MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Boeing counters EU’s claim of landmark victory in tax battle

Nov 28, 2016, 9:26 AM | Updated: 9:27 am

A World Trade Organization panel ruled a state tax break Washington offered to Boeing is a “prohibited” subsidy.

The state extended the business tax reduction to Boeing in 2013 to ensure production of the 777x plane would stay local. The decision found the state promised to give Boeing the prohibited subsidies from 2024-2040.

Trump: Why Boeing will leave, or stay, in Washington

Prohibited is the WTO’s strictest legal category, and indicates a subsidy that can’t be allowed to stand. If the ruling is upheld on appeal, action would be taken to remove the subsidy, the Associated Press reports.

The European Union says the subsidies would have amounted to $8.7 billion, according to the Associated Press. EU Trade Commissioner Cecila Malmstrom told the AP the panel ruled against $5.7 billion of the measures.

The European Union is claiming this as a victory in a battle between Boeing and its rival, Airbus.

Malmstrom said the ruling “an important victory for the EU and its aircraft industry,” AP reports.

But Boeing says otherwise.

A statement from Boeing says the WTO panel rejected “virtually all of the European Union’s challenges to the Washington state tax incentives.” WTO, according to Boeing, rejected the challenge to six of seven incentives and “most of the challenge to the seventh.”

“The WTO held only and narrowly that a reduction in Washington state’s Business and Occupancy (B&O) tax rate for future 777X revenues is inconsistent with the WTO agreements,” the statement reads. “The WTO threw out all of the EU’s other challenges to various incentive programs and left untouched even the B&O tax rate as it applies to revenue from the other Boeing models produced in Washington state–the 737, 747, 767, 777 (current model) and 787.”

The entire statement from Boeing can be read below.

The World Trade Organization (WTO) today rejected virtually all of the European Union’s challenges to the Washington state tax incentives.

In today’s case, the EU challenged seven different state tax incentives. The WTO rejected entirely the EU’s challenge to six of the seven incentives and rejected most of the challenge to the seventh. The WTO held only and narrowly that a reduction in Washington state’s Business and Occupancy (B&O) tax rate for future 777X revenues is inconsistent with the WTO agreements. The WTO threw out all of the EU’s other challenges to various incentive programs and left untouched even the B&O tax rate as it applies to revenue from the other Boeing models produced in Washington state–the 737, 747, 767, 777 (current model) and 787.

In total, the EU claimed that Boeing had received $8.7 billion in subsidies. This claim was rejected by the WTO, which found future incentives totaling no more than $50 million a year to be impermissible. The WTO found that to date Boeing has received no benefit from the 777X rate incentive, and will not until 2020 because the first airplane will not be delivered until then.

“Today’s decision is a complete victory for the United States, Washington State, and Boeing,” said J. Michael Luttig, Boeing’s general counsel. “The WTO found in September that Airbus has received $22 billion in illegal subsidies from the EU and that without these subsidies neither Airbus itself nor any of its airplanes would even exist today. By contrast, in rejecting virtually every claim made by the EU in this case, the WTO found today that Boeing has not received a penny of impermissible subsidies.”

“The WTO has repeatedly found that Airbus is entirely a creature of government, and they must now bring themselves into compliance with the international laws or risk massive sanctions,” said Luttig.

In light of today’s decision and the massive liability that the WTO has found against the EU and Airbus, we expect the EU and Airbus to appeal today’s decision. “After any appeal,” Luttig said, “we fully expect Boeing to preserve every aspect of the Washington state incentives, including the 777X revenue tax rate.”

MyNorthwest News

seattle DUI crash officers...

MyNorthwest Staff

2 Seattle officers collide while searching for suspected DUI driver who fled traffic response

Two Seattle police officers collided with each other at low speed while searching for a suspected DUI driver who fled near Beacon Hill early Friday morning.

1 hour ago

Seattle restaurant james beard...

Jason Sutich

Rising costs prompt James Beard nominee to rethink Seattle restaurant months after recognition

The owner of Café Suliman in Capitol Hill announced he will close his restaurant after three years, with plans to open a new concept in the same space.

2 hours ago

olympia jungle encampment...

Heather Bosch, KIRO 7 News

City of Olympia clears ‘The Jungle’ encampment; 286 people need housing

The city of Olympia is in the middle of a massive clean-up at a 20-acre encampment. At the same time, they’re trying to find housing for the camp’s nearly 300 residents.

2 hours ago

KIRO Newsradio app idea...

Charlie Harger

Harger: My trillion-dollar idea for the KIRO Newsradio app

Explore Charlie Harger's innovative vision for the KIRO Newsradio app and how it could reshape your listening and gaming experience.

4 hours ago

bellevue bear shot...

JAKE CHAPMAN, KIRO 7

Man who shot at bear on his lawn in Bellevue claims it was self-defense

A man who shot at a bear in Bellevue’s Lakemont neighborhood told police he fired in self-defense, according to authorities.

5 hours ago

Kittitas county goat infection...

Aaron Taylor, KIRO 7 News

Kittitas County officials ask public to help find goat carrying contagious infection

Kittitas County is asking for the public’s help locating a missing goat that may carry a contagious viral infection capable of spreading to other goats.

5 hours ago

Boeing counters EU’s claim of landmark victory in tax battle