JOHN CURLEY

‘I don’t know that there’s a credible argument for the other side’: WA Supreme Court candidate Edwards challenges income tax

Oct 26, 2026, 5:00 AM | Updated: 3:08 pm

Washington Supreme Court candidate Scott Edwards argued that the state constitution treats income as property and that judges should not reinterpret that language to advance a preferred tax policy.

Joining “The John Curley Show” on KIRO Newsradio, Edwards criticized the court’s approach to tax cases and its recent decision overturning Washington’s natural gas initiative. He framed his campaign as an effort to restore judicial independence and public confidence.

When KIRO host John Curley asked how he would argue against treating income as property, Edwards rejected the premise.

“I don’t know that there’s a credible argument for the other side on that,” Edwards said.

Edwards is challenging Justice Colleen Melody for Supreme Court Position 1. Gov. Bob Ferguson appointed Melody last year after she worked in the Attorney General’s Office, according to The Seattle Times.

Edwards argues judges should interpret law, not make policy

Curley opened with a baseball analogy, comparing judicial impartiality to an umpire calling balls and strikes without favoring a player.

He questioned whether Melody’s previous work for Ferguson could create concerns about her independence in a future challenge to the state’s income tax. Those concerns were Curley’s argument, not an established finding of a conflict of interest.

Edwards maintained that a justice’s responsibility is to apply the Constitution and the law rather than advance the governor’s agenda.

“The role of the Supreme Court is to interpret the law as it’s written in accordance with the Constitution, without regard to the judge’s policy views, not to act as an extra legislative body to make sure that the governor’s policy gets upheld,” Edwards said.

Asked how he would restore trust in the court, Edwards pointed to that same distinction between interpreting law and pursuing policy.

“That is interpreting the law as it’s written without regard to the justices’ political views,” he said.

Natural gas ruling becomes a campaign issue

Edwards identified the court’s decision overturning the voter-approved natural gas initiative as an example of what he considers judicial overreach.

He explained that the majority found the initiative violated the state constitution’s single-subject requirement. Edwards disagreed with that conclusion, arguing that repealing a statute and prohibiting regulations with the same effect could fall under one subject.

He also emphasized the dissent’s discussion of the people’s constitutional power to enact laws through initiatives.

Edwards has pointed to both the natural gas decision and the court’s ruling upholding Washington’s capital gains tax as examples of judges allowing policy preferences to shape their legal analysis, The Seattle Times reported. 

Curley asked whether frustration over the natural gas ruling could motivate voters to pay closer attention to judicial elections.

“Well, that’s certainly been my campaign’s experience so far. The natural gas initiative decision seems to have really captured people’s attention and caused people to realize how important the Supreme Court is, the effect they have on Washingtonians’ everyday lives,” Edwards said.

The constitutional question over income

Turning to the income tax, Edwards explained that the central question begins with the Constitution’s definition of property and its requirement that property of the same class be taxed uniformly.

He argued that income falls within that definition and endorsed the reasoning of the court’s 1933 decision in Culliton v. Chase.

Edwards maintained that changing the constitutional framework is possible, but that doing so should happen through an amendment rather than a judicial reinterpretation.

“It’s certainly possible to amend the Constitution to change the definition of property or to remove that restriction altogether,” Edwards said.

His opponent has taken a less definitive public position on the question. According to The Seattle Times, Melody described Washington’s tax system as complex, citing cases distinguishing property taxes from excise taxes, while Edwards unequivocally characterized income as property.

Edwards criticizes capital gains tax reasoning

Edwards also challenged the court’s reasoning in upholding Washington’s capital gains tax.

He argued that the decision’s opening discussion of fairness in Washington’s tax structure signaled a policy-driven approach rather than an analysis focused on the legal question.

In Edwards’ view, whether a judge supports a more progressive tax system should not determine whether a particular tax complies with the Constitution.

“Whether you agree or disagree with the policy enacted by either the people or the legislature, you need to follow the law, call it as it is, as written in accordance with the Constitution,” Edwards said.

Curley closed by endorsing Edwards’ emphasis on constitutional limits and thanking him for running.

Watch the full discussion in the video above.

Listen to “The John Curley Show” weekdays from 3 p.m. to 7 p.m. on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM.

John Curley on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM
  • listen to tom and curleyTune in to KIRO Newsradio weekdays at 3pm for The John Curley Show.

John Curley

John Curley

wa income tax ferguson...

John Curley Show

‘That money’s not going to be there’: Curley warns residents could leave WA as Ferguson counts on income tax revenue

John Curley criticized state spending and questioned Gov. Ferguson’s confidence in future tax revenue as Washington faces a projected $4 billion shortfall.

1 day ago

Washington Purple Jim Walsh Curley Libertarian State WA...

John Curley Show

‘Jim, what are you talking about?’: Curley challenges Jim Walsh’s claim that WA is a libertarian-leaning purple state

KIRO Newsradio host John Curley challenged Washington State Republican Party Chair Jim Walsh’s description of Washington as a libertarian-leaning purple state.

2 days ago

Seattle Cameras CCTV AI Mayor Katie Wilson...

John Curley Show

‘That’s always the big problem’: Curley questions data privacy as Mayor Wilson expands Seattle surveillance cameras

KIRO Newsradio host John Curley questioned whether Seattle’s planned safeguards for police surveillance cameras can keep pace with technology.

3 days ago

Microsoft president...

John Curley Show

‘They take the jobs with them’: Curley doubts Olympia will heed Microsoft’s call for budget stability

KIRO host John Curley is skeptical that state leaders will follow Microsoft President Brad Smith’s call for budget stability and affordability.

3 days ago

Follow @https://twitter.com/jcurleyshow...

John Curley Show

‘One party with two jerseys’: Former Evergreen professor Bret Weinstein outlines plan to take over Libertarian Party

Bret Weinstein said his American Liberty Party aims to break the hold of the Republican and Democratic parties by taking over the Libertarian Party.

6 days ago

Follow @https://twitter.com/jcurleyshow...

John Curley Show

‘She went against everybody that had gotten her in there’: Curley questions Katie Wilson’s Seattle CCTV expansion

John Curley characterized Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson’s decision to expand police surveillance cameras as a break with the supporters who helped elect her.

6 days ago

‘I don’t know that there’s a credible argument for the other side’: WA Supreme Court candidate Edwards challenges income tax