SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

The New York Times slimes Hanukkah

Dec 14, 2018, 12:17 PM

Hannukah...

(Flickr Creative Commons)

(Flickr Creative Commons)

The New York Times recently challenged its Jewish readers by featuring a provocative, but deeply misguided column titled, “The Hypocrisy of Hanukkah.”

In it, novelist Michael David Lukas trashed our joyous winter festival as “an eight-night long celebration of religious fundamentalism and violence.”

The writer identified himself with the “Hellenized Jews” in the second century B.C., who rejected the faith of their ancestors and defiled the Jerusalem Temple with the worship of Greek gods — usty deities who demanded ethical behavior from neither themselves nor from humanity.

It’s not fundamentalism to cherish ancient traditions and holy ordinances, and it wasn’t “violence” to cleanse and rededicate the Temple and ourselves.

The word Hanukkah derives from Hebrew for “dedication”, and it also connects to the word “Chinuch,” or education. The derisive author who slammed “the hypocrisy of Hannukah” might benefit, like the rest of us, from re-dedication and education.

Associated Press

Texas city council candidate who protested ICE shooting faces ‘riot participation’ charge

AUSTIN, Texas (AP) — A Texas city council candidate was arrested Saturday morning on a misdemeanor charge for “riot participation,” a week after he was part of a protest against the shooting of a Venezuelan man by a federal immigration officer. Public jail records do not specify the date of Misael Ramos’ alleged rioting, but […]

2 hours ago

Foreign Minister Abdul Mateen of Brunei speaks during the 81st session of the United Nations Genera...

Associated Press

They said it: Leaders at the UN, in their own words

UNITED NATIONS (AP) — Many leaders saying many things about many topics that matter to them, to their regions, to the world: That’s what the U.N. General Assembly invariably produces each year. And each year, certain voices dominate. Here, The Associated Press takes the opposite approach and spotlights some thoughts from leaders who might have […]

3 hours ago

Associated Press

Hurricane Nolo expected to unleash powerful winds, flash flooding on Hawaii

HILO, Hawaii (AP) — Heavy rain and powerful winds are expected to bring flash floods and extreme surf to the Hawaiian Islands over the weekend as Hurricane Nolo bears down on areas still recovering from previous storms. Nolo was churning slowly south of Hawaii’s Big Island on Saturday with maximum sustained winds of 105 mph […]

5 hours ago

A "Do Not Enter" sign is pictured on the fence at the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Art...

Associated Press

Kennedy Center put off planned repairs despite known structural issues, former employees allege

Kennedy Center officials were long aware of serious structural issues that they cited as new problems after the abrupt decision to close the performing arts venue this month, a group of former employees allege in a letter to Congress. The center’s executive director and chief operating officer, Matt Floca, did not treat the roofing issues […]

6 hours ago

Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov of Russia speaks during the 81st session of the United Nations Gener...

Associated Press

German, Russian foreign ministers have rare meeting at UN

UNITED NATIONS (AP) — The German and Russian foreign ministers met Saturday on the sidelines of the U.N. General Assembly, holding what’s believed to be the first such tête-à-tête since Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022. The meeting came as tensions between the European Union and Russia rose — and just before Russian Foreign […]

6 hours ago

President Donald Trump disembarks Air Force one at McGhee Tyson Airport, Saturday, Sept. 26, 2026, ...

Associated Press

CNN says it was left off Air Force One for Trump’s Saturday trip to a college football game

The White House left CNN off Air Force One for President Donald Trump’s trip Saturday to a college football game in Tennessee, marking the latest media restriction from the administration in an ongoing dispute with First Amendment implications. CNN, a member of the U.S. network video pool that rotates duties shooting and sharing video coverage […]

7 hours ago

The New York Times slimes Hanukkah