Would visiting life on Venus violate Star Trek’s Prime Directive?

Sep 16, 2020, 5:02 PM | Updated: Sep 17, 2020, 10:40 am

This May 2016 photo provided by researcher Jane Greaves shows the planet Venus, seen from the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency's Akatsuki probe. A report released on Monday, Sept. 14, 2020 says astronomers have found a potential signal of life high in the atmosphere of our nearest neighboring planet. (J. Greaves/Cardiff University/JAXA via AP)

(J. Greaves/Cardiff University/JAXA via AP)

On Monday, a group of astronomers announced that there may be life on Venus. Using powerful telescopes, they detected the molecule phosphine in the planet’s atmosphere.

“The molecule is not itself alive, it’s just four atoms, a phosphorus and three hydrogens,” said Dr. Sarah Ballard, professor of astronomy at the University of Florida. “The reason why much is being made of it is because there is no known way to produce phosphine on a terrestrial planet which does not involve living things.”

Full disclosure: Dr. Sarah Ballard happens to be one of my close friends. I like to brag about the fact that she discovered four new exoplanets before she turned 30, doing some of that work at the University of Washington as a NASA Carl Sagan fellow. But the reason I wanted to interview Dr. Ballard is because she does not hold the same opinion as many astronomers who are anxious to start getting up close and personal studying Venus. She thinks we need to slow down and consider the ethical consequences.

“I have an unusual position among scientists, in that I think it likely is life and we shouldn’t go. I think most scientists are in the opposite corner, where they think it isn’t life and we should go to understand what kind of exotic chemistry is going on,” she said.

“There are two reasons for why I’m very hesitant to jump right in and go,” she explained. “One of them is because it’s impossible not to contaminate Venus with Earth life if we send spacecraft. There have been spacecraft that have visited Venus and gone even to the surface of Venus where they were immediately crushed and destroyed. Venus is not particularly habitable. However, even putting something into outer space, there can still be living things on it. It is extremely hard to kill all organisms from Earth; even in the vacuum of space things can stay alive. So that means almost certainly, if we sent a spacecraft, the risk would not be zero that we are putting life into a situation which right now might be pristine. The second reason is because in Star Trek there’s something called The Prime Directive, which is basically a moral position about how you shouldn’t interfere with developing civilizations. It should be treated as if it’s a nature preserve, basically. There’s something ethical about it.”

Dr. Ballard thinks we need to be careful we don’t use curiosity as the number one reason to justify actions that might harm or destroy life on Venus, or any other place in the solar system.

“We have a really mixed history on Earth of using science to justify entry into spaces where we weren’t before,” she said. “I also think that the question of whether we should go shouldn’t just be a scientific question. I think it’s a question that everyone should weigh in on. Not only because taxpayer dollars fund NASA, but also because I think it is an enormously moral question, which extends beyond what scientists can answer. Which is, have we reckoned within our own history enough to feel like it’s moral to go to another planet where there might be life and interfere with it? And yet, nobody is more voraciously curious than me about what it is and whether it has DNA! Nobody wants to know more than me. But the fact that I have such a strong investment and such a strong bias for wanting to understand it means I need to be that much more careful at interrogating my motivation.”

Dr. Ballard also points out that phosphine exists on Earth and is incredibly toxic to humans and other living things, making it a dangerous mission. If research was conducted, and samples were collected, it would need to be done near Venus and would rely upon robotics and AI to do the work for humans.

  • listen to rachel belleTune in to KIRO Radio on weekdays to hear Rachel Belle.
Who is Rachel Belle?

Your Last Meal

Rachel Belle

supply chain...
Rachel Belle

Start your holiday shopping now or risk supply chain issues

Now is the time to start holiday gift shopping because if you don't buy soon, supply chain issues may make it tough to get what you want later.
17 days ago
Rachel Belle

How does Dick’s Drive-In pay workers $19 an hour with a menu completely under $5?

Dick's Drive-In recently raised its base pay, as did Taco Time, which is now offering employees $20 an hour at select locations. How do they keep prices low and pay high?
18 days ago
Rachel Belle

Don’t like how you look on Zoom? Many young Americans are now getting Botox

More people are turning to Botox to get rid of lines and wrinkles, but is it safe? How does one age naturally in a youth obsessed country? Experts weigh in.
24 days ago
certified wildlife habitat...
Rachel Belle

Turn your backyard into a Certified Wildlife Habitat

The National Wildlife Federation will help you make your yard a habitable home for bees, birds, bugs and critters. And they'll give you an official sign!
1 month ago
Emily Cherkin and Ben Gitenstein, pictured months after 9/11. (Photo courtesy of Emily Cherkin)...
Rachel Belle

‘You either got married or broke up’: 20 years later, a Seattle couple on falling in love in NYC in the wake of 9/11

On Sept. 11, 2001, Seattle's Emily Cherkin and Ben Gitenstein were 22 years old and separately taking the subway into Manhattan when two planes crashed into the Twin Towers. This is their story.
1 month ago
dirty work...
Rachel Belle

New book ‘Dirty Work’ reveals psychological toll of working unsavory jobs nobody wants

A new book by Eyal Press called "Dirty Work: Essential Jobs and the Hidden Toll of Inequality in America" takes a deeper look at jobs no one wants to do.
2 months ago

Sponsored Articles


Medicare open enrollment for 2022 starts Oct. 15 and SHIBA can help!

Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner SPONSORED — Medicare’s Open Enrollment Period, also called the Annual Election Period, is Oct. 15 to Dec. 7. During this time, people enrolled in Medicare can: Switch from Original Medicare to a Medicare Advantage plan and vice versa. Join, drop or switch a Part D prescription drug plan, […]

How to Have a Stress-Free Real Estate Experience

The real estate industry has adapted and sellers are taking full advantage of new real estate models. One of which is Every Door Real Estate.
IQ Air

How Poor Air Quality Is Affecting Our Future Athletes

You cannot control your child’s breathing environment 100% of the time, but you can make a huge impact.
Swedish Health Services

Special Coverage: National Prostate Cancer Awareness Month

There are a wide variety of treatment options available for men with prostate cancer. The most technologically advanced treatment option in the Northwest is Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy using the CyberKnife platform.
Marysville Police Department

Police Opportunities in a Growing, Supportive Washington Community

Marysville PD is looking for both lateral and entry level officers. Begin or continue your career in law enforcement for a growing, supportive community.

Small, Minority-Owned Businesses in King County and Pierce County Can Now Apply For $10,000 Relief Grants Through Comcast RISE

Businesses in King County and Pierce County can apply beginning on October 1, 2021, at www.ComcastRISE.com for a chance to receive a $10,000 relief grant.
Would visiting life on Venus violate Star Trek’s Prime Directive?