Burgess accuses Seattle City Council of having ‘optimism bias,’ but is not ‘shady’

Mar 16, 2016, 10:45 AM | Updated: 2:57 pm

Seattle City Council member Tim Burgess argues that proposed changes to the city's ethics code woul...

Seattle City Council member Tim Burgess argues that proposed changes to the city's ethics code would weaken accountability at the city level. (Seattle Channel)

(Seattle Channel)

There aren’t too many topics that KIRO Radio’s Dori Monson and Seattle City Councilmember Tim Burgess agree on. But count the Pronto bike share as one of them.

Burgess was one of two people who voted against rescuing Seattle’s bike-share program and called out his peers for falling for biased testimony.

Burgess says he and the rest of the council heard anecdotal stories on the value of bicycles. However, those stories don’t justify the city spending $1.4 million on Pronto! in addition to the $305,000 it already spent to keep it alive until the vote.

“Frankly, there is a lot of ‘optimism bias,’ the term economists use to describe judgments people make even when the facts suggest otherwise,” Burgess wrote in an email to constituents.

Related: City Council approves Pronto! bike-share system bailout

And Burgess says he voted “no” for more than one reason. In addition to feeling like the council was making decisions based on biased opinions, he says he is frustrated that the Seattle Department of Transportation failed to tell the council Pronto! was in financial trouble until months later, when it suggested rescuing the program.

“After receiving the rescue proposal, the council considered it incomplete, lacking the kind of financial rigor we would expect,” Burgess wrote. “We imposed a budget restriction, called a proviso, which prohibited spending money on the rescue until a business plan was presented. One month later, in December 2015, SDOT sent $305,000 to Pronto to pay operating costs, a violation of the spirit and intent of the council budget proviso. This payment was not disclosed to the council until February of this year.”

Burgess says the lack of transparency and the violation of the budget directives are “significant.”

“On both the substance of this proposal and the process by which it was pursued, the city fell short of the standard we should set for ourselves,” Burgess wrote. “I am disappointed in the final outcome, but I will continue to work with my colleagues to ensure that we invest wisely in our transportation infrastructure.”

Burgess was joined by council member Lisa Herbold in the opposition vote. The council approved the bailout by a 7-2 margin, and this time it looks like the vote was counted correctly.

Dori has been vocal about his opposition to the project and Burgess told him Wednesday that the council received hundreds of emails about Pronto! with about 98 percent asking for a “no” vote. He noted that many of the writers were avid cyclists, just like Dori.

However, while Dori describes the connections between the Seattle Department of Transportaion Director and the company that runs the bike share systems as “shady,” Burgess wouldn’t bite.

“I’ve certainly seen no evidence to indicate that, so I would not agree with you there,” he said. “I think that there is a very passionate advocacy in our city for a wide variety of transportation choices and a majority of my colleagues felt that, while there is risk here, it is a worthy effort to make sure that we have a very diverse transportation system. I just disagreed with them on this specific issue.”

train kills person puyallup...

Bill Kaczaraba

Train hits, kills person in Puyallup Wednesday morning

A person was hit and killed on the train tracks in Puyallup Wednesday morning, according to a report from authorities.

1 year ago

Work continues to shore up areas at Seacliff State Beach against further damage, Friday, Jan. 13, 2...

Associated Press

California gets more rain and snow, but dry days are ahead

LOS ANGELES (AP) — More rain and snow fell during the weekend in storm-battered California, making travel dangerous and prompting evacuation warnings over flooding concerns along a swollen river near Sacramento. Bands of gusty thunderstorms started Saturday in the north and spread south, with yet another atmospheric river storm following close behind Sunday, the National […]

1 year ago

Spanaway woman shot dead...

Kate Stone

Search for shooter continues after woman shot dead while driving in Spanaway

A 47-year-old woman was shot dead in Spanaway, causing her to hit another driver head-on early Wednesday morning.

23 minutes ago

Associated Press

Barges are bringing cranes to Baltimore to help remove bridge wreckage and open shipping route

BALTIMORE (AP) — Massive barges carrying cranes streamed toward Baltimore on Thursday to begin the challenging work of removing twisted metal and concrete in an attempt to open a key shipping route blocked by the wreckage of the Francis Scott Key Bridge. U.S. Coast Guard officials said Wednesday night that the barges were on their […]

34 minutes ago

Associated Press

Russia vetoes UN resolution, abolishing monitoring of UN sanctions against North Korea by UN experts

UNITED NATIONS (AP) — Russia vetoed a U.N. resolution on Thursday, effectively abolishing the monitoring of U.N. sanctions against North Korea by a panel of U.N. experts. The Security Council resolution sponsored by the United States would have extended the mandate of the panel for a year, but Russia’s veto will halt its operations. The […]

37 minutes ago

nintendo redmond...

Frank Sumrall

Nintendo to lay off 86 Redmond employees this spring

Nintendo of America is laying off 86 contract workers in Redmond, beginning May 25, due to company reorganization.

1 hour ago

I-5 overpass 145th seattle...

Chris Sullivan

Sullivan: I-5 overpass at 145th in Seattle to close

The North 145th Street overpass of I-5, right there at the new light rail station, is about to close for seven months.

2 hours ago

opening day baseball...

Paul Holden

Paul Holden: Opening Day reminds us why we love baseball so much

I spoke with baseball writer Joe Posnanski ahead of Opening Day and asked one simple question: Why do we love baseball?

2 hours ago

Burgess accuses Seattle City Council of having ‘optimism bias,’ but is not ‘shady’