NATIONAL NEWS

Federal appeals court hands NCAA a victory in struggle for five-year eligibility rule

Nov 6, 2026, 2:04 PM

FILEL - Texas Tech quarterback Tommy Castellanos (4) warms up before an NCAA college football game,...

FILEL - Texas Tech quarterback Tommy Castellanos (4) warms up before an NCAA college football game, Saturday, Sept. 12, 2026, in Corvallis, Ore. (AP Photo/Lydia Ely)
Credit: AP Photo/Lydia Ely

(AP Photo/Lydia Ely)

DENVER (AP) — Federal appeals court judges handed the NCAA a significant victory in its struggle to implement a new five-year eligibility ruling Friday, though the win does nothing to tamp down dozens of similar lawsuits playing out in state courts across the country.

Ruling in the case Wisne vs. NCAA, the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals in Denver reversed a lower-court decision that had granted players across the country who graduated high school in 2022 a fifth year of eligibility.

The lower-court ruling in July went against the NCAA’s new rule that granted five years of eligibility, but only starting with athletes from the next year’s class. It essentially made all those Class of ’22 players eligible, leading to nationwide chaos, with teams looking to sign players who had been relegated to the sideline.

But in August, when this same appeals court first put the ruling on hold, many of those players still found their way onto rosters thanks to favorable rulings in state courts.

The decision Friday doesn’t resolve some 200 state cases that involve as many as 850 athletes. The NCAA applauded it nonetheless, with chief legal officer Scott Bearby calling it “consistent with the approach taken by every federal court of appeals” in cases like these.

“The decision also acknowledges the NCAA’s concern that retroactively changing eligibility rules can destabilize rosters and disrupt the settled expectations of student-athletes regarding roster spots and playing time,” Bearby wrote in a memo to NCAA members.

Much of that damage has already been done, as football’s regular season heads into its final month with some players — for instance, Texas Tech quarterback Thomas Castellanos — toggling on and off rosters depending on the latest court ruling. Basketball season started this week under similar uncertainty.

The decision hinged over what judges said was the plaintiffs’ inability to define the market for players — a key point in determining how those players are being harmed by being declared ineligible.

In the decision penned by Judge Carolyn McHugh, the three-judge panel knocked down the plaintiff argument that all Division I players, regardless of sport, formed a single market.

“Obviously, a football player looking for a Division I roster spot would not view the 101 schools without a football program as reasonably good substitutes,” McHugh wrote.

___

Sign up for Top 25 poll alerts here, visit the Top 25 here and see AP’s full college football coverage here

Please follow our Community Guidelines

National News

President Donald Trump speaks during an event to mark Veterans Day at Arlington National Cemetery i...

Associated Press

The Latest: Trump will head to Asia for economic deals and historic nuclear talks

President Donald Trump is preparing to depart for Asia on Monday, turning his focus to economic deals and historic three-way nuclear talks with Russia and China as his administration adjusts to a new political reality in Washington. Also, Trump on Sunday decried a “ highly destructive and political decision ” from a federal judge who […]

1 hour ago

FILE - A pair of North Atlantic right whales interact at the surface of Cape Cod Bay, March 27, 202...

Associated Press

Rare North Atlantic right whale population drops, alarming scientists

PORTLAND, Maine (AP) — The population of one of the world’s rarest whales has fallen after trending upward in recent years, worrying scientists who fear the animal could still be at risk of extinction. The North Atlantic right whale now numbers 382 animals, according to a consortium of scientists that released its annual population estimate […]

5 hours ago

Associated Press

Russia says its defenses intercepted over 1,300 Ukrainian drones in a major attack

Russia intercepted 1,336 drones launched by Ukraine, Russia’s Defense Ministry said Monday, in what was the most claimed downings since Moscow’s all-out invasion of its neighbor nearly five years ago. Ukraine has scaled up its long-range aerial assaults on Russia, as well as the illegally annexed Crimean Peninsula and the Black and the Azov seas, […]

5 hours ago

A person looks at a flight information board at LaGuardia Airport in New York, Friday, Nov. 13, 202...

Associated Press

Questions swirl around FAA’s new SMART AI system, though officials say no link to ground stop

The airline ground stop that wreaked havoc on travel since Friday was not related to the FAA’s new, $875 million AI-powered system the agency is rolling out to help predict problems in the sky, according to government officials and the artificial intelligence company behind the technology. But the timing of the ground stop, so close […]

7 hours ago

FILE - The Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., head of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, s...

Associated Press

Handwritten draft of MLK’s ‘I Have a Dream’ speech to go on display before it’s sold at auction

ATLANTA (AP) — Words scrawled in blue pen — and others scratched out — give an intimate peek into the writing of what would become the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr.’s most famous speech. Delivered Aug. 28, 1963, from the steps of the Lincoln Memorial, the “I Have a Dream” speech reflects on the shameful […]

10 hours ago

President Donald Trump speaks before signing an executive order in the Oval Office of the White Hou...

Associated Press

Trump’s Asia reset: Deals in Manila and Shenzhen, then a rare nuclear summit with Xi and Putin

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump is preparing to depart for Asia on Monday, turning his focus to economic deals and historic three-way nuclear talks with Russia and China as his administration adjusts to a new political reality in Washington. Trump’s departure comes after the often-omnipresent president had remained largely out of public sight for […]

10 hours ago

Federal appeals court hands NCAA a victory in struggle for five-year eligibility rule