NATIONAL NEWS

Democrats say they don’t oppose voter ID, but argue that GOP voting bill is too strict

Mar 19, 2026, 3:29 PM

Democratic candidate for Congress, Kat Abughazaleh, holds a "Thank you for voting" sticker after vo...

Democratic candidate for Congress, Kat Abughazaleh, holds a "Thank you for voting" sticker after voting in the Illinois primary election for the upcoming midterms, in Chicago, Tuesday, March 17, 2026. (AP Photo/Nam Y. Huh)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(AP Photo/Nam Y. Huh)

WASHINGTON (AP) — Republicans who are pushing a strict proof-of-citizenship legislation have tried to frame the debate in simple terms — if you have to show your photo identification to get on a plane or check out a book at the library, shouldn’t you have to show one to vote?

As Republicans hold the Senate floor to debate the bill, touted by President Donald Trump as essential to winning the midterm elections, they argue that Democrats completely oppose the idea.

“It kind of feels like the only Americans not to support voter ID requirements are Democrats here in Congress,” said Majority Leader John Thune, who said that they either oppose it because it’s a Republican proposal, or “Democrats believe that there are in fact people out there voting illegally and that it’s benefiting Democrats.”

But Democrats say they are not entirely opposed to voter identification at the polls, despite longstanding concerns.

“Our objection as Democrats is not to a photo ID,” Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer said this week, when asked if he might negotiate with Republicans on the bill’s requirement that voters show specified forms of identification when they vote. “Our objection is that it’s a voter suppression bill.”

Democrats, who are expected to block the bill, say they have bigger concerns about new voter-registration requirements in the legislation — the Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act, also known as the SAVE America Act or the SAVE Act.

Because most forms of photo ID don’t indicate citizenship, voters who want to register would have to show up in person at an election office with a passport, birth certificate or other approved documentation. The legislation would also give the Homeland Security Department access to state voter rolls for review.

People could show up at the polls and be told, “You’re off the rolls,” Schumer said.

Democratic proposals to loosen, not eliminate, voter ID laws

Even as he suggests he could support voter ID, Schumer didn’t give specifics.

Asked if he might be willing to negotiate with Republicans on voter ID, Schumer responded: “You’d have to define it clearly and properly and easily.” He did not elaborate.

Democrats have said for years that requiring identification at the polls could disenfranchise voters, particularly those who have less money and education. But they did not suggest eliminating state ID laws when they proposed their own voting bills in the majority four years ago.

Instead, Democrats at the time proposed loosening some state ID laws, ensuring that voters lacking identification could sign sworn statements to prove their identity or allowing additional forms of identification, such as utility bills.

Democrats are generally supportive of the idea of voter identification, says Matt Weil of the Bipartisan Policy Center, “as long as there are options.”

Illegal voting by noncitizens is rare. Still, a poll by the Pew Research Center in August 2025 found that about 8 in 10 US adults said they favor requiring all voters to show government-issued photo identification to vote.

Americans back voter ID, Weil says, “but there’s a lot of ambiguity. And it might not be the strict voter ID that Republicans are pushing in this bill.”

Republicans say it shouldn’t be ambiguous.

The SAVE America Act is “going to make it harder to cheat, because Americans do not want their legitimate vote canceled by a fraudulent one,” said Wisconsin Sen. Ron Johnson during floor debate this week.

Most states require voter ID already

According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, 36 states have some sort of law requiring ID at the polls. As of last year, NCSL reports that 23 states require photo identification and 13 accept non-photo identification.

The SAVE America Act would require photo identification and could override many forms of ID allowed in states across the country — including fishing and hunting licenses or college IDs. It would also require that people voting by mail include a photocopy of their ID with their ballot, potentially creating new problems for states not set up to review and process those photocopies.

Virginia Sen. Tim Kaine, a Democrat, says he supports voter ID laws in Virginia that are less strict than those required by the bill. “We have voter ID laws, and most states do,” Kaine says. “So why does there have to be a federal solution?”

Some Democrats have suggested a national identification card that shows proof of citizenship and is free for all citizens.

“If there really were proof of an epidemic of noncitizen voting, we would need to look for ways to prevent that from happening,” said Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen. “We would have to come up with some form of required ID to meet that problem.”

Please follow our Community Guidelines

National News

Associated Press

Classified communications network at the National Security Agency goes down, defense official says

WASHINGTON (AP) — An internal network the National Security Agency uses to communicate classified information was offline Tuesday after what one U.S. official described as “routine maintenance.” A defense official said that the problem affected NSANet, a classified internal network used by employees of the agency. A different U.S. official said that the NSA “experienced […]

1 hour ago

FILE - Sen. Chris Van Hollen, D-Md., speaks during the Senate Subcommittee on Commerce, Justice, Sc...

Associated Press

Van Hollen’s bid to replace Schumer as leader is putting pressure on Democrats to take sides

WASHINGTON (AP) — Senate Democrats elect their leader every two years behind closed doors and on a secret ballot. But this year’s race has burst into the public eye as Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen mounts an insurgent bid against New York incumbent Chuck Schumer. The Dec. 1 contest has put Senate Democrats on edge […]

1 hour ago

FILE - Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang listens as President Donald Trump speaks during an event at the U.S....

Associated Press

Jensen Huang breaks his silence. Read his full statement here

Jensen Huang was unseated last week from the top job at Nvidia, a company that is a linchpin in the booming artificial intelligence sector. Huang broke his silence Tuesday. The full statement, as posted on X, follows: Over the past week, I’ve been overwhelmed by the love and support of friends, industry colleagues, and people […]

1 hour ago

Federal Aviation Administrator Bryan Bedford, left, with Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, speak...

Associated Press

Congress agrees on civilian plane locator mandate after deadly American Airlines-Black Hawk crash

Congress has agreed to require airliners and other civilian aircraft to carry systems that help pilots locate nearby aircraft. But lawmakers still have to resolve the provisions that apply to the military. Senators Ted Cruz and Maria Cantwell announced the agreement Tuesday at a demonstration on the lawn outside the Capitol building. A group representing […]

2 hours ago

Palestinians ride past the rubble of buildings destroyed during the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza City, ...

Associated Press

Board of Peace delivers bleak report on Gaza, warning of ceasefire collapse without immediate action

NEW YORK (AP) — The body overseeing the U.S.-brokered ceasefire in Gaza delivered another bleak report Tuesday on its progress to the United Nations Security Council, warning diplomats of a collapse of the fragile agreement if steps are not taken for full implementation. The Board of Peace report — its first annual assessment — calls […]

2 hours ago

FILE - Pages from the Anthropic website and the company's logos are displayed on a computer screen ...

Associated Press

Anthropic forges ahead with its IPO even as AI fears mount and markets wobble

NEW YORK (AP) — Investors fearing an AI bubble are getting jittery. Financing costs are rising. Democrats are vowing to crack down on the industry. It’s not an ideal time for an artificial intelligence company to sell stock, but Anthropic is pressing ahead with its blockbuster initial public offering anyway. No ordinary sale, the Claude […]

2 hours ago

Democrats say they don’t oppose voter ID, but argue that GOP voting bill is too strict