‘Come hate us’: Jake and Spike divided over pub adding 20% tip for bad tippers
Nov 22, 2026, 5:00 AM
A North Carolina pub that adds a 20% gratuity to the bills of repeat bad tippers divided KIRO hosts Jake Skorheim and Spike O’Neill. Spike would put up the same sign in his own restaurant. Jake believes the pub made itself a target.
“What this guy did is he planted a flag, and he said, ‘Hey, everybody out there who doesn’t like tipping, which is everyone, come hate us,’” Jake said on “The Jake and Spike Show” on KIRO Newsradio.
Freeman’s Grub & Pub in Greensboro faced a wave of online anger after a photo of its tipping policy spread on Reddit, according to The New York Post. Customers who tip poorly twice without explaining why get an automatic 20% gratuity on future visits, and the pub keeps their receipts as proof.
Owners Kevin and Emily Purcell told The New York Post the rule has been around for five months and 10 regulars are now on the list. In their view, leaving less than 10% for table service counts as a poor tip.
Owner: ‘It’s 2026’
The hosts played a video Kevin Purcell posted to defend the policy. He argued that diners should know what’s expected by now.
“But I will say that it’s 2026, right? And you should know by now the rules of engagement, expectations to tip at a bar or restaurant,” Purcell said.
He described his staff as professionals who rely on tips to support their families.
“That money goes to feed their kids, to take care of their families, try to survive in this economy, just like everybody else,” Purcell said.
Jake wasn’t moved.
“Yada yada yada. Save the whales,” Jake said.
Spike: ‘Good riddance’
Spike, who has worked in restaurants, would follow the pub’s lead.
“I would put up a sign,” Spike said.
He pointed to how slim restaurant margins are and how much servers depend on tips. Spike always counts the tip as part of the cost of a meal.
“I always factor in the tip as part of what I expect to pay when I go out and I dine,” Spike said.
Bad service is a different story, Spike noted, such as food that arrives late and cold or a rude server. But when the service is good, he has no use for customers who skip the tip.
“If you’re getting everything you should expect from a server, and you decide not to tip, you know I don’t want your business,” Spike said. “I’d rather make room for people in my restaurant who can appreciate what my staff does.”
He’s fine with losing customers who refuse to tip.
“Good riddance,” Spike said.
Emily Purcell expressed a similar view.
“Honestly, all of the people that are commenting in a negative way, we don’t really want them at Freeman’s, and neither does our staff,” she told The New York Post.
Jake: Talk to them, don’t post a sign
Jake, who also worked in food service, would never post a sign like that. Running a restaurant is hard enough, he argued, and public outrage only makes it harder. He predicted the pub won’t last another six months.
He can’t imagine bad tipping is a widespread problem there. If it is, Jake believes the servers probably aren’t as good as the owners think, since most people tip for decent service. He suggested dealing with problem customers one at a time.
“You are not required by law to provide them service. You can approach them, be like, ‘Listen, you guys have been stiffing our staff when you guys come in. This is a private establishment. We don’t have to serve you,’” Jake said.
Spike noted that the person who posted the sign online vowed never to return. The poster told Reddit it was their first and last visit, according to The New York Post.
Jake suspects the policy reflects badly on the owners. As he sees it, a pub with that many non-tippers may have management and training problems, and its servers may not have earned the tips.
Watch the full discussion in the video above.
Listen to “The Jake and Spike Show” weekdays from noon to 3 p.m. on KIRO Newsradio 97.3


