NATIONAL NEWS

Appeals court sides with parent group in fight over Ohio school district’s pronoun policy

Nov 6, 2025, 8:00 PM

FILE - The William McKinley Monument is silhouetted near the Ohio Statehouse, April 15, 2024, in Co...

FILE - The William McKinley Monument is silhouetted near the Ohio Statehouse, April 15, 2024, in Columbus, Ohio. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster, File)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster, File)

COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) — A divided federal appeals court in Ohio ruled against the state’s fourth largest school district on Thursday in a case that pitted its gender pronoun policies against the rights of students who believe there are only two genders.

The full Sixth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the suburban Olentangy Local School District cannot prohibit students from using gender-related language deemed offensive, siding with Parents Defending Education, which had argued the policies were unconstitutional.

The national membership organization first filed suit against Olentangy in 2023, saying the district’s policies requiring the use of peers’ “preferred pronouns” were a violation of students’ rights under the First and Fourteenth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution. The district argued the rules were aimed to prevent bullying and discrimination.

The lawsuit had captured broad national attention, with a number of conservative policy groups, the American Civil Liberties Union and Christian, Jewish, Muslim and Hindu rights organizations lining up against the policy and leading LGBTQ+ rights and schools groups lining up generally in defense of it.

The court found the district “has fallen far short” of meeting the standard that allowing such speech would “materially and substantially disrupt” school activities or infringe the legal “rights of others” in the school community.

“Our society continues to debate whether biological pronouns are appropriate or offensive — just as it continues to debate many other issues surrounding transgender rights,” Circuit Judge Eric Murphy wrote for the majority. “The school district may not skew this debate by forcing one side to change the way it conveys its message or by compelling it to express a different view.”

Circuit Judge Jane Stranch retorted in a dissent written entirely without the use of gendered, third-person pronouns for individuals.

While “it may be a new phenomenon for many to use new pronouns or to avoid using pronouns, it is certainly possible,” Stranch wrote, “social mores around pronouns have shifted over the course of American history, and these shifting mores have not suddenly rendered people unable to speak.”

It is not clear how far-reaching the impacts of the ruling might be. One Ohio teachers’ union had told the court that Olentangy’s policies are substantially similar to those used by districts around the state.

A three-judge panel of the 6th Circuit had found against the organization in July 2024, ruling that the school district had sufficiently shown that the speech it sought to prohibit would disrupt classroom instruction. That earlier decision also held that those policies did not compel students and families represented by the parents’ group to use any certain pronouns to address LGBTQ+ students nor suppress alternative viewpoints.

Thursday’s ruling reversed that decision and sent the case back to U.S. District Judge Algenon Marbley in Columbus to issue a preliminary injunction against Olentangy enforcing the pronoun policies, which he did.

At issue in the case were overlapping district policies that prohibited the use of gender-related language that other students might deem insulting, dehumanizing, unwanted or offensive and call for the use of peers’ “preferred pronouns.”

The district’s electronic devices policy — which applies both on and off school time — prohibits transmitting “disruptive” material or material that could be seen as harassing or disparaging other students based on their gender identity or sexual orientation, among other categories.

A separate antidiscrimination policy prohibits students from saying or writing “discriminatory language” when they’re under the school’s authority. The policy bans derogatory comments, jokes or slurs based on a range of factors, including gender identity.

Marbley’s order did not prevent the district from continuing to enforce its antidiscrimination policy.

The district’s code of conduct echoes many of the same themes a third time.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

National News

This booking photo, released by the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office in Largo, Fla., shows Thomas M...

Associated Press

Mental competency at issue in US criminal case against Meghan’s father

TAMPA, Fla. (AP) — A judge scheduled a mental competency hearing Thursday for the 82-year-old estranged father of Meghan, the Duchess of Sussex, two weeks after he was arrested in Florida and charged with storing child sexual abuse material in California. Thomas Markle was released after his arrest at a senior care center but was […]

4 hours ago

This photo provided by the U.S. Army shows the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in Middletown, Iowa, on M...

Associated Press

Iowa residents brace for a lead dust cloud as Army plans to detonate 5 tons of bomb-making chemicals

DES MOINES, Iowa (AP) — Plans by the U.S. Army to detonate about 5 tons of bomb-making chemicals that have become unusable and might explode if moved have residents in southeast Iowa worried that a cloud of lead dust could cause environmental contamination and health problems. The detonation at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant is […]

4 hours ago

From left, South Carolina Corrections Department Director Joel Anderson, South Carolina Attorney Ge...

Associated Press

FCC expected to allow state prisons to jam contraband cellphone signals with Thursday vote

COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — The Federal Communications Commission is poised to grant permission to state prisons across the United States to jam the signals of cell phones smuggled to inmates, devices that authorities say represent the No. 1 security threat in the nation’s correctional facilities. Inmates have used contraband cell phones — smuggled inside hollowed-out […]

4 hours ago

Deputy clerk Devin Black, right, assists Cheryl McGee and Johnny McGee Sr., who came to verify thei...

Associated Press

Mississippi saw a spike in ‘inactive’ voters for the midterms. Democrats want answers

JACKSON, Miss. (AP) — Democratic lawmakers in Mississippi are calling for an investigation after a spike in the number of people listed as inactive on voter rolls ahead of this year’s midterm elections — an increase of nearly 60,000 since the presidential election two years ago. The shift apparently was caused by the integration of […]

4 hours ago

Rep. Nick Begich III, R-Alaska, sign-waves with supporters at the edge of Midtown Mall, Monday, Nov...

Associated Press

Republican Nick Begich wins reelection to Alaska’s US House seat, a rare bright spot for the GOP

JUNEAU, Alaska (AP) — Republican U.S. Rep. Nick Begich has won reelection to Alaska’s lone U.S. House seat, hanging on during a year that saw Democrats regain control in both houses of Congress. His win Wednesday through the state’s ranked vote tabulations process was a rare bright spot for Republicans, whose ranks in the House […]

6 hours ago

Associated Press

Republican Nick Begich wins reelection to U.S. House in Alaska’s at-large Congressional District

Republican Nick Begich won election Wednesday to the U.S. House of Representatives representing Alaska’s at-large Congressional District, defeating independent candidate Bill Hill. Begich’s victory over Hill means he’ll serve a second straight term, helped in part by President Donald Trump’s endorsement. Hill ran as an independent but had back from the state’s Democratic Party as […]

6 hours ago

Appeals court sides with parent group in fight over Ohio school district’s pronoun policy