MYNORTHWEST NEWS

State Supreme Court upholds B&O tax on large banks in Washington

Sep 30, 2021, 1:52 PM | Updated: Oct 1, 2021, 6:39 am

B&O tax banks Washington...

A Wells Fargo location in downtown Seattle. (Can Pac Swire, Flickr Creative Commons)

The Supreme Court of Washington State reversed a lower court decision on Thursday, ruling that a B&O tax on banks doing business in Washington state is indeed constitutional.

Washington state lawmakers push to suspend Boeing tax breaks

The tax was passed by the state Legislature in 2019, enacting an additional 1.2% B&O levy on financial institutions worth at least $1 billion.

The Washington Bankers Association and the American Bankers Association filed a lawsuit over the tax later that year, claiming that it violated the U.S. Constitution’s Commerce Clause by only targeting out-of-state institutions, and giving banks in Washington an unfair advantage. The groups’ initial filing also alleged that the measure violated the Washington State Constitution due to its initial status as a “title-only” bill.

“Title-only” bills basically function like a legislative IOU — lawmakers first introduce a bill with a title and no text, and then amend it to add the actual provisions later on. In the case of this tax, the bill’s substantive policies weren’t fleshed out until the final two days of the legislative session. The WBA and ABA claimed that violated a clause in the state Constitution requiring bills be introduced at least 10 days before the session ends.

That claim was thrown out in a lower court, with the state Supreme Court subsequently stating that “this case is not the proper venue to collaterally attack or relitigate a dismissed issue.” Regardless, justices did also note that plaintiffs “offered little argument and no case law or persuasive authorities in support” of their argument pertaining to “title-only” bills.

State lawmaker: Capital gains tax ‘not necessarily’ the first step toward income tax

The state Supreme Court voted 8-1 against the banking groups’ other claims, pointing out that the B&O tax “applies equally to all financial institutions meeting the $1 billion income threshold, irrespective of whether they are based inside or outside of Washington.”

State Attorney General Bob Ferguson praised the court’s decision on Thursday, saying that it “correctly applies the law and is a win for those fighting to make Washington’s tax system fairer.”

“I’m proud of my team’s work to uphold Washington’s new progressive tax on the tremendously most profitable large banks operating in Washington,” he added.

KIRO Radio reporter Hanna Scott contributed to this story.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

MyNorthwest News

doughnut shop...

MyNorthwest Staff

Beloved doughnut shop closes Tacoma location

A beloved Tacoma doughnut shop made the tough decision to close its Tacoma location.

5 hours ago

Nooksack High School...

KIRO 7 News Staff

15-year-old arrested after threats made at Nooksack High School

A 15-year-old student was arrested after allegedly threatening several people at Nooksack High School.

6 hours ago

Tacoma St. Joseph strike...

Frank Lenzi

St. Joseph Medical Center workers issue strike notice; hospital plans replacement staff

More than 225 healthcare workers at St. Joseph Medical Center in Tacoma are planning a three-day strike starting Dec. 2.

6 hours ago

seattle (9)...

James Lynch

Man tells Seattle police his backpack held explosive, prompting closures near Capitol Hill precinct

All roads near the Seattle Police Department precinct in Capitol Hill have been reopened after a suspicious package was found to pose no threat to the public.

6 hours ago

Spokane Complex Fires (1)...

Lexi Herda, KIRO 7 News

After devastating Washington wildfires, lawmakers push for tougher penalties for arson

After intentionally set fires contributed to the destruction of hundreds of Washington homes this summer, state leaders want to create a new crime.

6 hours ago

Red Cup Day...

Julia Dallas

Starbucks announces Red Cup Day; Mayor Wilson joined workers’ protest at last year’s event

Starbucks has announced the return of Red Cup Day, where customers get a free limited-edition reusable red cup.

7 hours ago

State Supreme Court upholds B&O tax on large banks in Washington