NATIONAL NEWS

Mamdani has a place in NYC history. But which place in a centuries-long list of mayors?

Dec 18, 2025, 8:59 AM | Updated: 11:00 am

FILE - New York City Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani listens as President Donald Trump speaks in the Ova...

FILE - New York City Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani listens as President Donald Trump speaks in the Oval Office of the White House, Friday, Nov. 21, 2025, in Washington. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci, File)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(AP Photo/Evan Vucci, File)

NEW YORK (AP) — Zohran Mamdani can claim multiple firsts when he becomes New York’s mayor Jan. 1.

Besides being the first Muslim and first person of South Asian heritage elected to the office, the Democrat also is poised to shape city history by being the 112th mayor — rather than 111th, as he was expecting. That’s due to a longstanding oversight in record-keeping that recently gained new attention.

“I’m excited to be whichever mayor,” Mamdani told reporters Wednesday after learning about the counting contretemps. It shows how tricky history’s arithmetic can be.

Paul Hortenstine, an independent historian exploring early New York mayors’ participation in slavery, recently noticed that the city government’s widely used list of mayors undercounted Matthias Nicolls, a figure from the beginning years of English colonial rule in New York.

Nicolls was listed as the sixth mayor, from 1671 to 1672, but there was no mention of his return to office two years later. In the interim, successor John Lawrence took office, then was ousted by a Dutch invasion that briefly implemented a different form of colonial government. The Netherlands eventually gave up the area in exchange for other concessions, and the new English governor reappointed Nicolls in late 1674.

Other mayors were counted multiple times if they served nonconsecutive terms, so Hortenstine suggested Nicolls get the same treatment. The correction would entail renumbering 350 years of subsequent mayors, from William Dervall (who would become No. 9) to incumbent Eric Adams (who’d be No. 111).

“The numbering of mayors is a fascinating issue that is much more difficult than it appears at first glance,” Hortenstine said by phone.

A Washington, D.C.-area researcher, Hortenstine has his own history with New York mayors: He worked for Michael Bloomberg’s 2009 reelection campaign. (The three-consecutive-term Bloomberg would be 109th if the list is renumbered.)

He hopes the debate will stir interest in early mayors and their personal and political involvement with slavery.

As Hortenstine noted, a former New York State Library official, the late Peter Christoph, pointed out the Nicholls numbering flub in 1989. This time, after local news site Gothamist broached the apparent mayoral miscount, the city Department of Records and Information Services looked into it.

In a Dec. 11 blog post, agency archivist Michael Lorenzini painstakingly traced a trail of complexities and gaps in centuries-old records. When the city began printing lists of past mayors in the mid-1800s, Nicolls’ second term didn’t make it.

“It does appear that on January 1, 2026, Mayor Mamdani should be mayor number 112,” Lorenzini wrote, while noting “the numbering of New York City ‘mayors’ has been somewhat arbitrary and inconsistent.”

The list doesn’t enumerate the “burgomasters,” mayor-like officials who served in pairs during some periods of Dutch governance. There’s no accounting for any leaders among the Native Americans who lived in the area for thousands of years before colonization. Some acting mayors are mentioned but not awarded numbers — except in a more obscure version of the list, nestled in a 2015 document in the city archives.

Moreover, even equating “mayors” is, to some extent, Big Apples and oranges. The mayor initially led a New York City that comprised only Manhattan, before the Bronx, Brooklyn, Queens and Staten Island were added in the late 1800s.

So how much does the numerical list ultimately count?

“In some ways, it is a sort of academic exercise,” Lorenzini said by phone this week. “But I think what’s interesting to me is that we still have these records, and people can still dive into them and still find something new or something to argue about. History is still alive.”

Please follow our Community Guidelines

National News

Associated Press

Alaska victory gives Democrats their ninth Senate flip of the year, the most for the party since 1958

WASHINGTON (AP) — Alaska victory gives Democrats their ninth Senate flip of the year, the most for the party since 1958.

1 hour ago

Associated Press

Democrat Mary Peltola wins election to U.S. Senate from Alaska

Democrat Mary Peltola won election Tuesday to the U.S. Senate representing Alaska, defeating Republican Dan Sullivan. Peltola’s victory secures another seat for the Democratic Party as it tries to retake control of the Senate in the final two years of President Donald Trump’s term. Peltola is a former member of the U.S. House. She booted […]

2 hours ago

Costco recall (1)...

MyNorthwest Staff

Costco recalls popular holiday item in 12 states

Costco is recalling a widely used topping ahead of the holiday rush.

3 hours ago

FILE - Dr. Heidi Overton testifies at the Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Comm...

Associated Press

White House pulls FDA nominee Heidi Overton after wavering support from Senate Republicans

WASHINGTON (AP) — The White House said Tuesday it has pulled the nomination of Dr. Heidi Overton to lead the Food and Drug Administration amid growing indications she didn’t have the votes needed to win Senate confirmation. Overton, a physician and White House domestic policy adviser, has spent most of her professional career working directly […]

4 hours ago

FILE - In this U.S. Navy provided photo, the USS Gerald R. Ford embarks on the first of its sea tri...

Associated Press

Trump faces GOP pushback to his order to use steam to launch jets from aircraft carriers

WASHINGTON (AP) — Senators want to scuttle President Donald Trump’s order to retrofit new aircraft carriers with old steam catapults to launch fighter jets, a directive that would cost billions of taxpayer dollars and could even blunt the lethality of America’s most advanced warships. Sen. Roger Wicker, the Mississippi Republican who chairs the Senate Armed […]

5 hours ago

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman speaks at Semafor's Silicon Valley and The World conference in Menlo Park, Ca...

Associated Press

What tech CEOs are saying about the saga around Jensen Huang’s exit from Nvidia

MENLO PARK, Calif. (AP) — The saga surrounding former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang has riveted Silicon Valley like few other stories, from reports of extramarital affairs to his resignation last week and short-lived comeback bid. Huang and Nvidia, a computer chip company that has been driving the AI boom, were top of mind this week […]

5 hours ago

Mamdani has a place in NYC history. But which place in a centuries-long list of mayors?