NATIONAL NEWS

New Hampshire Supreme Court takes up disputed verdict in landmark youth center abuse case

Nov 20, 2025, 10:50 AM

FILE - Youth Development Center. plaintiff David Meehan testifies as his intake photo, when he was ...

FILE - Youth Development Center. plaintiff David Meehan testifies as his intake photo, when he was 14 is displayed during his civil trial at Rockingham County Superior Court in Brentwood, N.H. on April 17, 2024. (David Lane/Union Leader via AP, Pool, file)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(David Lane/Union Leader via AP, Pool, file)

CONCORD, N.H. (AP) — New Hampshire Supreme Court justices heard oral arguments Thursday about the disputed verdict in a landmark lawsuit over abuse at the state’s youth detention center, questioning whether their decision could bankrupt the state or essentially let it off the hook.

Jurors last year awarded $38 million to David Meehan, who alleged that the state’s negligence allowed him to be repeatedly raped and beaten as a teenager at the Youth Development Center in Manchester. But the state is seeking to reduce the award under a sovereign immunity law that caps individual payouts at $475,000 per “incident.”

Jurors were not aware of the cap, and some later said they wrote “one” on the verdict form to reflect a single case of post-traumatic stress disorder resulting from more than 100 episodes of physical, sexual and emotional abuse.

Meehan’s attorneys argue that because jurors found the state was wanton, malicious or oppressive, applying the cap would deprive Meehan of his constitutional right to equal protection. In order of preference, they asked the court to let the $38 million verdict stand, allow the trial judge to determine the number of incidents, order a new trial just on that question or order an entirely new trial.

The state argues that the state’s mismanagement of the facility constitutes a “single incident.” Questioning that logic, Justice Patrick Donovan asked whether that would severely limit the total amount the state would pay to hundreds of others who claim they were similarly abused. The same law that limits individual payouts to $475,000 also caps the state’s total per incident at $3.75 million.

Meehan’s attorney, Dan Deane, said the state’s definition would pave the way for applying the larger cap to “decades of abuse.” But Solicitor General Anthony Galdieri, representing the state, disagreed, saying each case involves different circumstances.

Donovan also considered the opposite scenario, questioning whether a decision in Meehan’s favor would push the state toward bankruptcy given the many other cases yet to be decided. Galdieri said the justices should take the state’s finances into account, and that removing the cap would amount to an authorized appropriation of taxpayer money.

Meehan’s allegations of horrific sexual and physical abuse at the Manchester facility in the 1990s led an unprecedented criminal investigation, nine additional arrests, over 1,100 lawsuits, and the establishment of a settlement fund to compensate victims. Only Meehan’s lawsuit has gone to trial; the rest are on hold pending the outcome of the Supreme Court appeal.

Thursday’s oral arguments came a day after one of the men Meehan accused of abuse was acquitted on three sexual assault charges by a jury that wasn’t able to reach a verdict on five other charges. Stephen Murphy still faces charges related to two other former residents of the facility, now called the Sununu Youth Services Center, and prosecutors could retry him on the five charges on which no verdict was returned Wednesday.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

National News

This combination of photos of 2026 Democratic candidates who flipped Senate seats shows Annie Andre...

Associated Press

Democrats who swept into the Senate promised change. A leadership vote is testing them early

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Democratic Party’s incoming senators haven’t even been sworn into office yet, but the decision over who will lead their new majority is already testing the promise of change they made as candidates. The 13 new Democrats are part of the largest incoming Senate class in decades, with several winning in Republican […]

47 minutes ago

Specialist Meric Greenbaum works on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange in New York, Monday, N...

Associated Press

A 10% drop for the stock market is unnerving, but it’s not that unusual

The U.S. stock market has dropped 10% from its high set last month amid concerns about the growing hurdles faced by the high-flying artificial intelligence industry. The fall for the S&P 500 is steep enough that Wall Street has a name for it: a “correction.” Such drops have happened regularly for more than a century, […]

48 minutes ago

A food inspired bath bomb is displayed at a Kohl's store in Dallas, Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026. (AP Pho...

Associated Press

Products in food-inspired colors like matcha and ube are popping up in unexpected places

NEW YORK (AP) — A Kindle in ube-inspired purple. A velvet sofa reminiscent of dill pickles. A portable fan in shades borrowed from a trendy cafe menu. Contemporary food culture is providing inspiration beyond the kitchen. From matcha green and butter yellow to cherry red and dragon fruit pink, the names of familiar and fashionable […]

2 hours ago

FILE - Oath Keepers founder Stewart Rhodes attends the House Select Subcommittee hearing to investi...

Associated Press

Oath Keepers founder and Jan. 6 leader Stewart Rhodes is ‘absolutely done’ with Trump

IRVING, Texas (AP) — Stewart Rhodes didn’t just go to prison for Donald Trump. While serving time for his role in the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol, the founder of the right-wing militia known as the Oath Keepers got a tattoo of Trump’s defiant face after he survived an assassin’s bullet in Butler, […]

2 hours ago

The Christian nationalist and pastor Joel Webbon speaks on stage during his conference, Christ is K...

Associated Press

Christian nationalists see Republicans’ midterm losses as an opportunity to supplant Trump’s MAGA

IRVING, Texas (AP) — Christian nationalists once celebrated President Donald Trump’s return to the White House as a victory for their movement. Now they see the Republican Party’s recent election losses as an opportunity to supplant his “Make America Great Again” movement with their extremist vision. Many gathered in Texas last week for a three-day […]

2 hours ago

Paul Smith, chief commercial officer of Anthropic, center left, and Krishna Rao, chief financial of...

Associated Press

Anthropic worker claims to have solved a Holy Grail of math problems with the help of AI

A mathematician who works for artificial intelligence giant Anthropic claims he has solved a Holy Grail of math problems with the help of the company’s AI tool Claude. It marks the second time in recent months that an AI company or someone linked to one claims to have cracked a famed unsolved math problem. Levent […]

10 hours ago

New Hampshire Supreme Court takes up disputed verdict in landmark youth center abuse case