SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

‘Rogue One’ is a rip-roaring ride but doesn’t offer anything new

Dec 16, 2016, 9:13 AM | Updated: 3:11 pm

“Rogue One: A Star Wars Story,” was supposed to be a bit different as the very first Star Wars stand-alone movie. Sure, it takes place in the Star Wars universe, but it’s the first film not part of the Star Wars canon. That means we get entirely new characters, new story lines, even new planets. No one in the family trees of Luke Skywalker, or Han Solo, or Princess Leia or Obi-Wan Kenobi need apply. “Rogue One” is basically virgin territory for the imaginations of Star Wars storytellers.

And yet, this galactic spin-off seems so awfully familiar, it can’t help but be a little disappointing.

“Fantastic Beasts” manages to be mostly fun and charming

Don’t get me wrong. It’s all very well done and a worthy installment in the Star Wars series. But for those looking for a somewhat fresh take on this far, far away galaxy, you’ll have to look elsewhere. “Rogue One” may not be an entry in the official Star Wars canon, but it might as well be. Star Wars’ gravitational pull is so strong that this spin-off stays in very close orbit.

As in the most recent Star Wars film, our hero is a heroine, Jyn Erso, played winningly by Felicity Jones. Her father Galen abandoned her as a youngster so he could work on the Empire’s ultimate weapon, the Death Star. Left to fend for herself, she turned to a life of petty crime which ultimately landed her in prison. When the rebels suddenly break her out of prison, her life changes dramatically. The rebels have a mission for her.

The rebels know the Empire is up to something. They’ve heard rumors about a new weapon. Her mission is to steal the design plans of the Death Star. Despite a series of setbacks, Jyn remains undaunted. And over time, this once reluctant rebel becomes the most rebellious of them all.

The bulk of the film is then made up of virtually non-stop battle scenes, in the air, on land, and inside Empire headquarters. This movie really puts the “wars” in Star Wars. And this is all very familiar territory for Star Wars fans, what with all those iconic Stormtroopers, the out-manned but scrappy rebels, the aerial dogfights, the blasters and light sabers, and of course, the Force.

Jyn and her merry band of rebels include a blind monk-like seer who constantly preaches “Follow the Force and the Force will protect you,” shades of the Jedi Masters. She’s also teamed up with a wise-crackin’ robot named K-2SO, who’s like a tougher version of C-3PO.

Clearly these are tips of the hat to its Star Wars predecessors and there are countless more. Jyn even has major father issues similar to Luke Skywalker’s. That’s all well and good, up to a point.

But if “Rogue One” wants to put its stamp on the franchise, to somehow alter or even just shade the way we see the Star Wars world, it fails. At times, the movie seems to be yearning for an emotional power that has always been beyond the reach of Star Wars movies. I appreciate the yearning but it remains a bridge too far for “Rogue One” as well.

But it’s still a rip-roaring good time for fans.

Britain's Prime Minister Andy Burnham and his wife Marie-France van Heel board a plane for the Unit...

Associated Press

Andy Burnham seeks common ground with Trump at the UN and pitches the UK as a major AI player

NEW YORK (AP) — British Prime Minister Andy Burnham faces a double test on the world stage Tuesday when he meets U.S. President Donald Trump for the first time and addresses the United Nations General Assembly. It’s a baptism of fire for the neophyte leader, who has gone from mayor of the northwest England city […]

26 minutes ago

A general view of Nuuk, Greenland, Sunday, Sept. 6, 2026. (Mads Claus Rasmussen/Ritzau Scanpix via ...

Associated Press

A timeline of US President Donald Trump’s interest in Greenland

President Donald Trump’s interest in a U.S. acquisition of Greenland, a semiautonomous territory of NATO ally Denmark, first became publicly known in 2019. Here’s a timeline of events that led to a crisis between Washington and its European allies. Aug., 2019: During his first term, Trump expresses interest in buying Greenland for the U.S., but […]

3 hours ago

The flag of the United Nations flies during the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) at the UN he...

Associated Press

Messy, troubled, unpredictable: Diplomats describe a world in turmoil as UN opens annual meeting

UNITED NATIONS (AP) — There is not much that diplomats can agree on these days. But if asked about the state of the world ahead of the annual meeting at the U.N. General Assembly, heads of state and government and ministers alike will describe a globe in massive turmoil. With two escalating wars raging in […]

4 hours ago

FILE - President Donald Trump gestures as he addresses the 80th session of the United Nations Gener...

Associated Press

Trump returns to UN at a moment of anxiety about Iran, AI and the future of world body itself

NEW YORK (AP) — President Donald Trump is set to address the U.N. General Assembly on Tuesday at a tumultuous moment for the world — and for his presidency. The global economy has been shaken by his decision to launch a war against Iran. Anxiety about the social impact being wrought by artificial intelligence is […]

4 hours ago

Currency traders work near a screen showing the Korea Composite Stock Price Index (KOSPI) and the f...

Associated Press

Asian benchmarks mostly rise after Wall Street’s rally

TOKYO (AP) — Asian shares mostly rose early Tuesday, as the market mood turned positive from the overnight rally on Wall Street. Australia’s S&P/ASX 200 added 02% in early trading to 8,748.20. South Korea’s Kospi jumped 1.6% to 7,120.25. Hong Kong’s Hang Seng gained nearly 0.6% to 25,185.26, while the Shanghai Composite rose 0.4% to […]

5 hours ago

landlord...

John Curley Show

‘Where’s the emergency for the landlord?’: Curley questions Spokane’s new rent ordinance after fire

KIRO host John Curley had a question after the Spokane City Council passed a new tenant protection ordinance. What about the landlords?

7 hours ago

‘Rogue One’ is a rip-roaring ride but doesn’t offer anything new