MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Charleena Lyles inquest: Jury finds officers used reasonable force in deadly 2017 shooting

Jul 6, 2022, 5:22 PM

Flowers and candles are pictured at a makeshift memorial during a vigil on the third anniversary of...

Flowers and candles are pictured at a makeshift memorial during a vigil on the third anniversary of the death of Charleena Lyles who was shot and killed by Seattle police in Seattle, Washington on June 18, 2020. (Photo by Jason Redmond / AFP) (Photo by JASON REDMOND/AFP via Getty Images)

(Photo by JASON REDMOND/AFP via Getty Images)

After days of hearing testimony in an inquest to ascertain the facts about the fatal shooting of Charleena Lyles, jurors deliberated and found that the two officers who fatally shot the mother of four used reasonable force.

The jury ruled it did not appear as though a reasonably effective alternative to deadly force existed, and that the amount of force used was reasonable.

They also determined that a stun gun would not have been a reasonably effective alternative, that officer complied with the use of force policy as it related to firearms, and that the officers’ actions were consistent with Seattle Police Department training.

They also determined officers did not comply with SPD policy on the use of force with a stun gun/electrical weapon.

On Father’s Day in 2017, Lyles, 30, called police to report a burglary at her Magnuson Park apartment.

Seattle police officers Jason Anderson and Steven McNew shot her seven times. They said Lyles suddenly came at them with a knife.

Lyles’ family insists she had a history of mental health problems and that the officers failed to de-escalate the situation before shooting her.

In the final day of testimony on Tuesday, McNew said there was no time to give Lyles detailed verbal warnings before he fired his gun.

He said he had to protect himself.

“I felt that, that was — in that moment, with what we had — trying to respond to her behavior, felt that it was clear that if I’ve got my gun pointed toward you and I’m a police officer, and you’re coming toward me with a knife and I say, ‘get back,’ that’s sufficient warning,” said McNew.

Anderson, the other officer, originally told investigators he was trapped in a confined space and his back was against a closed door when Lyles lunged at him, but surveillance video showed the officers backing up through an open door into a hallway.

Anderson agreed that his memory and the video don’t match.

“I was talking to Ms. Lyles. I was somewhere at the corner of the peninsula talking to Ms. Lyles, she’s in front of me, I see her produce the knife, she’s lunging it towards me and I did one of these (demonstrates a jump to the jury) movements. You know there’s very little space behind me and you know, I go for the hall, I hit the door — I don’t remember that,” said Anderson.

Both Anderson and McNew were cleared by Seattle police and are still on the job.



 

Please follow our Community Guidelines

MyNorthwest News

kitsap felon gun drugs...

Jason Sutich

Kitsap deputies find gun, drugs after felon found semi-unconscious in parked car

A 32-year-old Port Orchard man was arrested on Tuesday after he was found partially unconscious inside a parked car during a welfare check.

7 minutes ago

Amazon bite of seattle shooting vendors...

MyNorthwest Staff

Amazon donates $350K to vendors impacted by Bite of Seattle shooting

Amazon is donating $350,000 in aid for local food vendors and anyone impacted by the Bite of Seattle shooting at the Seattle Center.

42 minutes ago

containment spokane complex fires old trails autumn lane fairview...

MyNorthwest Staff

Containment progress for Spokane Complex Fires: Old Trails, Autumn Lane at 13% containment, Fairview at 5%

The Old Trails and Autumn Lane Fires are currently at 13% containment, as of this reporting, while the Fairview Fire is at 5% containment.

54 minutes ago

spokane wildfires arson...

Jake Chapman, KIRO 7 News

KIRO 7 interview: Witness recounts seeing Spokane arson suspect minutes before wildfires spark

A 37-year-old man faces first-degree arson charges and is being held on a $1 million bond for allegedly starting a wildfire that destroyed hundreds of homes near Spokane.

2 hours ago

Mariners jimothy seattle...

Jason Sutich

Mariners celebrate ‘Hot Jimothy Summer’ with special night honoring viral raccoon

The Mariners will tip their cap to Jimothy on Aug. 5, hosting a special "Jimothy Night" at T-Mobile Park when the team faces the Detroit Tigers at 6:40 p.m.

2 hours ago

washington ferry ferguson...

MyNorthwest Staff

Washington breaks ground on first new ferry in 11 years, three hybrid-electric vessels ordered

Governor Bob Ferguson announced construction is underway on the state's first new ferry in 11 years, stating a third hybrid-electric vessel has now been added to the order.

3 hours ago

Charleena Lyles inquest: Jury finds officers used reasonable force in deadly 2017 shooting