NATIONAL NEWS

Utah’s chief justice speaks out as Republicans look to expand the state Supreme Court

Jan 20, 2026, 7:37 PM

Chief Justice Matthew Durrant stands in the House of Representatives as he delivers the State of th...

Chief Justice Matthew Durrant stands in the House of Representatives as he delivers the State of the Judiciary address on the first day of the 2026 legislative session in Salt Lake City, on Tuesday, Jan. 20, 2026. (The Deseret News via AP)
Credit: ASSOCIATED PRESS

(The Deseret News via AP)

SALT LAKE CITY (AP) — The chief justice of Utah’s state Supreme Court cautioned lawmakers against meddling with the judiciary as Republicans pushed to add justices to the high court during their annual 45-day session that began Tuesday.

Republican legislative leaders and Gov. Spencer Cox have said they support a proposal to expand the five-judge panel to seven, arguing it would help speed up decision-making. Legal experts say the move could have the opposite effect and set a dangerous precedent at a time of tension between the two branches.

The move comes as Utah courts have dealt lawmakers a string of defeats on abortion restrictions, transgender athletes and the Legislature’s ability to change or repeal voter-approved initiatives. The Legislature is also preparing to appeal a redistricting ruling that gave Democrats a strong shot at picking up one of Utah’s four Republican-held congressional seats in the midterms this fall.

“I ask that your disappointment with a few results not lead to penalties for an entire branch of government and, by extension, penalties for your constituents,” Chief Justice Matthew Durrant said Tuesday in his yearly address to lawmakers.

The state Supreme Court does not challenge the Legislature’s integrity in its opinions, he said, asking lawmakers for the same courtesy when they challenge legal outcomes.

Durrant said it’s the Legislature’s prerogative to expand the Supreme Court, but he urged them to prioritize adding judges to lower courts, where the need is greater.

Cox included nearly $2.8 million in his proposed state budget that could help pay for two more Supreme Court justices. But John Pearce, who recently retired as an associate chief justice on the high court, said the money could go a lot further in the district and trial courts. He said adding justices could slow the work of the Supreme Court.

“If we’re really concerned about the efficiency of the judiciary, there are places where money would be much better spent than at the Supreme Court,” he said in an interview.

Most states have five or seven state Supreme Court justices, but a few have nine. Cox has said the additions would put Utah in line with other states of its size.

In Utah, justices are appointed by the governor and approved by the state Senate. Justices are elected in many other states, some in partisan elections where political parties are listed on the ballot.

Two states — Arizona and Georgia — have added justices in the past decade after making similar arguments about efficiency. In the years after Arizona grew its court in 2016, several past and present justices said the expansion made the high court less efficient because more people had to review drafted opinions before they could be issued.

“Another few cooks in the kitchen doesn’t necessarily get the cake baked any quicker,” said Chris Peterson, a law professor at the University of Utah. He proposed adding a judicial clerk for each justice to help them work faster.

In a December special session, Republican lawmakers voted to take authority from state Supreme Court justices to pick their own chief justice and instead let the governor choose. They also passed a resolution rebuking the courts over the redistricting ruling, with some calling for the district court judge’s impeachment.

Cox has denied that the proposal to add justices is politically motivated, noting that Republican governors and senators have made all recent appointments to the court.

Still, adding justices can be a slippery slope, Peterson warned.

“The fear is that if powerful political interests don’t get their way, they can simply add new justices to a state or even the federal Supreme Court to try to overturn decisions,” he said. “It can escalate and undermine trust in our government.”

Please follow our Community Guidelines

National News

Rep. Lauren Boebert, R-Colo., arrives for a House GOP leadership candidate forum and elections for ...

Associated Press

From MAGA stardom to a U-Haul: Lauren Boebert considers her own and GOP’s losses

Rep. Lauren Boebert sat in a U-Haul van in the nation’s capital after packing up her congressional office and her “dungeon of an apartment” on Thursday, about six years after she became a MAGA star and one week after voters decided not to return her to Washington, D.C. “I think about it every day,” said […]

1 hour ago

Flowers and cards rest by a statue outside the Cincinnati Zoo entrance on Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026, ...

Associated Press

Fiona’s death gives parents a chance to teach kids about grief — and life

For many children, the death of Fiona, a beloved hippo at the Cincinnati Zoo, may be their first experience with losing an animal they have grown to love, even if they never met her in person. Fiona died Thursday from complications after swallowing a knit hat that was accidentally flung into her enclosure. Her death […]

2 hours ago

Associated Press

Judge tells prosecutors that terrorism case defendant can read violent religious passages

NEW YORK (AP) — A federal judge told federal prosecutors Thursday that the government must permit a man jailed on terrorism charges access to religious materials describing an important figure in Muslim history even if passages advocate violence because similar violent texts in the Bible would never be banned from distribution in jails. Judge Colleen […]

2 hours ago

FILE - The John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts is seen, Oct. 8, 2026, in Washington. (AP...

Associated Press

Trump administration urges judge to lift order blocking Kennedy Center’s two-year closure

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump’s administration on Thursday urged a federal judge to lift a court order blocking its plans to close the Kennedy Center for two years of renovation work on the cultural and arts venue. U.S. District Judge Christopher Cooper didn’t immediately rule from the bench after hearing arguments on the government’s […]

3 hours ago

President Donald Trump, right, China's President Xi Jinping, center, and Russia's President Vladimi...

Associated Press

China bars Bloomberg reporter from trilateral meeting after she shouted question at earlier event

NEW YORK (AP) — It’s a scenario seen every day: A reporter shouts a question out to a leader at an event. The leader either answers or ignores it. In China, though, Bloomberg TV journalist Annmarie Hordern was blocked from a key event by Chinese officials Thursday, apparently as retribution for having shouted a question […]

4 hours ago

FILE - Mark Longo, center, and his wife Daniela Bittner, left, speak during a news conference at th...

Associated Press

Former owner of internet-famous squirrel charged with mortgage fraud

One of the owners of an internet celebrity squirrel named Peanut has been charged with numerous felonies including mortgage fraud, a few weeks after the animal’s other owner was detained by ICE. After New York wildlife officers euthanized the squirrel, also known as P’nut, in 2024, prominent Republicans cited the killing as an example of […]

4 hours ago

Utah’s chief justice speaks out as Republicans look to expand the state Supreme Court