MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Lawyer: Bremerton schools have ‘radical rule’ on prayer

Jun 12, 2017, 6:50 AM | Updated: 3:54 pm

Bremerton Coach...

Former Bremerton High School football coach Joe Kennedy. (KIRO 7)

(KIRO 7)

The case of a Bremerton coach who refused to stop praying on a football field with students took another step forward Monday as lawyers argued in court.

The Bremerton School District fired Coach Joe Kennedy in 2015 for refusing to stop praying on the field. Students and players often joined him in prayer, prompting a classic debate of church and state. Kennedy sued the district for religious discrimination in response to the firing.

Dori Monson: Why the Bremerton coach should not be praying with students

Three district judges with the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in Seattle pressed attorneys for answers to explain why, or why not, a high school football coach should be praying on a football field after games.

“You’re dealing with someone who is unambiguously a representative of the school district,” argued an attorney for the Bremerton School District.

The district’s lawyer said that a coach communicates a message on behalf of the school in his role as a district employee. There is no issue when an employee prays in private, the lawyer said, but things are different when students join in. It can put coercive pressure on students and create a message that the district endorses a religion.

“Public schools must be tolerant and welcoming places to students of all faiths,” the district’s attorney said. “…you can really have ugly rifts erupting in a school community when members of religious minorities complain about, or even separate themselves from a religious practice going on. What the Bremerton School District did here was not just within their right, but their duty to their students, to the entire community of the school district to ensure that it was a safe place and a welcoming place to students of all different faiths.”

Arguments for the Bremerton coach

But the Bremerton coach thinks otherwise, and Kennedy’s lawyers argued that the district’s broad definition of a school employee sets up a “radical rule.” Teachers could be fired for wearing scarves or yarmulkes under district policy, according to Kennedy’s lawyer.

“It is … an undermining of First Amendment protection for public employees … employers cannot restrict employee rights by creating excessively broad job descriptions, which is effectively what the district has tried to do here by characterizing Coach Kennedy as a teacher – plus.”

Kennedy’s attorney further argued that nobody would reasonably take Kennedy’s kneeling on the football field as a sign the district endorses a religion.

This is the second stop for Kennedy’s case. A lower court previously denied his effort to be reinstated as a coach in Bremerton. He has said that the case is not about money.

Information from KIRO 7 was used in this article.

MyNorthwest News

Department of Justice (1)...

MyNorthwest Staff

Seattle man charged in decade-long immigration fraud scheme involving friends, family

A Seattle man was arrested Tuesday on an indictment in which he was charged in a scheme to submit false information to obtain immigration status for others.

22 hours ago

dad kids responsibilities...

Katrina Guischard

Viral video of moms’ weekend getaway sparks debate over whether dads need child care backup

Moms share insights on childcare during weekends away, igniting debate on dads' responsibilities in parenting.

22 hours ago

Poe Russell ground stop...

Frank Lenzi

KIRO Newsradio host Angela Poe Russell stuck in Cabo until Tuesday after ground stop

KIRO Newsradio host Angela Poe Russell and her family are stuck in Cabo San Lucas, Mexico, until Tuesday after a ground stop left them waiting aboard their plane for 6½ hours Friday.

2 days ago

everett meth trafficking...

MyNorthwest Staff

Everett drug trafficker sentenced after delivering meth to law enforcement officer

A 36-year-old Mexican national was sentenced to five years in prison after he was found tending to a drug stash house in Everett and making drug deliveries.

2 days ago

seattle holiday carousel westlake...

MyNorthwest Staff

Seattle’s Westlake Park holiday carousel returns after years-long hiatus

For the first time in more than five years, the Westlake Park Holiday Carousel is returning for the 2026 holiday season.

2 days ago

shooting...

MyNorthwest Staff

Shooting leaves 1 dead in Redmond, 2 suspects believed to be on the loose

A shooting in Redmond left one person dead, and two suspects are believed to be on the loose.

2 days ago

Lawyer: Bremerton schools have ‘radical rule’ on prayer