florida, don’t worry about it. You’ll probably be OK.”

Weather professionals are really in a tough spot. They are speaking in probabilities and computer models. Do they hype up the possible catastrophic outcomes? Of course. That’s human nature looking at a computer telling you the worst thing possible. Would it be better if they painted a rosier picture? For me, there are several occupations that I want to have a dash of pessimism. Airplane pilots, surgeons, and weathermen. I don’t want to hear any of them say, “Seems like it’ll be OK.”

All you have to do is go 90 miles to the south of Florida to see the full wrath of Irma in Cuba and then continue to follow her wake through the Caribbean to see that this storm was a monster. Yes, the hurricane wasn’t as bad as predicted — in the US. But it killed and destroyed on the way here.

Does this mean there’s a bunch of climate change radicals sitting in a conference room somewhere eating bagels and high-fiving right now. I think not. This is one instance where they are glad to be wrong.

As my 70-something mother would say, “Better to be safe than sorry.”

 

A reporter photographs a display showing people accused of illegally voting during a news conferenc...

Associated Press

Justice Department urges sanctions for database analysis critical of its noncitizen voting claims

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Justice Department on Sunday defended the accuracy of a list of what it says are more than 20,000 suspected noncitizens registered to vote in California and suggested that a federal judge consider whether an immigrant rights group and its lawyers should face contempt charges after they published an analysis of the […]

6 hours ago

A sign explaining the restoration work at the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool is displayed on a fe...

Associated Press

Trump signals he’ll give closing election pitch at the Reflecting Pool, a revamp plagued by problems

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump signaled Sunday that he’ll make his closing pitch of the midterm elections at the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool, pushing his slow, expensive and problem-plagued efforts to repair it back into the spotlight as Election Day looms. In comments to reporters as he deplaned from Air Force One for a […]

8 hours ago

The aftermath of a suspected DUI crash on I-5 near the Kent/Des Moines exit Sunday morning. (Photo:...

Tom Brock

Another State Patrol Car Hit on I-5, Renewing Calls to ‘Move Over’

On Sunday morning, an officer was responding to a disabled, blocking vehicle on southbound I-5 near the Kent Des Moines Exit when a car slammed into his patrol car.

8 hours ago

Associated Press

Business jet carrying 9 people crashed in a Florida neighborhood, erupting in a massive fireball.

WEST PALM BEACH, Fla. (AP) — A business jet carrying 9 people crashed in a Florida neighborhood Sunday, erupting in a massive fireball. The Learjet 60 was carrying nine people when it crashed in a residential area in Florida’s Palm Beach County, federal officials said. The Bahamas-bound jet departed from Austin-Bergstrom International Airport in Texas, […]

8 hours ago

Michigan Republican Senate candidate Mike Rogers speaks alongside Rep. Haley Stevens, D-Mich., righ...

Associated Press

The Latest: Democrat who lost Michigan Senate primary backs Republican in general election contest

Michigan Democrat Abdul El-Sayed’s former opponent in the U.S. Senate primary, Haley Stevens, stunned party officials on Sunday by endorsing Republican Mike Rogers in the general election contest after Democratic tensions boiled over. The move came after Stevens was uninvited to a joint event the same day with El-Sayed as he campaigned for the Michigan […]

9 hours ago

Pickup trucks are submerged along Highway 160 in South Fork, Colo., on Friday, Oct. 23, 2026. (Sout...

Associated Press

Flash floods trigger evacuations in Arizona and Colorado amid heavy rains in southwest

SEDONA, Ariz. (AP) — Flash flooding prompted mandatory evacuation orders in parts of the Southwest on Sunday as heavy rains in the normally arid region have already brought deadly flooding this fall. Officials in the tourist destination of Sedona, Arizona, ordered residents in areas near Oak Creek to leave immediately as flood waters were rising […]

10 hours ago

Is Rush Limbaugh right about weather conspiracies?