Questions, confusion after Senate passes ‘catastrophic’ measure limiting nurse shifts

Apr 19, 2019, 3:13 PM | Updated: 5:14 pm
Nurse Harborview...
Harborview Medical Center. (KIRO Radio)
(KIRO Radio)

For the last five years, State Rep. Marcus Riccelli has been working to give nurses a rest — right now, they get breaks and lunches as the law states, but neither are required to be uninterrupted.

RELATED: Nurse files class action suit over unpaid breaks
RELATED: Doctor fights against hospitals operating more like casinos

HB 1155 was supposed to mandate those breaks, a measure that’s proven widely popular among nurses.

“Those breaks are definitely needed and valuable — too many nurses don’t take their breaks and just chart that they did,” said Keenan Clinch, a registered nurse at Seattle’s Harborview Medical Center. “Making it mandatory is definitely something that we want, and it’s something that our union’s behind.”

That being so, nurses were stunned when they learned about changes made to the bill in the Senate.

The mandatory breaks remained, but amendments were added, excluding rural hospitals, and most significantly, making it so nurses wouldn’t be allowed to work more than eight hours in a single shift

The changes have introduced confusion concerning what nurses view as a direct threat both to health care workers and patients.

“An eight-hour daily cap to nursing hours would be catastrophic to the safety and quality of care for hospitalized patients in the state of Washington,” said Dr. Liam Yore, Past President of the Washington Chapter for the American College of Emergency Physicians.

Even more than that, nurses cite the eight-hour cap as a hazard to their patients.

“It definitely is a patient safety issue,” said Clinch.

According to Clinch, eight-hour shifts mean more hand-off periods between nurses during the day, where two nurses spend 30 minutes outside of patients’ rooms to debrief.

“Lots of research out there shows that the most dangerous time for patients is hand-offs,” he noted. “Eight-hour shifts would mean three hand-offs a day, whereas 12-hour shifts is just two. It’s less danger for the patient.”

Additionally, many nurses prefer to work three 12-hour shifts in a week, to allow for much-needed time away from a stressful profession.

“Doing three shifts a week and having four days off is much more therapeutic — it gives us a better work-life balance, and gets us further away from the hospital for longer periods of time,” Clinch described.

A surprise amendment passes

So, how did a bill originally designed to give nurses a break morph into something that threatens to upend their livelihood?

That all started when the amendment mandating eight-hour workdays was tacked on by Republican Sen. Maureen Walsh.

“I ran the amendment to simply say, that if the argument on behalf of this bill is nurses are experiencing exhaustion and fatigue, then perhaps the shifts are too long,” said Sen. Walsh. “This was a statement amendment by the minority party to try to make a point on the floor about the bill.”

Her point: “Maybe 12-hour shifts aren’t a good idea if you’re so exhausted.”

That said, Sen. Walsh also didn’t expect Democrats on the Senate floor to actually enact her measure.

“I fully expected a rousing ‘no’ on my amendment,” she said. “I never dreamed that the amendment would hang.”

Democrats in the Senate hold a 29-21 advantage, with one Democrat who often caucuses with Republicans. As for how the amendment was allowed to pass, Sen. Karen Keiser pointed out that it doesn’t take many well-meaning Democrats to sway a vote.

“Democrats generally support eight-hour shifts,” she pointed out. “But we didn’t have a roll call vote, so we don’t really know who really voted for which amendment.”

One Democrat who voted in favor of the amended bill was Sen. Rebecca Saldana, who cited her support as “procedural,” and that it “does not reflect (her) desire for the final outcome of the bill.”

“What was before us on the Senate floor gutted the original bill,” Saldana added.

Sen. Keiser — herself the Democratic sponsor for the Senate bill — noted that every Republican voted in favor of the eight-hour shift requirement.

Confusion spreads

What quickly followed was a massive campaign launched by the Washington State Hospital Association, a local trade organization. The WSHA asked that nurses voice their opposition to the amendment, but without mentioning the original intent of the bill regarding breaks.

The WSHA opposed the bill in its infancy, back when it was designed just to mandate uninterrupted breaks for nurses. Shortly after Sen. Walsh’s amendment passed, fliers from the organization began appearing in hospital break rooms, urging workers to oppose the eight-hour workday amendment.

“The Hospital Association went to break rooms and said ‘this eight-hour provision is awful,’ also asking them to kill the whole bill, which I think is somewhat deceptive,” said the bill’s primary sponsor in the House, Rep. Marcus Riccelli.

MyNorthwest acquired a copy of one of those fliers. It reads:

On April 16, the Washington State Senate passed a bill (SHB 1155) that limits nurses to working only 8 hours in a 24 hour period, with no exemptions for emergencies or matters of patient safety.

There is still time to stop this change!

Most hospitals, at the request of nurses, have 12-hour shifts, and under the new law nurses would need to work 5 days a week for full-time pay.

  • The Washington State Hospital Association believes most nurses will not like this 8-hour limit.
  • The hospital association opposes this provision in the bill because it decreases nurses’ flexibility.

While opposed initially, the WSHA later voiced its support when the amendment excluding rural hospitals was introduced. Its support for the bill moving forward is dependent on the removal of the eight-hour cap, and keeping the amendment excluding rural hospitals.

“The eight-hour shift limit amendment messed up the bill entirely,” a WSHA spokesperson told MyNorthwest.

HB 1155 now heads back to the House, where Rep. Riccelli hopes to remove both the eight-hour limit, and the measure excluding rural hospitals.

“I’ll be supporting our House work to remove those two changes … and we’re hoping to move this toward final passage,” said Riccelli.

In its final form, Democrats hope to have the bill function as it was originally intended: To provide uninterrupted, mandatory breaks for nurses in all of Washington’s hospitals, without limiting shifts to a set amount of hours.

KIRO Radio Reporter Carolyn Ossorio contributed to this report

Local News

world cup...
Frank Sumrall

Where to watch the World Cup: A guide to local soccer pubs

Now its time to support them by touring the best soccer bars in the region, all open for the match against the Netherlands.
1 day ago
Seattle likes Taylor Swift songs...
Micki Gamez

Seattle’s most downloaded songs and artists may surprise you

Newly released Spotify data says Taylor Swift is Seattle's most downloaded and listened to artist of the year 2022.
1 day ago
Stevens Pass skiing...
Heather Bosch

Stevens Pass vows to do better during this ski and snowboard season

The Stevens Pass Ski resort is open and it's under pressure to show skiers and snowboarders it has changed for the better.
1 day ago
Sunken ship Pacific...
Feliks Banel

Sunken ship lost 150 years ago, found off WA coast

The wreck of a sunken ship off the coast of Washington nearly 150 years ago has been found by a pair of maritime historians.
1 day ago
Puget Sound snow...
Bill Kaczaraba

Some snow into the Puget Sound region overnight

Friday snow is always a little bit different than Monday through Thursday snow. Friday snow is generally part of the holiday wonder.
1 day ago
human caused...
L.B. Gilbert

Small Business Administration offers disaster relief after Bolt Creek Fire

The SBA announced Thursday that they would be offering disaster relief loans to businesses impacted by the Bolt Creek Fire.
1 day ago

Sponsored Articles

Comcast Ready for Business Fund...
Ilona Lohrey | President and CEO, GSBA

GSBA is closing the disparity gap with Ready for Business Fund

GSBA, Comcast, and other partners are working to address disparities in access to financial resources with the Ready for Business fund.

Medicare open enrollment is here and SHIBA can help!

The SHIBA program – part of the Office of the Insurance Commissioner – is ready to help with your Medicare open enrollment decisions.
Lake Washington Windows...

Choosing Best Windows for Your Home

Lake Washington Windows and Doors is a local window dealer offering the exclusive Leak Armor installation.
Anacortes Christmas Tree...

Come one, come all! Food, Drink, and Coastal Christmas – Anacortes has it all!

Come celebrate Anacortes’ 11th annual Bier on the Pier! Bier on the Pier takes place on October 7th and 8th and features local ciders, food trucks and live music - not to mention the beautiful views of the Guemes Channel and backdrop of downtown Anacortes.
Swedish Cyberknife Treatment...

The revolutionary treatment of Swedish CyberKnife provides better quality of life for majority of patients

There are a wide variety of treatments options available for men with prostate cancer. One of the most technologically advanced treatment options in the Pacific Northwest is Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy using the CyberKnife platform at Swedish Medical Center.
Work at Zum Services...

Seattle Public Schools announces three-year contract with Zum

Seattle Public Schools just announced a three-year contract with a brand-new company to the Pacific Northwest to assist with their student transportation: Zum.
Questions, confusion after Senate passes ‘catastrophic’ measure limiting nurse shifts