MYNORTHWEST NEWS

WA State Supreme Court redefines warrantless interrogation, concludes ‘race and ethnicity matter’

Jun 9, 2022, 2:46 PM

court...

The Temple of Justice Washington State (Jason Rosenberg via Flickr)

(Jason Rosenberg via Flickr)

The Washington State Supreme Court has issued a ruling that has the potential to redefine warrantless interrogations and seizures, a protocol police refer to as “Terry stops.”

Thursday’s ruling concludes that “we [the Court] formally recognize what has always been true: in interactions with law enforcement, race and ethnicity matter. Therefore, courts must consider the race and ethnicity of the allegedly seized person as part of the totality of the circumstances,” the court opinion reads.

The ruling stems from an incident wherein a Pierce County Sheriff’s deputy approached an Asian man, Pallo Sum, sleeping in a vehicle at a location that had previously been the site of an arrest connected to a stolen car.

Police monitor finds Seattle police conducted fewest on-record stops in 2021

The deputy asked for the man’s identification, and upon returning to his police car, Sum fled the scene, ultimately crashing. Sum was later charged with multiple felony counts stemming from that flight, as well as his possession of an unregistered firearm.

Sum would appeal, claiming that he was unlawfully seized without reasonable suspicion, noting “there is no justification—aside from unacceptably ignoring the issue of race altogether—for courts considering the totality of the circumstances to disregard the effect of race as one of the circumstances affecting evaluation of police contact.”

“For purposes of this analysis, an objective observer is aware that implicit, institutional, and unconscious biases, in addition to purposeful discrimination, have resulted in disproportionate police contacts, investigative seizures, and uses of force against Black, Indigenous, and other People of Color (BIPOC) in Washington,” the court opinion continues.

“Finally, in accordance with our precedent, if the person shows there was a seizure, then the burden shifts to the State to prove that the seizure was lawfully justified by a warrant or an applicable exception to the warrant requirement.”

MyNorthwest News

Photo: Olympia police are looking for Allen Leman (L) and Drake Coop (R)....

Julia Dallas

Olympia police looking for two 11-year-old runaways

The Olympia Police Department is asking for the public's help in finding two children. OPD reported two 11-year-old boys ran away.

9 hours ago

Image: The lodge at Camp Long in West Seattle dates to the early 1940s; it was struck by an arsonis...

Feliks Banel

Seattle Parks expects to restore historic Camp Long lodge, but questions remain

The historic lodge at Camp Long in West Seattle was badly damaged in a fire in November and the cost to repair it has yet to be determined.

11 hours ago

Players vie for the ball in a high school basketball game. (Photo: AP)...

Bill Kaczaraba

New proposals in WA for transgender high school student-athletes

The Washington Interscholastic Activities Association is proposing a new way for transgender athletes to participate in high school sports.

12 hours ago

Photo: A Federal Way Police Department vehicle....

Julia Dallas

Federal Way crime data shows drug arrests skyrocketed more than 400% this year

The city of Federal Way released its yearly crime data report, revealing staggering numbers when it came to crime regarding drug use.

12 hours ago

Image: According to the Renton Police Department, Alex Díaz Rios, a former assistant principal at ...

James Lynch

Former assistant principal at Seattle K-8 school charged for allegedly soliciting sex from minor

The Renton Police Department announced the arrest of seven men following an undercover child sex trafficking operation. One of those individuals was a local principal.

12 hours ago

mortgage...

Frank Sumrall

$2M resolution with mortgage firm: Are you one of 1,500 WA residents owed money?

1,500 WA residents will get to claim their share of $2 million as a result of a resolution with Nationstar for mortgage violations.

13 hours ago

WA State Supreme Court redefines warrantless interrogation, concludes ‘race and ethnicity matter’