KIRO NEWSRADIO OPINION

‘Why take the power away from the people?’: Jake and Spike split over the future of Pierce County sheriff elections

Oct 22, 2026, 6:03 AM

Pierce County voters will decide Nov. 3 whether to make the sheriff an appointed position instead of an elected office. Charter Amendment 53 would also end Sheriff Keith Swank’s current elected term on Jan. 1, 2027, with future sheriffs appointed by the county executive and confirmed by a majority of the County Council.

The proposal divided co-host Jake Skorheim and co-host Spike O’Neill during “The Jake and Spike Show” on KIRO Newsradio, with Jake defending direct voter control and Spike supporting appointment as a way to address qualifications and accountability.

“I like elected officials. My personal view on this is that they are more accountable to the voters and less accountable to the comings and goings of executives’ offices and city halls,” Jake said.

“People sometimes can vote for candidates who aren’t qualified because they rally around a political position they have or whatever it might be,” Spike said.

Appointment would require council confirmation

The sheriff is currently a nonpartisan elected official. Under Amendment 53, the executive’s selection would require approval from a majority of the council, rather than taking effect through the executive’s decision alone.

“It’s not just one person saying, ‘I want this guy to be sheriff,’” Spike said. “You’d have to have a majority of the County Council.”

Jake questioned how much influence the executive would hold.

“Why take the power away from the people?” Jake said.

Spike emphasized that voters would decide whether to change the system.

“I like the fact that the voters get to decide if they’re going to put this power in the hands of the executive and a council, as opposed to them just taking that power from the citizenry,” Spike said.

Qualifications and removal become the focus

Supporters of the amendment argue that appointment would allow a wider search for qualified candidates. Opponents favor keeping the sheriff directly accountable to voters.

Spike posed hypothetical situations involving a sheriff who no longer met the qualifications for office.

“If they don’t meet the qualifications for the job, should the voters be able to say we want them anyway?” Spike said. “The people shouldn’t be able to vote past the regulations of the office qualifications.”

Jake rejected using those hypothetical cases as a reason to change the selection process.

“This is such a crazy hypothetical. It’s literally never happened,” Jake said. “So to take the power away from the people for a crazy hypothetical, I don’t accept the premise of your hypothetical.”

Recall process raises a separate disagreement

The hosts also disagreed about whether a recall election provides sufficient accountability. Jake described judicial review and a public vote as protections against removing an official without adequate grounds.

“Recall is limited to specific grounds. The official committed acts of malfeasance or misfeasance while in office, or violated the oath of office,” Jake said. “That’s the power of the people.”

Spike questioned what should happen if voters declined to remove an official despite an oath violation.

“But he still violated his oath of office. Shouldn’t the county have an ability to take him out if he violates his oath of office?” Spike said.

“That’s their decision,” Jake responded.

Pierce County has used both systems

Pierce County previously had appointed sheriffs before returning the office to elections. Former Sheriff Paul Pastor, who served under both systems, opposes Amendment 53, according to Gig Harbor Now.

The amendment is one of seven proposed charter changes on Pierce County’s November ballot.

Watch the full discussion in the video above.

Listen to “The Jake and Spike Show” weekdays from noon to 3 p.m. on KIRO Newsradio 97.3

KIRO Newsradio Opinion

turkey prep...

Charlie Harger

Big turkey? You may need to start defrosting it today. Here’s your Thanksgiving 2026 schedule by weight

Check your freezer. If there's a big turkey in there, it may need to start defrosting today.

2 hours ago

school employeesWashington Superintendent of Public Instruction Chris Reykdal...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘Why does it have to be left v. lefter?’: Jake challenges WA’s political options as Reykdal considers higher office

Jake Skorheim examines Washington's political landscape as Reykdal eyes higher office, exploring implications for future elections.

5 hours ago

Jimothy Seattle City Council Rob Saka...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘It’s still a very bad idea’: Jake and Spike mock illuminated Jimothy statue with impression

A discussion about an illuminated Jimothy raccoon statue turned into a mock Seattle City Council meeting where Spike O’Neill impersonated Councilmember Rob Saka.

6 hours ago

seattle publics schools reporter superintendent...

Charlie Harger

Harger: Families asked a reporter to cover their school closure meeting. Seattle Public Schools tried to throw her out

The Seattle School Board gave the superintendent, Ben Shuldiner, even more control over that process and dropped the requirement that he publicly explain why a school needs to close.

6 hours ago

toxic relationship...

Ursula Reutin

Ask Ursula: Should I stay in a toxic relationship because dating in Seattle in my 50s is hard?

Should you stay in a toxic relationship because you’re afraid to be alone? Ursula weighs in.

9 hours ago

Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘It feels bad actory to me’: Jake doubts the tech outages were a coincidence as Microsoft CEO promises resilience

Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella said last week’s global outage showed how much the world depends on his company’s services.

20 hours ago

‘Why take the power away from the people?’: Jake and Spike split over the future of Pierce County sheriff elections