Judge will make decision on City of Seattle trash lawsuit by end of month

Apr 14, 2016, 4:59 PM | Updated: Apr 15, 2016, 2:40 pm


Because thieves don't generally care about emotionally valuable items, they are frequently ditched near the trash. (AP)



King County Superior Court Judge Beth Andrus heard the case Thursday and said she will issue a written decision by the end of business day on April 29.

The hearing included a hefty discussion of constitutional law, privacy rights and precedent-setting cases involving trash-pickup and privacy.

Pacific Legal Foundation attorney Ethan Blevins said the city is breaking the law.

“We believe the city’s decision to have garbage collectors inspect residents’ trash on a weekly basis — inspecting for food waste or other recyclables — is a violation of Seattle residents’ right to privacy,” he said. “The Washington state constitution has special protections for privacy similar to the federal constitution’s Fourth Amendment, but Washington’s privacy right is even more robust.”

Ted Seder, an attorney for the City of Seattle, said the lawsuit lacked evidence that anything had changed with the implementation of a new ordinance requiring residents to put compostable items in compost bins.

“Trash collectors have been looking for prohibitive items in garbage since the beginning of trash collection,” he told the judge. “In the city prior to this ordinance, trash collectors looked for 43 items … and now there’s a 44th item.”

Original story:

Is the City of Seattle violating residents’ civil rights when it looks at their trash?

That’s the key question in a case that will be heard by a King County Superior Court judge on Friday.

Eight plaintiffs joined together to sue the city over its practices regarding garbage collection. The Libertarian group, Pacific Legal Foundation, filed the lawsuit last July.

Scott Shock is one of those plaintiffs.

“Me and my family are really diligent about recycling and composting our yard waste and it felt like the city was going overboard in being punitive about their approach to this issue,” he said.

Related: Washington lawmakers consider cutting taxes for beer and booze

Shock believes the city is violating his privacy when it checks to see whether he’s properly recycling and composting. He notes that he might have personal information in his garbage.

“I just think it’s the wrong approach for the city to move toward acting like big brother and acting punitive towards its citizens,” he said, especially ones who want to be cooperative.

In his response to the court, City Attorney Pete Holmes argues that Seattle is not breaking any laws.

“Plaintiffs are attempting to turn a straightforward police power case into a titanic struggle regarding constitutional law principles,” he writes. “This court should decline to follow the plaintiff into that dismal swamp.”

Seattle made national headlines over a year ago when public utilities officials announced they’d be fining residents who don’t properly sort their compost and recyclables.

They said they’d start out with the tags to get residents used to the new law. Later, the city was going to add the bonafide fines. But they’ve postponed the implementation of such fines more than once. So far, the city has yet to fine any private residents.

MyNorthwest News

Photo: The exterior of the Boeing Company headquarters on March 25, 2024....

James Lynch

Boeing working with DOJ to avoid criminal charges

After allegedly violating the terms of a 2021 deferred prosecution agreement, Boeing is reportedly working to avoid a criminal trial.

24 minutes ago

Photo: Yin May suffered severe injuries when she was hit by a driver in Kent....

Julia Dallas

Deputies searching for person who hit, nearly killed woman in Kent

King County deputies are looking for the person who almost killed a woman in Kent in a hit-and-run on Sunday.

2 hours ago

Photo: Snohomish County bus....

Bill Kaczaraba

Attacks against Community Transit drivers reveal potential troubling trend

Community Transit drivers in Snohomish County face a growing threat from violent passengers. Two drivers have been attacked recently.

2 hours ago

Image: A Seattle Police Department vehicle is parked outside Lumen Field in Seattle....

Steve Coogan

Report: Seattle officer fired after previous racist comments surfaced

A Seattle Police Department officer was fired for calling his neighbor racist and sexist slurs and making other comments in 2022.

4 hours ago

Image: Supreme Court Police officers stand on duty outside of the Supreme Court building in Washing...

Associated Press

Supreme Court upholds gun control law intended to protect domestic violence victims

The Supreme Court on Friday upheld a federal gun control law that is intended to protect victims of domestic violence.

7 hours ago

Photo: Woodland Park Zoo's Batu is expecting....

Julia Dallas

Local zoo animals become mothers for the first time

Woodland Park Zoo and Point Defiance Zoo and Aquarium both have news! Two animals are experiencing motherhood for the first time.

21 hours ago

Judge will make decision on City of Seattle trash lawsuit by end of month