LIFESTYLE

Judge says Smucker’s lawsuit against Trader Joe’s over frozen sandwiches can proceed.

Aug 31, 2026, 2:12 PM

FILE - Crust-less sandwiches from Smucker's and Trader Joe's are displayed on Oct. 15, 2025, in Det...

FILE - Crust-less sandwiches from Smucker's and Trader Joe's are displayed on Oct. 15, 2025, in Detroit. (AP Photo/Ryan Sun, File)
Credit: AP Photo/Ryan Sun

(AP Photo/Ryan Sun, File)

A federal judge has ruled that J.M. Smucker can proceed with a lawsuit against Trader Joe’s over frozen sandwiches that Smucker claims are too similar to its Uncrustables.

Smucker sued Trader Joe’s in federal court in Ohio last fall, claiming Trader Joe’s committed a trademark violation when it introduced frozen peanut butter and jelly sandwiches with the same round shape and crimped edges as Uncrustables.

The lawsuit further alleged that Trader Joe’s put its crustless PB&Js peanut in packaging that too closely resembled the coloring of an Uncrustables box and featured a similar photograph of a sandwich with a bite taken out of one side.

In court filings, Trader Joe’s said its frozen sandwiches aren’t round but shaped as “squircles,” or square sandwiches with rounded edges. The company said the crimped design is necessary to keep the contents inside the sandwich and Smucker, based in Orrville, Ohio, shouldn’t be allowed to monopolize it.

Trader Joe’s also said Smucker’s current Uncrustables packaging, which it only introduced in 2024, is not famous enough to meet the standards of a federal trademark dilution claim.

“Smucker reaches too far. Its sandwiches’ appearance and cartoon avatar are no Nike swoosh or McDonald’s golden arches,” Trader Joe’s said in a January court filing that asked for the case to be dismissed.

But U.S. District Judge John Adams ruled Friday that Smucker had devoted significant resources to developing Uncrustables and protecting the brand in the past 20 years. Adams said customers have come to associate Uncrustables’ design trademarks with the brand.

The judge also declined Trader Joe’s request to move the case to California, where it is headquartered and where the third-party supplier of its frozen sandwiches is also located.

The Associated Press left messages seeking comment Monday with Trader Joe’s and Smucker.

Smucker is seeking restitution from Trader Joe’s. It also wants a judge to require Trader Joe’s to deliver all products and packaging to Smucker to be destroyed.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

Lifestyle

FILE - Fiona, a Nile Hippopotamus, swims after eating her specialty birthday cake to celebrate turn...

Associated Press

‘The most effective ambassador’: Fiona the hippo’s death sparks grief and talk about famous animals

Why do we mourn famous animals we don’t even know? Maybe it’s because the media — and, increasingly, social media — makes us feel like we know them intimately. Millions of people watched footage of Fiona the hippo at the Cincinnati Zoo wiggle out of her mom and into the world in 2017, struggle to […]

13 hours ago

FILE - Girl Scouts Caroline Jahr, 11, from left, Audrey Figari, 12, and Angelica Armstrong, 10, sor...

Associated Press

Crunchy, chewy and charitable, the Girl Scout cookie is an emblem of empowerment

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (AP) — Ding dong — the Girl Scout cookies are here! Whether delivered door to door, sold outside a grocery store or even dropped by drones, the arrival of Girl Scout cookie season is a time-honored tradition that people anticipate for months. More than century ago, a simple idea of a bake sale […]

17 hours ago

Seattle restaurant james beard...

Jason Sutich

Rising costs prompt James Beard nominee to rethink Seattle restaurant months after recognition

The owner of Café Suliman in Capitol Hill announced he will close his restaurant after three years, with plans to open a new concept in the same space.

20 hours ago

Melania Trump arrives at the world premiere of Amazon Prime Video's "Melania: The Series," Thursday...

Associated Press

Melania Trump gives a peek inside her marriage, motherhood and more in new series

NEW YORK (AP) — Melania Trump is back on screens on Friday with another behind-the-scenes look at her life before and after she became first lady, discussing her marriage to President Donald Trump, her relationship with son Barron and the healing power of a day at the spa. “Melania: The Series” is a two-part follow-up […]

22 hours ago

Santa...

Paul Holden

Photos with Santa, gingerbread, designer trees, and more this weekend in the Seattle area

Thanksgiving is next week — can you believe it? Ahead of time, we have a busy weekend of fun that is kicking off the holiday season.

23 hours ago

Bart Collart poses for a photograph by the grave of his son, Marine Cpl. Spencer R. Collart, who di...

Associated Press

For families of the fallen, Trump’s proposed arch casts a shadow over Arlington National Cemetery

WASHINGTON (AP) — Cpl. Spencer Collart’s headstone faces the rising sun and the Lincoln Memorial to the east. The Marine Corps War Memorial is nearby. Soon, President Donald Trump’s gilded, towering arch could be, too. Collart’s silent stone speaks volumes in its simplicity of courage, sacrifice and loss. It stands among thousands of uniform headstones […]

24 hours ago

Judge says Smucker’s lawsuit against Trader Joe’s over frozen sandwiches can proceed.