SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Is Rush Limbaugh right about weather conspiracies?

Sep 11, 2017, 5:15 PM

Irma...

This photo shows a home destroyed by Hurricane Irma in Ponte Vedra Beach, Fla., Monday, Sept. 11, 2017. (Gary Lloyd McCullough/The Florida Times-Union via AP)

(Gary Lloyd McCullough/The Florida Times-Union via AP)

Rush Limbaugh took a lot of heat this week for calling out the media on how much they hype extreme weather like Hurricane Irma. He called it part of the Liberal agenda on climate change.

Then he looked at the radar from the National Weather Service and promptly evacuated his Florida compound.

So who was right? At least at the eye of the hurricane?

RELATED: In defense of meteorologist – don’t get mad at forecasts

As many of you know, my parents live in Naples, Florida. This is their 20th hurricane season down there, and they rarely evacuate. For Irma, it initially looked like it was going to hit Miami, so their plan was to stay put. By the time its path shifted west, all the shelters were packed, and it was too late for a couple in their 70s to risk the drive north.

I obsessed in front of the Weather Channel all weekend doing the mental calculations of what a 12-15 foot storm surge would look like in their neighborhood. I had lived through a 22-foot surge during Katrina, and it wiped the town of Bay St. Louis off the map.

But the surge from Irma never came. It wasn’t even close to 15 feet.

Was Rush Limbaugh right? Is there a weather conspiracy that caused hundreds of thousands of Floridians to buy gas and food and water and hotel rooms? Did the shadowy left wing elites win again?

Would it have been better if the media was like, “We usually get these wrong, so Florida, don’t worry about it. You’ll probably be OK.”

Weather professionals are really in a tough spot. They are speaking in probabilities and computer models. Do they hype up the possible catastrophic outcomes? Of course. That’s human nature looking at a computer telling you the worst thing possible. Would it be better if they painted a rosier picture? For me, there are several occupations that I want to have a dash of pessimism. Airplane pilots, surgeons, and weathermen. I don’t want to hear any of them say, “Seems like it’ll be OK.”

All you have to do is go 90 miles to the south of Florida to see the full wrath of Irma in Cuba and then continue to follow her wake through the Caribbean to see that this storm was a monster. Yes, the hurricane wasn’t as bad as predicted — in the US. But it killed and destroyed on the way here.

Does this mean there’s a bunch of climate change radicals sitting in a conference room somewhere eating bagels and high-fiving right now. I think not. This is one instance where they are glad to be wrong.

As my 70-something mother would say, “Better to be safe than sorry.”

 

Palau's President Surangel Whipps Jr. speaks during the 81st session of the United Nations General ...

Associated Press

‘We’re not giving up’: Beset by climate change, island nations act as conscience of a warming world

UNITED NATIONS (AP) — When Palau President Surangel Samuel Whipps Jr. recently took his children to his nation’s Helen Island, two-thirds of it was gone. Rising seas caused by climate change had swallowed generational burial grounds, washing away a people’s entire culture and identity. “For us, it’s devastating,” Whipps told The Associated Press on Friday, […]

2 hours ago

Chinese Vice President Han Zheng speaks during the 81st session of the United Nations General Assem...

Associated Press

China, as usual, uses UN speech to promote global development as solution to world’s challenges

NEW YORK (AP) — A day after his boss met with President Donald Trump in Washington, China’s vice president unfurled the nation’s familiar list of global talking points, emphasizing development, issuing mild statements about the U.S. war with Iran, artificial intelligence and protectionism, and making no direct mention of Taiwan. Han Zheng’s speech to the […]

2 hours ago

FILE - Michael Davis, of Bellwood, Ala., picks up a sign supporting Doug Jones for governor after a...

Associated Press

Southern Democrats see hope for first time in years, seek to build on discontent of midterm voters

DOTHAN, Ala. (AP) — People crowded shoulder to shoulder upstairs in a south Alabama coffee shop, in a region sometimes called the reddest in the heavily conservative state. They were there to hear Doug Jones, the Democratic nominee for governor and the last Democrat to hold statewide office in Alabama. “Alabama has been under Republican […]

5 hours ago

Associated Press

Roads flood in New Jersey, inundate some homes, as major signs of nor’easter take shape

PROVIDENCE, R.I. (AP) — More than 70,000 customers were without electricity in the U.S. Northeast on Saturday, the sign of a powerful nor’easter expected to create dangerous conditions through the weekend. Forecasters warned of gale winds that could down trees and heavy inundations that could put roads underwater. Tens of millions of people are in […]

5 hours ago

House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, D-N.Y., talks about the policies of President Donald Trump a...

Associated Press

House Democrats plan vast oversight of Trump administration. Impeachment is an option

WASHINGTON (AP) — House Democrats are preparing a vast oversight agenda, with investigations of President Donald Trump, his family and his administration if the party sweeps control of the chamber from Republicans in the November elections. The undertaking is a robust as it is daunting, spanning several House committees. With majority power comes bigger budgets […]

5 hours ago

seattle police response times...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘We’re chasing our tail’: KIRO hosts warn Seattle’s 911 response times reveal a problem no new chief can fix alone

Seattle's police response times raise concerns with KIRO hosts as they warn no chief can solve this issue alone.

5 hours ago

Is Rush Limbaugh right about weather conspiracies?