MYNORTHWEST POLITICS

‘Disturbing:’ Supporters stunned to hear of failed legal effort to kill ballot initiatives

Aug 10, 2024, 9:46 AM | Updated: 10:57 am

Washington Democrats initiatives...

Hedge fund owner and Let's Go Washington founder Brian Heywood can be seen at a Shell gas station in Kent on Tuesday, Nov. 21, 2023. (Photo: Kate Stone, KIRO Newsradio)

(Photo: Kate Stone, KIRO Newsradio)

The Washington Supreme Court issued two rulings Friday dismissing related lawsuit appeals brought by organizations attempting to stop certifying the voter initiatives that were set for placement on the general election ballot in November.

In two separate cases, the groups sued Washington Secretary of State Steve Hobbs and sought to enact similar actions: challenging the process of certifying the signatures procured and seeking an injunction to remove the initiatives from the November ballot as Hobbs’ office reconfirms the signatures came from legal voters.

In the first case, Defend Washington and two voters sued Hobbs, challenging “certification of signatures on five voter initiative petitions,” according to the Washington Supreme Court decision delivered Friday.

“At issue in the appeal is whether the secretary permissibly certified the signatures on the sole basis that the signatures matched those found in the voter rolls,” the decision reads. (Readers can view a PDF of the court’s decision here.)

Sen. Mark Mullet after the primary: ‘I thought there were more moderate Democrats’

In the second and most recent case, the Washington Conservation Action Education Fund (WCAEF) and two citizens sued Hobbs for an order requiring Hobbs “to cease counting signatures for ballot initiative 2066 using present signature verification procedures.”

“Principally at issue is whether the secretary’s verification based solely on matching petition signatures to signatures found in the voter rolls is insufficient, and whether the secretary must also verify signers’ addresses, the decision states. (Readers can view a PDF of the court’s decision here.)

The decisions, both signed by Washington Supreme Court Chief Justice Steven C. González, both stated that, “An opinion fully explaining the court’s decision will be issued at a later time. ”

If the challenges had been successful, the citizen initiatives that would have come off the ballot included repealing the state’s capital gains tax (I-2109), ending its cap-and-trade program and repealing sections of the Climate Commitment Act (I-2117), making participation in a long-term care program run by the state optional (I-2124) and eliminating natural-gas restrictions in new construction projects (I-2066).

‘Disturbing’: Why supporters of initiative were surprised appeals got this far

Brian Heywood of Let’s Go Washington, the group formed to tackle these citizen initiatives, told another Seattle media outlet in an interview that he found out about appeals Friday, hours before the ruling and only because Washington State Standard reporter Jerry Cornfield reached out to his organization about documents he discovered.

In an interview with “The John Curley and Jake Skorheim Show” on KIRO Newsradio Friday, State Republican Rep. and Washington Republican Party Chairman Jim Walsh called the legal moves by these organizations “a terrible story” and “disturbing” as they sued Hobbs alone to have the initiatives removed and didn’t name others in the suit. That means they didn’t need to be informed.

“I, who was the sponsor initiatives, was not a party the lawsuit,” Walsh said. “Brian Heywood, and let’s go Washington, who were the main marketing, supporting signature gathering organization were not notified because they were not named in the lawsuit.”

KIRO Newsradio interview: Head here or click on the player below to listen to the chat with Rep. Jim Walsh

Walsh went on to explain the office of Washington State Office of the Attorney General Bob Ferguson never informed the potentially interested parties of the lawsuits, insulting the court maneuvering in the process.

Projection: Ferguson, Reichert to square off in state governor’s race

“The real shady part of this is that the state attorney general’s office, who normally would notify parties of interest in this kind of lawsuit, never said a word,” Walsh said. “So it’s very disturbing. Some would say it is unconstitutional, unprofessional, not kosher, whatever you want to say, it’s a very strange situation.”

Walsh did acknowledge the lawsuits weren’t illegal. He just believes that from an ethical perspective, mistakes were made since he wasn’t notified.

“Ethically and professionally and normal practice is that they would, and that never happened here,” Walsh said on KIRO Newsradio. “And it’s it’s egregious, in my opinion.”

That said, Walsh insulted the move of the “snow flakey radical left groups” to bring this type of action forward,

“It is so hypocritical, it’s hard to even talk about it, the idea that the same people scream and whine about saving democracy when they’re doing these incredibly undemocratic, sneaky, authoritarian, sleazy things,” Walsh said.

MyNorthwest politics: More stories and analysis from the primaries

Other reactions to the lawsuits about the ballot initiatives

In a statement sent to KIRO Newsradio and AM 770 KTTH Friday referring specifically to the WCAEF lawsuit about I-2066, Building Industry Association of Washington Executive Vice President Greg Lane said his organization was “pleased” the people who signed the petition “will have the opportunity to vote on this in November.” He also called called out the lawsuit as not democratic.

“These frivolous attempts to keep the voters from having a voice when it comes to energy choice are undemocratic and nothing short of voter suppression,” Lane said. “In essence, they are conceding through these desperate tactics that they know Washingtonians want energy choice.

Jackson Maynard, executive director and counsel of the Citizen Action Defense fund, offered his legal opinion to The Center Square about the development of the cases, calling it “really troubling.”

“In 22 years of legal practice, I’ve never seen a case progress this far without all necessary parties being before the court or at least being given the courtesy of a phone call about litigation as important as this,” he told the outlet.

MyNorthwest reached out to Defend Washington and the WCAEF for comments late Friday about the cases and has not yet received responses. Defend Washington did send a statement to the Washington State Standard, which called the decision “disappointing.” The organization reiterated that it had concerns, but it would abide by the ruling.

Steve Coogan is the lead editor of MyNorthwest. You can read more of his stories here. Follow Steve on X, or email him here.

MyNorthwest Politics

Leesa Manion - King County...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘Three days of medication and not much else’: King County prosecutor calls for fixes to WA’s involuntary treatment system

People released after being involuntarily committed for mental health or substance use treatment in King County often leave with little support.

2 days ago

Follow @https://twitter.com/jcurleyshow...

John Curley Show

‘One party with two jerseys’: Former Evergreen professor Bret Weinstein outlines plan to take over Libertarian Party

Bret Weinstein said his American Liberty Party aims to break the hold of the Republican and Democratic parties by taking over the Libertarian Party.

2 days ago

Brown - transgender ban...

Julia Dallas

WA attorney general’s office appoints outside law firm to defend transgender sports ban

The Washington AG's Office announced it appointed an outside law firm to defend I-638, which will bar transgender girls from girls' school sports.

3 days ago

Reykdal Governor Ferguson Schools WA...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘We’ll keep bringing the facts, and others can keep bringing the politics’: Reykdal pushes back at Ferguson, won’t rule out governor run

Washington schools Superintendent Chris Reykdal pushed back against Gov. Bob Ferguson’s criticism of student performance and declined to rule out running for the governor’s job himself.

3 days ago

Wilson (2)...

Luke Duecy

Seattle council fails to override Wilson’s RV permit veto in 5-4 vote after heated exchange

Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson’s veto of an RV permit program stands after the Seattle City Council failed to override it Thursday.

3 days ago

Wilson (1)...

James Lynch

Seattle council to vote on overriding Wilson’s RV permit veto Thursday

A showdown is brewing between Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson and the Seattle City Council over RV parking.

5 days ago

‘Disturbing:’ Supporters stunned to hear of failed legal effort to kill ballot initiatives