KIRO NIGHTS

Stine: It’s time to listen to others’ views on Manuel Ellis case

May 28, 2021, 2:28 PM | Updated: 3:21 pm

It is clear to me that the Manuel Ellis case echoes very strongly of the George Floyd case for many people — and because of that, I would like to remind people of the power of listening and empathy when discussing an issue as complicated and as sensitive as a man dying at the hands of the police.

I have witnessed a disingenuous rhetorical technique from my contemporaries within right-wing circles, in which they discuss the facts of the case, while also commenting on the deceased’s past. I witnessed this far too many times from my comrades in talk radio and, frankly, I find it deeply disturbing.

Judge sets bail at $100,000 for three officers charged in death of Manuel Ellis

For example, in the case of George Floyd, all too often one of my compatriots in right-wing media would refer to George Floyd’s criminal past, his many incarcerations, and his drug use. I see the same technique currently being executed against Manny Ellis. It is a rhetorical tactic that has no practical use in our attempt at discovering the facts of the case or in discussing the complexities of the case.

This technique is often used to distort or alter the perception of the case and broaden the range of discussion to the point where the initial question becomes lost. That question was and is: Did Manny Ellis deserve the treatment he received based on our understanding of the law?

I do not care about his criminal past, and I do not care about his drug use. My only concern is to discover whether his rights as a citizen were violated by our public servants. Anything else is a bad-faith attempt to poison the well of discourse around our relationship to the state.

In last night’s “Inside Stine’s Mind,” Stacy Jo Rost and I discussed a new technique in approaching difficult and sensitive issues, something called “listening.” It is this neat trick wherein we take the time to understand how a person views the cases of Manny Ellis or George Floyd — at both a personal and communal level. In this way, not only do we connect with people who we might fundamentally disagree with, but we also build empathy and tolerance for positions we might otherwise dismiss, based on presuppositions or prejudices against a person’s past.

What is courage?

In a distorted world, a firm sense of clarity can come from reducing the range of rhetoric around several key questions: How do I feel about the way Manny Ellis was treated? Where do my biases lie for or against the police? And would I expect similar treatment based on what the facts of the case present to us?

Anything else is useless gossip and conjecture.

Listen to KIRO Nights with Jack Stine weeknights from 7 p.m. – 10p.m. on KIRO Radio, 97.3 FM. Subscribe to the podcast here.

KIRO Nights on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM
  • listen to kiro nightsTune in to KIRO Newsradio weekdays at 7 pm for KIRO Nights with Jack Stine.

KIRO Nights

KIRO Nights

machete...

Matt Butler, KIRO Nights and Bill Kaczaraba, MyNorthwest

The tale of a local hero and his machete

Nafi Quatamin owns the Salena One Market in Tacoma. Like many small stores in the area, his market has been targeted for robbery.

1 month ago

Image:A Mexican Mariachi band surrounded by heart-shaped balloons awaits the arrival of a couple's ...

Matt Butler

KIRO Nights on dating rules, timeframes: How long is too long to wait?

Deborah Graham's mention of the rule of threes provoked some polar opposite opinions from listeners.

1 month ago

smart phone...

Frank Sumrall

Skorheim: ‘I’m not going to give my kids a smartphone’

"I think it's very dangerous to give kids smartphones at too young of an age," KIRO Nights host Jake Skorheim said.

3 months ago

Image: A rest area sign advertising free coffee can be seen in the state of Washington....

Jake Skorheim

Skorheim: How do you feel about WSDOT’s $10M bathrooms?

WSDOT says the agency needs $500 million to fix their 47 aging rest stops throughout the state.

4 months ago

Image: Fireworks go off at Mount Rushmore National Memorial on July 3, 2020, near Keystone, South D...

Matt Butler

Which artists, groups belong on Seattle’s music Mount Rushmore

KIRO personalities debated and discussed the music that defines Seattle and what artists belong on the Mount Rushmore of Seattle music.

5 months ago

bob rivers...

Matt Butler

Spike O’Neill reflects on 25 years with Bob Rivers amid radio HOF induction

There began what would become a 25-year Seattle radio legacy with Bob Rivers and company bringing "Twisted Radio" to morning drives.

5 months ago

Stine: It’s time to listen to others’ views on Manuel Ellis case