NATIONAL NEWS

Lawyers for patients of UCLA doctor say clients shaken by court overturning his sex abuse conviction

Feb 3, 2026, 2:31 PM

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Two years after a former University of California, Los Angeles, gynecologist was convicted of sex abuse and sentenced to 11 years in prison, an attorney working to prepare an appeal of the case stumbled across an astounding find for the defense counsel.

A note by the jury’s foreperson, a designated spokesperson for the jury, had been sent to the judge expressing concern that one of the jurors did not have sufficient English to carry out his duties and deliberate. The juror was an alternate who was brought in after another juror had a medical issue and two days before the verdict. The judge never shared that information with the prosecution or defense attorneys.

“That note was never turned over to us ever,” said Leonard Levine, the defense attorney of Dr. James Heaps. “We were shocked.”

A California appeals court on Monday found the mistake violated Heaps’ Sixth Amendment right and ordered the case to be retried. Lawyers for patients who accused Heaps say the decision to overturn his conviction has left them devastated, and legal experts say they are puzzled by the type of judicial error that transpired. Levine said he believes Heaps will be exonerated when retried.

“In my 30 years of trial and appeals work, excluding the defense from a jury question is unheard of,” said Dmitry Gorin, a former prosecutor and criminal defense specialist.

Courtney Thom, who represents more than 200 of Heaps’ former patients, said there is no question that jury note should have been shared with attorneys, but said the defense “exploited” the error to overturn Heaps’ conviction.

“When that happens, a common defense tactic is they delay, delay, delay, the second trial,” Thom said. “What does this say to survivors of sexual abuse? Who wants to come forward with their abuse if this is their path to justice?”

Thom’s firm won more than $240 million for Heaps’ accusers in a settlement with the University of California system. UCLA patients said Heaps groped them, made suggestive comments or conducted unnecessarily invasive exams. Overall, the university has paid nearly $700 million to settle lawsuits.

The Los Angeles District Attorney’s office said it plans to retry Heaps as soon as possible. Once that happens, his defense attorney Levine said he will ask that his client be released on bond just as he was before the first trial.

Heaps’ trial spanned more than two months in 2022 and included testimony from several of his former patients. He was accused of sexually assaulting hundreds of patients during his 35-year career. He pleaded not guilty to 21 felony counts in the sexual assaults of seven women between 2009 and 2018.

After several days of jury deliberations, one of the jurors was replaced by an alternate, Juror number 15, according to court filings. But an hour later, the foreperson sent a note to the judge that read, “We have observed that the language barrier with Juror (No.) 15 is preventing us from properly deliberating. Juror (No.) 15 was not able to understand calls to vote guilty or not guilty, and expressed to us that his limited English interfered with his understanding of the testimony.”

It also appeared that “his mind is already made up,” the note read.

Later on, when the judicial assistant spoke to Juror No. 15 in Spanish, the juror said, “They think that I don’t understand English, but I do.” He insisted he could continue deliberating.

The next day, the foreperson told the judicial assistant that the note no longer needed to be addressed, according to court filings.

Heaps was convicted in October 2022 of three counts of sexual battery by fraud and two counts of sexual penetration of two patients. The jury found him not guilty of seven of the 21 counts and was deadlocked on the remaining charges.

If the note had been simply disclosed in court, Heaps’ defense attorneys would have the opportunity to question whether that juror was qualified to serve or call for a mistrial, said Robert Little, a Los Angeles attorney specializing in appellate law.

Usually any potential juror who did not speak adequate English is dismissed during the jury selection process, Little said.

“Mistakes are made in courtrooms and during trials every day,” Little said. “The question in any given appeal … is whether that particular error was harmless, or was it prejudicial.”

The three-judge panel found “the trial court’s handling of the note deprived defendant of his constitutional right to counsel at a critical stage of his trial.”

Another attorney for 200 former patients in the case, John Manly, said in a statement the overturning of the conviction “sends a message that victims, especially women and children, do not matter.”

“These brave survivors suffered through a four-year ordeal of prosecution and trial resulting in an 11-year prison sentence for this monster,” Manly said. “Now they are being told that they must start over.”

_____

Watson reported from San Diego.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

National News

The U.S. Capitol is seen, Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026, in Washington. (AP Photo/Julia Demaree Nikhinson...

Associated Press

Trump orders federal contractors to check with White House before responding to Congress

NEW YORK (AP) — President Donald Trump is directing federal contractors and subcontractors to consult with his administration about inquiries they receive from Congress and to withhold any communications that the White House considers privileged, according to a new executive order issued late Friday. The companies must also coordinate with the White House and U.S. […]

2 minutes ago

FBI Director Kash Patel, left, with U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche, takes questions from the me...

Associated Press

FBI investigating apparent hack of a key criminal justice information database, AP source says

WASHINGTON (AP) — The FBI is investigating an apparent hack of a national law enforcement database that it maintains, a person familiar with the matter said Saturday. The National Crime Information Center, known as the NCIC, is a computerized database of criminal justice information that is available to local, state and federal law enforcement agencies […]

36 minutes ago

This combination of photos of 2026 Democratic candidates who flipped Senate seats shows Annie Andre...

Associated Press

Democrats who swept into the Senate promised change. A leadership vote is testing them early

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Democratic Party’s incoming senators haven’t even been sworn into office yet, but the decision over who will lead their new majority is already testing the promise of change they made as candidates. The 13 new Democrats are part of the largest incoming Senate class in decades, with several winning in Republican […]

3 hours ago

Specialist Meric Greenbaum works on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange in New York, Monday, N...

Associated Press

A 10% drop for the stock market is unnerving, but it’s not that unusual

The U.S. stock market has dropped 10% from its high set last month amid concerns about the growing hurdles faced by the high-flying artificial intelligence industry. The fall for the S&P 500 is steep enough that Wall Street has a name for it: a “correction.” Such drops have happened regularly for more than a century, […]

3 hours ago

A Sheriff's vehicle drives past the Hotel Graham on Monday, Nov. 16, 2026, in Graham, N.C. (AP Phot...

Associated Press

Voters oust some sheriffs who signed pacts to help Trump’s immigration enforcement efforts

GRAHAM, N.C. (AP) — As he ran for sheriff in North Carolina against a longtime incumbent who had joined forces with the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown, Shannon Long found his campaign van was an obstacle with some voters. The trust between law enforcement and Alamance County’s growing Latino community was so fractured, Long said, that […]

3 hours ago

A food inspired bath bomb is displayed at a Kohl's store in Dallas, Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. (AP Pho...

Associated Press

Products in food-inspired colors like matcha and ube are popping up in unexpected places

NEW YORK (AP) — A Kindle in ube-inspired purple. A velvet sofa reminiscent of dill pickles. A portable fan in shades borrowed from a trendy cafe menu. Contemporary food culture is providing inspiration beyond the kitchen. From matcha green and butter yellow to cherry red and dragon fruit pink, the names of familiar and fashionable […]

4 hours ago

Lawyers for patients of UCLA doctor say clients shaken by court overturning his sex abuse conviction