MYNORTHWEST NEWS

WA sheriff ‘loyalty oath’ law challenge moved to Thurston County ahead of key May hearing

Apr 19, 2026, 5:00 AM

killing girlfriend fox island 7.5 years sentenced...

A stock image of a gavel in a Washington courtroom. (Photo courtesy of Getty Images)

(Photo courtesy of Getty Images)

A legal challenge to Washington’s new sheriff eligibility law, including a controversial oath requirement, is being moved to Thurston County, where a similar case is already underway.

Judge Adam Walser of Lincoln County Superior Court declined Thursday to rule on the merits of the case or issue an emergency injunction, instead siding with the state and ordering the venue change.

Walser said consolidating the cases in one court would help avoid conflicting rulings across Washington. He also determined the situation did not rise to the level of an emergency requiring immediate court intervention.

The lawsuit was filed by four eastern WA sheriffs

John Nowels, Glenn Blakeslee, Brad Manke, and Ray Maycumber filed the lawsuit, all of whom are up for election this year.

They are challenging a newly signed law by Gov. Bob Ferguson that requires sheriff candidates to meet specific qualifications and sign a sworn statement confirming compliance with standards set by the Criminal Justice Training Commission.

Those requirements include a minimum of five years of law enforcement experience, age limits, and no disqualifying criminal history.

The sheriffs argue the law is unconstitutional and amounts to a “loyalty oath” that could allow the state to control who can run for sheriff instead of voters. Their attorney also argued the requirement could infringe on free speech.

“We’re talking about the gravest possible consequence under the First Amendment … where time is of the essence,” Attorney Mark Lamb explained. “In this situation, that an abridgment of a First Amendment right, even for minimal periods of time, unquestionably constitutes an irreparable injury.”

That date comes just days before the May 4–8 candidate filing window, when sheriff candidates must submit the required sworn statements under the new law, setting up a fast-moving legal battle with potential statewide impact.

State attorneys, led by Solicitor General Noah Purcell, counter that sheriff candidates already certify similar standards under existing law and say the lawsuit is based on a misunderstanding of the statute.

“All of the plaintiff sheriffs are currently certified by the Criminal Justice Training Commission. They are currently certified under the exact standard that they’re saying they can’t possibly comply with,” Purcell said in court. “So, the idea that somehow, in the next two weeks, something’s going to change that will render them unable to comply with that law just doesn’t it doesn’t pass the smell test. It just doesn’t make any sense.”

The case now moves to Thurston County, where a related lawsuit is set for a key hearing on May 1.

Follow Luke Duecy on X. Read more of his stories here. Submit news tips here.

MyNorthwest News

doughnut shop...

MyNorthwest Staff

Beloved doughnut shop closes Tacoma location

A beloved Tacoma doughnut shop made the tough decision to close its Tacoma location.

6 hours ago

Nooksack High School...

KIRO 7 News Staff

15-year-old arrested after threats made at Nooksack High School

A 15-year-old student was arrested after allegedly threatening several people at Nooksack High School.

7 hours ago

Tacoma St. Joseph strike...

Frank Lenzi

St. Joseph Medical Center workers issue strike notice; hospital plans replacement staff

More than 225 healthcare workers at St. Joseph Medical Center in Tacoma are planning a three-day strike starting Dec. 2.

8 hours ago

seattle (9)...

James Lynch

Man tells Seattle police his backpack held explosive, prompting closures near Capitol Hill precinct

All roads near the Seattle Police Department precinct in Capitol Hill have been reopened after a suspicious package was found to pose no threat to the public.

8 hours ago

Spokane Complex Fires (1)...

Lexi Herda, KIRO 7 News

After devastating Washington wildfires, lawmakers push for tougher penalties for arson

After intentionally set fires contributed to the destruction of hundreds of Washington homes this summer, state leaders want to create a new crime.

8 hours ago

Red Cup Day...

Julia Dallas

Starbucks announces Red Cup Day; Mayor Wilson joined workers’ protest at last year’s event

Starbucks has announced the return of Red Cup Day, where customers get a free limited-edition reusable red cup.

9 hours ago

WA sheriff ‘loyalty oath’ law challenge moved to Thurston County ahead of key May hearing