MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Hoping for life in prison, convicted murderer Joseph McEnroe breaks down on stand

Apr 6, 2015, 11:37 PM | Updated: Apr 7, 2015, 6:33 am

Joseph McEnroe told the courtroom he wanted to walk away, but his girlfriend was intent on killing ...

Joseph McEnroe told the courtroom he wanted to walk away, but his girlfriend was intent on killing six members of her family on Christmas Eve 2007. (Pool photo)

(Pool photo)

In a bid to avoid the death penalty, Joseph McEnroe continued testifying Monday before a King County jury, saying repeatedly he was forced to commit murder by his manipulative girlfriend, Michele Anderson.

He said he wanted to walk away, but Michele was intent on killing six members of her family on Christmas Eve 2007. McEnroe was found guilty on six counts of first-degree murder on March 25.

“She had a lot of anger and a lot of hatred, and she thought the best way to act on that was to go off and kill people.”

Michele was supposedly upset at her family over money and years of what she perceived as disrespect.

McEnroe claimed at one point during their relationship, on a daily basis he would look down the barrel of his gun and consider shooting himself.

“The only reason I didn’t actually [do it] is it would have made a huge mess, and would have left her vulnerable,” he said, referring to Michele.

During one bizarre turn in his testimony, McEnroe told the jury he threatened to castrate himself when Michele verbally abused him.

“I was going to just do it, and she stopped me. She said ‘Look, we don’t have insurance.'”

McEnroe then described how he and Michele began to wipe out three generations of Andersons. It started when the pair walked over from their mobile home, only a few hundred yards from Michele’s parents’ house, for a family celebration on Christmas Eve.

Michele first argued with Wayne, and took a shot at her father. She missed, and when her gun jammed, Wayne allegedly charged Michele.

That’s when McEnroe said he stepped in to finish the job.

“I killed him. I shot him in the head,” he explained.

Michele’s mother, Judy, witnessed the whole thing from the kitchen. McEnroe shot her next.

“The last thing she said was ‘no, no!'” McEnroe’s voice rose and became shrill in court.

In the aftermath, the murderers had to decide how to dispose of the bodies of Wayne and Judy, before Michele’s brother Scott, Erica, and their children showed up at the house.

When he discussed hiding Judy’s body, McEnroe appeared to emotionally break down on the stand, grabbing his head and violently shaking.

“I put a bag over her head because I couldn’t look at her, or see the emptiness where she should be,” he cried.

Eventually, with the help of his attorney, the convicted murderer reclaimed his composure.

King County prosecutors are expected to cross-examine McEnroe beginning Tuesday.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

MyNorthwest News

king county courthouse security...

Frank Lenzi

King County courthouse logs more than 50 security reports in 2026, including judge assault

More than 50 security incident reports have been filed at the King County Courthouse so far in 2026, including an assault on a judge in their courtroom.

31 minutes ago

surveillance camera...

Julia Dallas

Wilson turns stadium district cameras back on, authorizes SPD expansion

Seattle Mayor Wilson announced she is turning on the stadium district cameras immediately and allowing the SPD to expand its camera network.

1 hour ago

I-001 parents bill of rights...

Frank Sumrall

Parents’ bill of rights initiative I-001 fails to pass

Initial results show Initiative 001 narrowly trailing, with 52.77% of votes counted opposed and 47.23% in favor. The measure seeks to restore the original 2024 parents’ bill of rights by undoing changes made by the Washington Legislature last year.

2 hours ago

cle elum arrest dead...

KIRO 7 News Staff

15-year-old found dead during Cle Elum arrest operation

A 15-year-old boy was found dead inside a Cle Elum-area home Monday after deputies attempted to serve an arrest warrant.

2 hours ago

seattle paramount oh mary record...

Manda Factor

‘Oh, Mary!’ sets $2.5 million box office record at Seattle’s Paramount Theatre

The production of “Oh, Mary!” grossed more than $2.5 million in Seattle, setting a record for the highest-grossing week for a play at the Paramount Theatre.

3 hours ago

Seattle fall out boy tour...

Julie Berg, KIRO 7

Fall Out Boy announces 2027 Seattle stop for Twilight of the Punks Tour

The Seattle Mariners announced Monday that Fall Out Boy will bring their Twilight of the Punks North America Stadium Tour to T-Mobile Park on Aug. 24, 2027.

4 hours ago

Hoping for life in prison, convicted murderer Joseph McEnroe breaks down on stand