Seattle neighbors file lawsuit against mail carrier

Aug 25, 2017, 7:40 AM | Updated: Dec 19, 2017, 5:27 pm

mail carrier...

Mark and his daughter pose with their dog in front of their Seattle home. (KIRO Radio)

(KIRO Radio)

By Carolyn Ossorio

In the past seven years in Seattle, 90,000 people have moved to the city, Amazon has become one of the nation’s largest employers, and local mail carriers have delivered tens of millions of letters, cards, and packages to businesses and homes across the city.

Mark Middlesbrook’s Ballard home isn’t one of them.

But that’s not from a lack of desire. Middlesbrook would love to see letters return to the black mailbox nailed to his duplex on 58th Street.

But a longstanding dispute that the 42-year-old mortgage broker blames on a toxic combination of false “bad dog” reports, postal service mismanagement, and a lone letter carrier has left him — and others in the neighborhood — unable to regularly receive mail at their homes since former President Barack Obama’s first term in office.

And now some residents have decided to fight back. Middlesbrook’s neighbor, Randy Erlich, filed a lawsuit against the United States Postal Service, the individual letter carrier, and two managers seeking compensatory and punitive damages for violating his civil rights.

USPS spokesman Ernie Swanson declined to comment specifically on the dispute and instead issued a statement centered on the USPS’s dog policy.

Middlesbrook said the problem began in March 2010. He came home and instead of mail, he received a letter from the USPS stating that his mail carrier filed a “Dog Problem” report.

According to the carrier, Middlesbrook’s dog — a pet he describes as gentle — was off leash in front of his house.

This, Middlesbrook learned, triggered the mail termination. The only way to get mail service back was to sign a “Memo of Understanding,” which promised that any dog on his property would be kept under control during delivery hours.

Middlesbrook signed even though he strongly disagreed with the memo. He assumed everything was fixed.

A few weeks later, on June 24, the carrier submitted another dog problem report to her boss. This time it permanently terminated Mark’s mail delivery. The report said the dog was loose again.

But there was a problem. The carrier fabricated the entire story, Middlesbrook said.

And the fabrication isn’t limited to his residence, he said. He’s collected 13 complaint letters from his neighbors who said the same carrier had submitted “fake” dog problem reports to the United States Postal Service management.

Middlesbrook said after this, he permanently forwarded his mail to his parent’s home in Renton.

Then in December 2016, Middlesbrook’s dog died. But the carrier still wouldn’t deliver to his house.

After the family delivered the dog’s death certificate to USPS managers, he began receiving mail – for a short time.

Middlesbrook got a new dog in April 2017. Less than a month later, he received another official shut off letter from the postal manager of Ballard.

Middlesbrook said this mail feud over the past seven years is the first time in his life he has ever felt truly railroaded. The USPS management has, at best, turned a blind eye to the complaints, he said. At worst, it’s actively protected a long-term employee with a history of filing fake reports and bullying customers, he added.

“During this time I felt that my input was not only unimportant but viewed with great negative prejudice by the USPS. It seemed clear to me that (the letter carrier) had established her complete and unchallenged control over our mail delivery.”

MyNorthwest News

Listen to the discussion from KIRO Newsradio's John & Shari show....

Bill Kaczaraba

John & Shari VIDEO: Training for local firefighters ‘destructive’

Local fire departments have suspended their Diversity Equity Inclusion training.

7 hours ago

Image: Seattle Police Department dashcam video shows officers' pursuit of two juveniles who carjack...

Kate Stone

Boys, ages 12 and 13, who led police on car chase given different outcomes after court appearances

Seattle detectives believe the woman was reporting her two children, but she did not provide their names or indicate she knew them.

8 hours ago

A Seattle Police Department vehicle....

Steve Coogan and Sam Campbell

Seattle police officers given 9 hour suspensions after slow shooting response

A new report has revealed two Seattle Police Department officers took over 20 minutes to get to a shooting scene a mile away in late 2022.

8 hours ago

Food delivery biker...

Heather Bosch

Delivery apps adding a side dish of ‘worry’ for restaurants, customers

This should be a joyous time for entrepreneurs, but Seattle's new delivery driver pay standards - and the app-based companies that use them - have served up a side dish of worry.

9 hours ago

cap rent criminal background checks...

Bill Kaczaraba

Survey: Washingtonians ‘unhappy’ with the lack of affordable housing

Washington residents are more "unhappy" than others in the nation about the price of housing.

10 hours ago

kent trooper shot...

Kate Stone

Man faces multiple charges after WSP trooper shooting in Kent

A man accused of shooting a Washington State Patrol trooper multiple times in Kent last Friday has been charged.

10 hours ago

Seattle neighbors file lawsuit against mail carrier