KIRO NEWSRADIO OPINION

‘No urgency’: Gee, Ursula slam response to Garfield student’s shooting death amid familial lawsuit

May 13, 2025, 4:03 PM

garfield high school bitcoin bomb threat...

Exterior of Garfield High School in Seattle's Central District neighborhood. (Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)

(Photo courtesy of KIRO 7)

The family of a 17-year-old Garfield High School student who was killed just outside the campus last year is suing the school district.

The lawsuit alleges the school’s “negligent security practices” allowed Amarr Murphy-Paine, 17, to die, according to The Seattle Times. Murphy-Paine was killed on June 6. There have been no arrests related to the shooting, as of this reporting.

“So far as we have been telling you, no witnesses have come forward to ID the person who pulled the trigger, even though there were witnesses,” Ursula Reutin, co-host of “The Gee and Ursula Show” on KIRO Newsradio, said.

Gee Scott, co-host of “Gee and Ursula,” offered a solution.

“Ursula, here’s a solution. How much is the reward money? $50,000? Let’s make it $100,000. Let’s solve this case now,” Gee said. “There needs to be urgency, and I don’t feel that there’s urgency. I don’t feel that there’s urgency because it’s at Garfield High School. If this happened at Bellevue High School and there was video footage of someone losing their life, you mean to tell me a year later, we still wouldn’t have answers? There needs to be more urgency, and, in my opinion, it’s just not enough.”

Murphy-Paine was on the school’s varsity football team and was just days away from graduation when he was killed. According to the Seattle Police Department (SPD), he was allegedly trying to break up a fight between two other male students when an unknown individual shot him multiple times.

The lawsuit was filed by Amarr’s father, mother, stepmother, and brother. The family believes his death was preventable and was a culmination of open campus policies and inadequate security measures from the school.

“I think they’ve got a lot of details in this particular lawsuit that would help them win it, but it doesn’t bring their son back,” Ursula said. “But I don’t blame them for filing this lawsuit.”

“I don’t blame them either, and I really believe Ursula, in my heart, that there are a lot of people who actually probably know information that they’re sitting on,” Gee said. “Information that would help solve this case. Hence, the reason why I brought up the reward. I don’t think the reward money should come from the family. I think the reward should come from either the city or the district.”

Should school resource officers return?

According to KIRO 7, SPD Chief Shon Barnes said his department is ready to reinstall school resource officers onto campuses, but there are several hurdles in the way—one being lifting or removing a 2020 moratorium that suspended the district’s partnership with police, including removing officers from campuses.

“I am continuing to get angry, we were during our show in 2020 when the whole idea of taking resource officers from the school was happening, and both you and I kept saying, ‘No. No!'” Gee said. “And that was literally the same time you had screams for people saying, ‘Defund the police.’ ‘We don’t need police departments.'”

“I will tell you right now, because I just had a conversation with a current Seattle police officer who says that they are still dealing with the aftereffects of that whole (decision) to this day,” Ursula added. “I mean, they’re really trying to address that because it was a morale killer.”

Listen to the full conversation here.

Listen to Gee and Ursula on “The Gee and Ursula Show” weekday mornings from 9 am to 12 pm on KIRO Newsradio. 

Gee and Ursula Show

KIRO Newsradio Opinion

A photo of a Social Security card and money. (Photo: nodar77 via Envato)...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘That’s unacceptable’: Ursula criticizes Social Security uncertainty as AARP projections show funding for only 80% of promised benefits

AARP warns funding for Social Security benefits may drop to 80%, raising concerns over the program's financial stability.

21 hours ago

Denny Blaine Seattle LGBTQ...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘This is a beautiful thing’: Gee praises Seattle’s celebration of Denny Blaine Park’s LGBTQ history amid nude beach controversy

Seattle honors Denny Blaine Park's LGBTQ history after years of debate, uniting community leaders and members in celebration.

2 days ago

microsoft outage...

Luke Duecy

The Spin: Microsoft outage and how the company used PR to manage a global service disruption

A major Microsoft outage disrupted Outlook, Teams, Copilot, and other Microsoft 365 services for two days.

2 days ago

Follow @https://twitter.com/jcurleyshow...

John Curley Show

‘She went against everybody that had gotten her in there’: Curley questions Katie Wilson’s Seattle CCTV expansion

John Curley characterized Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson’s decision to expand police surveillance cameras as a break with the supporters who helped elect her.

3 days ago

Seattle Freeways tailgaters...

Charlie Harger

Harger: Turn signals, tailgaters, and the 5 most annoying drivers on Seattle freeways

I drive to work in the dark, and I’m coming down the ramp from westbound Highway 18 onto northbound I-5. Wipers going. Coffee in the cupholder. A semi is barreling down the right lane, and there’s a car in front of me on the ramp.

3 days ago

vote (2)...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘It matters’: Gee and Ursula point to 4-vote WA House race as proof every ballot counts

If you've ever thought your vote doesn't matter, KIRO hosts Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin have an example from East Pierce County.

3 days ago

‘No urgency’: Gee, Ursula slam response to Garfield student’s shooting death amid familial lawsuit