SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

This is what a real American memorial actually looks like

Sep 5, 2017, 1:15 PM | Updated: 9:53 pm

There’s been a lot of talk about memorials in the news lately. Protests and torches and heritage and murder. This tumult has centered mostly around civil war era statues of fallen heroes on horseback. I’ve been confused and I’ve been angry, but I haven’t cried.

RELATED: The upside to living in perpetual rage

This Labor Day Weekend I went to a memorial that made me cry, and it reminded me that the the purpose of remembering is to inspire, not anger. It was at the 911 Memorial in New York City. I went out for the holiday weekend, and the 911 Memorial was the first thing on my list.

Now, I’m not an easy crier. I’ve never cried at a museum before, but I’ll try and put my finger on what happened about 100 feet below street level at Ground Zero. I think it was a mixture of the mood of America right now, and the raw emotion of that place that all came together for me.

To start out, the design of the memorial is genius. You begin above ground at the footprint of the twin towers. Where the skyscrapers stood, now there are matching water features. A giant square hole in the earth that marks where the tower stood with a continuous rush of water over the rim. The water collects in a smaller square drain in the middle. Around the perimeter is a laser etched metal band with names. Lots and lots of names. Since we’re only a few days from the anniversary, family members and friends were placing tiny American flags and other mementos on the name of their loved one. A tiny sign under said, “you are invited to touch the names.”

I was a bit early and the museum wasn’t open yet. After walking around the two water features, I went inside and started to descend into the memorial. All the exhibits are under ground. New York City is loud and busy and overwhelming, so to get you to slow down and focus, the architect funnels people down a low slug dark hallway about 100 yards long. The only source of light are projections of words and you hear a thousand voices describing where they were on September 11th. You can barely see, and by the time you reach the end of this hallway, you are in a different mindset.

That hall of voices opens up into a giant cavern where a 53 ton steel pillar stands. You overlook it from above and you can see the numbers 343, 23, and 37. The spray painted tallies of first responders that died going in while everyone else was going out. But that’s not when I cried.

I went down further, past the crushed fire trucks, past the last staircase, past the exhibit from when they built the original buildings.

I turned another dark corner, this time after the section about the terrorists, and I was face-to-face with a wall of handmade fliers.

People desperately searching for their husband or their daughter or their wife or their child. It was overwhelming. But I still didn’t cry, not yet.

I walked a few feet more, and I started to hear the voicemails. That’s when the tears flowed.

It felt good to cry because it wasn’t out of anger. It wasn’t about trying to keep people out or strip away rights. In that memorial, deep under ground, I felt included. These people that died are my family; they are fellow Americans. Even the ones that look different than me.

Memorials should make us remember the best about ourselves. They should inspire us to do better. They should make us cry.

A reporter photographs a display showing people accused of illegally voting during a news conferenc...

Associated Press

Justice Department urges sanctions for database analysis critical of its noncitizen voting claims

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Justice Department on Sunday defended the accuracy of a list of what it says are more than 20,000 suspected noncitizens registered to vote in California and suggested that a federal judge consider whether an immigrant rights group and its lawyers should face contempt charges after they published an analysis of the […]

6 hours ago

A sign explaining the restoration work at the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool is displayed on a fe...

Associated Press

Trump signals he’ll give closing election pitch at the Reflecting Pool, a revamp plagued by problems

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump signaled Sunday that he’ll make his closing pitch of the midterm elections at the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool, pushing his slow, expensive and problem-plagued efforts to repair it back into the spotlight as Election Day looms. In comments to reporters as he deplaned from Air Force One for a […]

8 hours ago

The aftermath of a suspected DUI crash on I-5 near the Kent/Des Moines exit Sunday morning. (Photo:...

Tom Brock

Another State Patrol Car Hit on I-5, Renewing Calls to ‘Move Over’

On Sunday morning, an officer was responding to a disabled, blocking vehicle on southbound I-5 near the Kent Des Moines Exit when a car slammed into his patrol car.

8 hours ago

Associated Press

Business jet carrying 9 people crashed in a Florida neighborhood, erupting in a massive fireball.

WEST PALM BEACH, Fla. (AP) — A business jet carrying 9 people crashed in a Florida neighborhood Sunday, erupting in a massive fireball. The Learjet 60 was carrying nine people when it crashed in a residential area in Florida’s Palm Beach County, federal officials said. The Bahamas-bound jet departed from Austin-Bergstrom International Airport in Texas, […]

8 hours ago

Michigan Republican Senate candidate Mike Rogers speaks alongside Rep. Haley Stevens, D-Mich., righ...

Associated Press

The Latest: Democrat who lost Michigan Senate primary backs Republican in general election contest

Michigan Democrat Abdul El-Sayed’s former opponent in the U.S. Senate primary, Haley Stevens, stunned party officials on Sunday by endorsing Republican Mike Rogers in the general election contest after Democratic tensions boiled over. The move came after Stevens was uninvited to a joint event the same day with El-Sayed as he campaigned for the Michigan […]

9 hours ago

Pickup trucks are submerged along Highway 160 in South Fork, Colo., on Friday, Oct. 23, 2026. (Sout...

Associated Press

Flash floods trigger evacuations in Arizona and Colorado amid heavy rains in southwest

SEDONA, Ariz. (AP) — Flash flooding prompted mandatory evacuation orders in parts of the Southwest on Sunday as heavy rains in the normally arid region have already brought deadly flooding this fall. Officials in the tourist destination of Sedona, Arizona, ordered residents in areas near Oak Creek to leave immediately as flood waters were rising […]

10 hours ago

This is what a real American memorial actually looks like