SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Talking about ‘what movie critics won’t tell you’

Jun 5, 2013, 6:17 AM | Updated: 11:41 am

Critics may like Tarantino more than average moviegoers because he’s willing to subvert, brea...

Critics may like Tarantino more than average moviegoers because he's willing to subvert, break up, or even overthrow many movie conventions.

People love to bash critics. The Wall Street Journal came up with a list of 10 things movie critics won’t tell you, and it quickly became the most popular article on their website.

Like any list, this one is highly subjective but since critics put together Top Ten lists that are equally subjective, what’s good for the goose is good for the gander.

Here are some highlights.

1.) We’re not as powerful as we once were
Duh. With the passing of Roger Ebert, lots of people weighed in that the era of powerful individual critics is over. But that era had already long passed. (Pauline Kael may have single-handedly saved “Blue Velvet,” as Kyle MacLachlan suggested the other night but that just doesn’t happen anymore.)

The great thing about the Internet is it freed up access to hundreds of other critics’ views, not just your local critic and the handful of national critics who wrote for magazines.

Although it does nothing for the state of critical thinking, aggregation sites like Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic help create a persuasive critical consensus that no single critic could ensure alone. Collecting a couple hundred reviews and quantifying them may be crude but it’s an effective barometer nonetheless.

2.) We’re not exactly in tune with the public’s taste
Duh again. It’s not our job to reflect the tastes of the masses. Never has been and never will be. That being said, except for movies like “Transformers” and “The Fast and the Furious” series, there’s a lot closer correlation between box office hits and critical hits than you might think. For instance, the Rotten Tomatoes critics gave the new “Star Trek” movie a score of 87 out of 100 and the Will Smith debacle “After Earth,” only a 12. That corresponds pretty closely with the respective box office receipts.

Jumping ahead…

8.) It’s gotten so bad, we actually prefer television to most movies
This is a little misleading, but it contains a kernel of truth. I’d say, we actually prefer great television to most movies. Cable series like “The Sopranos” and “The Wire,” “Dexter” and “Game of Thrones,” even “Girls” and “Veep,” are better than most movies. But all in all, the percentage of good to bad on television is probably no higher than that of good to bad movies. And I still think a great movie tops a great TV show, but I admit it’s close, and getting closer.

And finally, the last thing movie critics won’t tell you is:

When all else fails, we turn to Tarantino
This made me laugh, because it’s certainly true for me. I find Quentin Tarantino to be one of world’s most exciting filmmakers, even though his movies are often wildly uneven in tone, lazily plotted, and chock full of violence and arch dialogue. Critics may like Tarantino more than average moviegoers because he’s willing to subvert, break up, or even overthrow many movie conventions. Since critics tend to see hundreds of movies, they, more than most people, prize innovation. And Tarantino is nothing if not innovative.

That being said, Tarantino has had remarkable box office success. His last two films, “Django Unchained” and “Inglorious Basterds” grossed almost $750 million worldwide – that can’t be all critics.

Seattle News Archives & Features

Fire crews respond to a helicopter hard landing after the aircraft's engine reportedly lost power n...

Tom Brock

Two aircraft emergencies in Pierce County Saturday

Two aircraft emergencies in Pierce County Saturday resulted in injuries to one pilot. 

12 days ago

This NOAA satellite image shows the magnitude of the storm moving inland from the Pacific Ocean. (P...

Ted Buehner, KIRO Newsradio Meteorologist

What to expect as Western Washington’s first big fall storm arrives Saturday night

The fall season’s first strong weather system will sweep through Western Washington tonight, bringing strong winds and rain.

12 days ago

Associated Press

3 dead, including suspect, and 2 deputies critically injured in eastern Washington state

SPOKANE COUNTY, Wash. (AP) — A shooting and subsequent firefight with responding officers left three people dead, including the suspect, and two deputies critically wounded in eastern Washington state Tuesday. Deputies responded to a home in Spokane County, which borders Idaho, around 2:30 p.m. after a woman told her neighbor that she had been shot […]

16 days ago

Sedro-Woolley medications missing...

KIRO 7 News Staff

Student medications found missing or diluted at Sedro-Woolley schools

Students’ medications are missing or diluted at multiple schools across the Sedro-Woolley School District, according to a district statement.

30 days ago

In this photo taken with a smartphone, Mike Herrington, the FBI special agent in charge, speaks to ...

Associated Press

Washington resident charged with conspiracy in Canada shool shooting is ordered detained

SEATTLE (AP) — A Washington state resident charged with conspiracy in one of the worst school shootings in Canada’s history has been ordered detained pending further hearings in the case. Melody Bryant, also known as James Cody Bryant, of Bellingham, Washington, was charged this month with conspiring to murder people in a foreign country. Investigators […]

1 month ago

The location of the Vertical Evacuation Tower will be near the Westport Marina. It will be the thir...

Tom Brock

Rising above the risk: Westport breaks ground on Washington’s newest tsunami refuge

The city of Westport broke ground Saturday on what will become Washington state's latest tsunami-safe location: a new vertical evacuation tower.

2 months ago

Talking about ‘what movie critics won’t tell you’