GEE & URSULA

Why county isn’t prosecuting teen suspect in fatal Maple Valley hit-and-run as an adult

Sep 16, 2021, 1:02 PM | Updated: 1:19 pm

Maple Valley hit and run...

A memorial to Greg Moore, who was killed in a hit-and-run in Maple Valley in July. (KIRO 7)

(KIRO 7)

While the wife of a Maple Valley man killed in a hit-and-run over the summer wants to have the 15-year-old girl suspected of the crime tried as an adult, the King County Prosecutor’s Office points to several factors that would make that difficult.

Deputies identify 15-year-old girl as suspect in Maple Valley hit-and-run

The teen was alleged to have intentionally swerved a vehicle taken from a relative into 53-year-old Greg Moore. Moore was out for a run along the shoulder of the road, and was found after being struck just after 6 a.m. on the morning of July 18.

Because the girl is a minor, she faces up to six years in jail if convicted. As for why the county can’t simply choose to try her as an adult to yield a longer sentence, prosecutors are largely limited by state laws.

“When you’re 15, that’s a juvenile court case and that’s really it,” King County Prosecutor’s Office spokesperson Casey McNerthney told KIRO Radio’s Gee & Ursula Show. “If you’re 16 or 17 and you’re charged with murder, automatically across Washington state that goes to adult court — those are called ‘auto adult cases.'”

“If this were a 16-year-old, then we wouldn’t be in this spot,” he added. “But when you’re 15, or 14, or 13, that leaves a difficult decision for prosecutors.”

Why not attempt to send the case to adult court anyway, though? As McNerthney points out, there would still be barriers in place that could prevent a longer sentence regardless.

“It’s very unlikely that a juvenile court judge would approve the move to adult court, which is what has to happen; it’s not our choice here,” he clarified, noting that prosecutors would also have to prove the suspect explicitly intended to kill Moore. “And even if that does happen and there is a conviction in an adult court, superior court judges can and very often do sentence somebody along juvenile guidelines if the crime was committed when they were a juvenile.”

That said, McNerthney also understands the frustration from Moore’s wife, Michelle, who expressed to KIRO Radio’s Dori Monson that she believes proving the teen’s intent shouldn’t be difficult, given that “anyone above the age of 8 knows … if you hit a small person with a 3,000-pound car, the chances are pretty good that they’re going to die.”

But proving the suspect intended to kill Moore is more difficult than it seems.

“When people (say) ‘how can you hit somebody with car and not expect to kill them,’ I mean, of course, how is that not first degree [murder]?” McNerthney described. “But that doesn’t hold up in court — we can’t say, ‘well, of course that’s what would have happened.’ You’ve got to clearly show that in order to prove intent.”

The King County Prosecutor’s Office is instead charging the teen with two charges: second-degree murder and felony hit-and-run, which represents the “highest possible charge we can file with the evidence we’ve received so far.”

Listen to the Gee and Ursula Show weekday mornings from 9 a.m. – 12 p.m. on KIRO Radio, 97.3 FM. Subscribe to the podcast here.

Gee and Ursula Show

Gee & Ursula

wa girls sports i-638...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘This is going to be a mess’: Gee raises concerns about girls missing competitions under WA’s new verification rules

New verification rules in Washington raise alarms about girls missing sports competitions. Insights on I-638 and its impact.

2 hours ago

kratom edmonds death...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘Withdrawal from kratom is horrific’: KIRO producer describes his struggle as Edmonds family pushes for sales ban

KIRO producer Andrew Lanier shares his withdrawal struggle as an Edmonds family seeks to ban kratom following their son's death.

8 hours ago

seattle superintendent ipad school...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘You are here to be the fall guy’: Gee and Ursula criticize Seattle School Board for handing school closure power to superintendent

The Seattle School Board has given Superintendent Ben Shuldiner the power to close or merge schools without a final board vote.

19 hours ago

toxic relationship...

Ursula Reutin

Ask Ursula: Should I stay in a toxic relationship because dating in Seattle in my 50s is hard?

Should you stay in a toxic relationship because you’re afraid to be alone? Ursula weighs in.

1 day ago

In this photo illustration, a case for the upcoming console game "Grand Theft Auto 6", also known a...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘What good is there in this?’: Ursula questions Grand Theft Auto’s violence as KIRO hosts debate taking time off to play

KIRO Newsradio's Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin discuss the impact of Grand Theft Auto's violence and its implications for players ahead of the new release.

2 days ago

...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘We’re tired of hearing’ it: Councilmember Rod Dembowski demands answers as King County project costs soar

King County Councilmember Rod Dembowski argued the county's usual explanations for cost overruns aren't good enough anymore.

2 days ago

Why county isn’t prosecuting teen suspect in fatal Maple Valley hit-and-run as an adult