SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Here’s what happened when this guy tried a Costco blind date

Oct 7, 2016, 9:16 AM | Updated: 11:45 am

Costco blind date...

Susan and David Barrow celebrated their two year anniversary much in the same way they first met, in front of mustard in Costco. (Contributed)

(Contributed)

It was a match made in Costco. Susan and David Barrow celebrated their two year anniversary much in the same way they first met — with mustard.

“We met in Costco in the mustard aisle,” Susan told KIRO Radio’s Dori Monson. “It was the Kirkland Costco, aisle 38.”

Why Seattle women are such big drinkers — men

That was in March 2014. It was a Costco blind date. The mustard-themed meeting was a good blend. The pair were married six months later.

So this month, the couple decided to celebrate their wedding anniversary by touring Costcos in the area dressed up as Mr. and Mrs. Mustard. Their tour made the news. Susan said that there has been so much depressing news lately, she wanted to do something fun.

A Costco blind date

David got Susan’s phone number from a friend and the two started chatting on the phone. They hit it off. So David decided to take it to the next level.

“I wanted to ask her out on a date, but I wanted it to be very normal … so I invited her out to Costco,” he said. “I think she thought I was a bit crazy.”

She didn’t think he was crazy.

“I thought he was either really cheap,” Susan said. “Or, because I’m a single mom, maybe he was going to fill a basket and bless me with a whole bunch of food.”

“I got neither of them,” she noted. “I got free samples, though.”

Susan headed into the blind date with an open mind. She didn’t know what the guy on the phone looked like, though David had her business card with her photo on it.

“I’m waiting there by the mustard and anytime someone came down, I was like, ‘Is this him, is this him?’” Susan said. “There was this lovely lady named Doris having a difficult time deciding if she wanted to buy mayonnaise or not. And she was distracting me, and I was like, ‘Listen, lady, I don’t have time to talk with you right now because this could be the date of my life.’ He turned the corner then, with a smile, and I figured that was him.”

“In person, she was much prettier than her business card,” David added. “I asked Doris to take a picture of us. That was the beginning of us becoming Mr. and Mrs. Mustard. The mustard was in the background. We walked around getting free samples and talking.”

As it turns out, Costco was a good date idea, but David did make one misstep that day — forgot to buy Susan the hot dog he promised her. On their anniversary, he fixed that. The two ate a hot dog together, starting at each end and meeting in the middle.

seattle mariners dan wilson game 7...

Charlie Harger

Harger: Dan Wilson gave Seattle a Game 7. The Mariners should give him back a microphone

From the low of a Seahawks loss to the bittersweet high of Rick Rizzs saying "goodbye baseball" to the low again of a shaken Dan Wilson, sitting behind a table at a press conference, confirming what the whole town saw coming: He's out as Mariners manager.

2 minutes ago

rain fall sunshine...

Ted Buehner

Up to an inch of rain Tuesday before fall sunshine returns to western Washington

The fall season’s first rainfall occurred last week. After a weekend of sunshine, another Pacific weather system is forecast to swing onshore Tuesday for more rain.

41 minutes ago

tacoma drug dealing sleeping car...

KIRO 7 News Staff

Two men suspected of drug dealing arrested in Tacoma, found sleeping in car

Two men, found sleeping in a car, were arrested for suspected drug dealing earlier this month in Tacoma.

60 minutes ago

kurt cobain olympia airbnb...

KIRO 7 News Staff

Kurt Cobain’s Olympia apartment transformed into Airbnb

Nirvana fans can now spend the night in one place Kurt Cobain called home, as Cobain’s Olympia apartment is now available to book on Airbnb.

1 hour ago

tacoma officer-involved shooting...

Frank Sumrall

Tacoma officer-involved shooting kills man during domestic assault response Sunday

A deadly officer-involved shooting that happened in Tacoma on Sunday is under investigation.

1 hour ago

FILE - A view of the construction site of the new U.S. Consulate in Milan, Italy, on June 8, 2026. ...

Associated Press

US construction giant agrees to a $35 million settlement for workers building the Milan consulate

MILAN (AP) — The U.S. company building the new American consulate in Milan has agreed to a nearly 31-million-euro ($35 million) settlement that includes back pay and damages to foreign workers who prosecutors allege were paid less than $2 an hour, officials said Monday. The settlement was signed by the Milan prosecutors, Alabama-based multinational Caddell […]

2 hours ago

Here’s what happened when this guy tried a Costco blind date