JASON RANTZ

You won’t believe this shockingly disingenuous housing affordability study

Jun 3, 2015, 12:30 PM | Updated: 1:30 pm

affordability , Puget Sound...

More people than ever are concerned with the central Puget Sound region's affordability problem. (File, Associated Press)

(File, Associated Press)

In this week’s housing affordability crisis news, activists and bloggers are pushing a new, shockingly disingenuous study by the National Low Income Housing Coalition (NLIHC) to make a case for a minimum wage much higher than the $15 an hour activists have been pushing for.

The NLIHC aims to answer a simple question: what would your hourly wage need to be in order to afford a modest apartment in your neighborhood? This assumes you follow the general rule of spending 30 percent of your income on housing.

Their takeaway is the same it’s been for the last several years and is in lockstep with housing activists: it’s become more and more expensive to live in Washington. In fact, we’re the 10th most expensive state in regards to housing affordability.

Here’s the data they present:

-In WA, on average, you need to make $21.69 to afford a two-bedroom apartment.

-In Pierce County, you’d need to make $21.02 an hour for the two-bedroom apartment.

-In King County, where we’ve been hearing the most complaints over housing affordability &#8212 a hefty $27.21 an hour for a two-bedroom apartment.

Obviously, if you’re a grocery store clerk in Tacoma or Puyallup, you’re not making $21.02 an hour. If you’re working retail at the Northgate Mall or Lincoln Towne Square, you’re not making $27.21 an hour.

So the takeaway from this study is to get you to support raising the minimum wage. They report, in part: “A renter earning the federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour would need to work … 102 hours per week to afford a two-bedroom Fair Market Rent.”

Related: Skyrocketing rents? How about you live within your means?

Sounds like a compelling argument to raise the wage if you want people to live comfortably. Predictably, journalists and activist bloggers are running with that message.

But did you notice a data point that I quoted above? It’s a key data point they use. In fact, it’s the default data point.

They’re talking about a single person making minimum wage and what it would take to live in a two-bedroom apartment.

They say the two-bedroom housing wage in Washington state is $21.69. No, it’s not. It’s $10.85. Why? Because two bedrooms are generally for two people (at a minimum).

If two people working full time – either roommates or a couple – put their money together, they can easily afford a two bedroom, modest apartment on minimum wage in Washington.

It may still be tight – it may still be uncomfortable, depending on your lifestyle, your commute, etc. – but it paints a dramatically different picture than the misleading one they want to present.

And this is important because the majority of people who are working these low-skilled, minimum wage jobs are single young adults.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics says over half of the minimum wage workers are under 25. Of that, half are teens. Pew Research backs the numbers up. That’s the face of the minimum wage in this country.

By the way, they’re overwhelmingly white – 77 percent, in fact. We’re told how this is a social justice issue; that the face is a single mom who has two kids and two jobs and is black or Latina. But that’s not the majority of the cases. It’s a white college grad or high schoolers just entering the workforce. And when you’re just entering the workforce, you have no skills to demand too high of a wage. You’re hoping that you can impress someone enough to hire you with no experience, then let you gain the experience you can then exploit for a higher wage at the same company or a different one.

And they shouldn’t be living in a two-bedroom apartment alone if they’re unwilling to understand it costs more than they can afford.

Related: Seattle’s ‘walkability’ hurts the poor

Now it is true that there are single parents, for example, who also have minimum wage jobs. Luckily, they’re in the minority, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t help (it also doesn’t mean, by the way, that we shouldn’t talk about choices that lead to poverty, which includes “waiting until age 21 to get married and have children,” per the left-leaning Brookings Institute).

But a blanket claim that is so easily dismissed with the facts does their side a huge disservice. How about we work together to come up with additional policy prescriptions for Americans in that situation, rather than pretending the 21-year-old kid with a degree in interpretative dance should be making $27.21 at a retail job so he can afford a two-bedroom apartment.

Jason Rantz on Seattle Red AM 770
  • listen to jason rantzTune in to Seattle Red AM 770 weekdays at 3-7pm to The Jason Rantz Show.

Jason Rantz Show

Jason Rantz

SBA wa grocery guarantee farmers...

Jason Rantz, Seattle Red

SBA brings Grocery Guarantee loans to Washington farmers as state costs pile up

Washington farmers are getting squeezed from every direction, and Olympia has no plans to help.

4 months ago

...

MyNorthwest Video

Video: Seattle residents demand action on crime!

Jason Rantz discusses how residents of Seattle’s Central District voiced their frustrations over crime at a community forum. Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red or livestream on the Seattle Red YouTube Channel weekdays from 3pm – 7pm or on demand wherever you podcast!

12 months ago

...

MyNorthwest Video

Video: Senator pushes bill benefitting sex offender?

Jason Rantz unpacks his exclusive story about a Washington Democrat who pushed for softer child sex crime penalties to help her friend with a predator son. Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red or livestream on the Seattle Red YouTube Channel weekdays from 3pm – 7pm or on demand wherever you podcast!

1 year ago

...

MyNorthwest Video

Video: King County Court lets a rapist go?

The King County Superior Court accidentally released a convicted rapist from custody, the King County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office (KCPAO) confirmed to “The Jason Rantz Show.” A jury found Noel D. Stepney guilty of Rape in the Second Degree on June 11. According to the KCPAO, he has a combined 33 convictions and charges stemming from […]

1 year ago

...

MyNorthwest Video

Video: AM 770 KTTH becomes Seattle Red

Bonneville Seattle has officially rebranded AM 770 KTTH as Seattle Red, launching a fresh conservative media presence for the Pacific Northwest. The change marks more than just a name—it’s a mission. Listen to The Jason Rantz Show on Seattle Red or livestream on the Seattle Red YouTube Channel weekdays from 3pm – 7pm or on […]

1 year ago

A shot from the KING 5 studio control room when Jason Rantz was allowed on the station. (Photo: Jas...

Jason Rantz

Rantz: Seattle’s ‘Resistance TV’ pushes another story making criminal illegal immigrant the victim

KING 5 news wants you to think a criminal illegal immigrant is the victim for being deported. Maybe that's why they don't detail his crime.

1 year ago

You won’t believe this shockingly disingenuous housing affordability study