JOHN CURLEY

‘That’s a problem’: Center Square editor speaks out on teen wrestler’s alleged assault by biological male

Feb 11, 2026, 2:03 PM | Updated: 3:25 pm

Following reports of a teen athlete in Puyallup allegedly being sexually violated by a biological male during a wrestling match, concerns were raised after the school district failed to report the allegations in a timely manner.

Carleen Johnson, The Center Square’s Washington associate editor, detailed the incident involving Kallie Keeler, who is a Rogers High School athlete, and explained why she would want the same transparency for her own child.

“[Keeler’s] been a wrestler since she was little. She was at a school meet. Didn’t know she was wrestling against a boy much larger than her,” Johnson told “The John Curley Show” on KIRO Newsradio. “Her assertion is that while he’s in the process of pinning her and has a hand between her legs, he spent a little bit more time in the inner regions than he should have.

“You can actually see in the video that she’s looking over at her mom, who’s videotaping, thinking, ‘Oh my God. Like, what’s happening? I’ve just been sexually assaulted.’ The problem is, she told the school two days later, and they didn’t tell police until January 30, so that’s a problem,” Johnson continued.

Puyallup School District accused of failing to act

Brandi Kruse noted the Puyallup School District’s (PSD) failure to report the allegations to the police in her “unDivided” podcast, mentioning that four PSD officials did not act on the report in a manner consistent with state law.

Johnson labeled the incident a “problem” and spoke for herself and other parents seeking greater transparency in youth sports.

“In this case, this girl thought she was wrestling another girl. She didn’t know until later that he was a biological male. That’s a problem, right there,” Johnson said. “We should tell these young women, because she might not have felt comfortable doing that to begin with. She’s never wrestled a boy before.

“I would want my daughter to know, right? As a volleyball player, I’d want to know that the guy who’s going to be blocking her could break her nose with the strength of his swing,” Johnson continued. “I want to know so that I can help her make a decision whether she wants to compete against that boy or not. I want to know.”

Watch the full discussion in the video above.

Listen to John Curley weekday afternoons from 3 – 7 p.m. on KIRO Newsradio, 97.3 FM. Subscribe to the podcast here.

John Curley on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM
  • listen to tom and curleyTune in to KIRO Newsradio weekdays at 3pm for The John Curley Show.

John Curley

John Curley

flock cameras everett renton...

John Curley Show

‘The police are basically renting access to data’: Cybersecurity expert warns about Flock cameras

John Curley likes Flock cameras. Producer Joe Wallace brought in someone he said could explain the risks better than he could.

2 days ago

Doctors Office gender...

John Curley Show

‘We’re supposed to be healers, not harmers’: Doctor says politics has taken over medical groups’ stance on gender care for minors

With Initiative 638 on the November ballot, Curley said he went looking for a better understanding of the medical side of the transgender debate.

2 days ago

WA Supreme Court candidate Sean O’Donnell...

John Curley Show

‘Judges are a check on power’: WA Supreme Court candidate Sean O’Donnell warns against politicizing judicial races

King County Superior Court Judge Sean O’Donnell said a late flood of outside spending against him threatens public trust in Washington’s courts.

4 days ago

King County Council candidate Nick Duda...

John Curley Show

‘Deeply undemocratic’: King County Council candidate says opponent canceled their only scheduled debate

King County Council candidate Nick Duda said voters lost their chance to see him debate incumbent Teresa Mosqueda after she canceled the event.

4 days ago

Sheriff candidate Golden...

John Curley Show

‘Is he drinking while he’s doing this?’: Curley reacts to sheriff candidate’s video explaining his arrest

Some candidates run on public safety. Jason Golden is running on getting arrested for public intoxication.

5 days ago

‘I think, I think it’s actually collusion on the part of judges’: Stevens takes aim at Washin...

John Curley Show

‘It’s actually collusion’: WA Supreme Court candidate David Stevens takes aim at fellow judges

Washington Supreme Court candidate Judge David Stevens highlighted a lack of transparency about how judges shield one another.

6 days ago

‘That’s a problem’: Center Square editor speaks out on teen wrestler’s alleged assault by biological male