NATIONAL NEWS

Vermont defends its landmark climate superfund law against Trump administration lawsuit

Mar 30, 2026, 11:34 AM | Updated: 8:08 pm

Vermont’s effort to make fossil fuel companies pay for damage caused by climate change was tested Monday in a federal courtroom, where the state argued that two lawsuits challenging its groundbreaking 2024 law should be thrown out.

Vermont became the first state to enact a climate superfund law, modeled on the federal superfund law that taxed petroleum and chemical companies to pay to clean up sites polluted by toxic waste. It took action after suffering catastrophic summer flooding in 2023 as well as damage from other extreme weather, which scientists say is occurring more frequently due to climate change. The money it collects would be used for climate adaptation projects, such as upgrades to stormwater drainage systems, sewage treatment plants and roads.

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and a top oil and gas industry trade group, the American Petroleum Institute, sued Vermont over the law in December 2024, calling it unconstitutional and a violation of federal law. ordered Attorney General Pam Bondi to take action against states that may be overreaching their authority in how they regulate energy development. In suing, Bondi called the laws “burdensome and ideologically motivated” and said they threaten American energy independence and national security.

In asking a judge to dismiss the lawsuits Monday, Vermont argued that it has the authority to raise revenue, protect the health and welfare of its citizens and mitigate environmental harms. The state also said that the law does not conflict with federal law or policy, regulate fossil fuel emissions or punish fossil fuel producers.

“As a sovereign state, Vermont gets to do certain things that are exercises of a traditional state authority. The Superfund Act operates squarely in those areas of traditional state authority,” Jonathan Rose of the Vermont attorney general’s office said in U.S. District Court in Rutland.

The plaintiffs in both cases, however, argue that Vermont can’t legally impose liability or penalties on out-of-state energy producers for harms arising from out-of-state and global greenhouse gas emissions.

“This case is not about Vermont’s ability to raise revenue and protect the health and welfare of its residents. It’s about Vermont’s attempt to subject global energy production activity to Vermont law, which brazenly disregards the constitutional division of power in the federal government and the states,” said DOJ attorney Riley Walters.

While other courts have allowed the application of a state law to out-of-state conduct, those cases involved direct and traceable connections between the behavior and the harm, he said.

“It’s impossible to trace in-state harm to any particular source of greenhouse gas emissions, let alone to the fossil fuel production that is even further down along the alleged causal chain,” he said. “There is not a direct and traceable connection between oil that’s extracted in Texas or in Saudi Arabia and a flood or some other weather event that takes place in Vermont.”

West Virginia, a top producer of natural gas and coal, is leading two dozen states intervening in the case with the Chamber and API, out of concern that Vermont will demand to recover billions of dollars from major energy producers and oil refiners in their states. Meanwhile, the Conservation Law Foundation, an environmental advocacy group in New England, and the Northeast Organic Farming Association of Vermont are supporting Vermont in the litigation.

Attorney Bridget Asay, representing the conservation foundation and farmers, told the judge Monday that granting the plaintiffs’ motions to strike down the law “would give the federal government this roving license to seek to enjoin any state law that it disagrees with simply by pleading preemption.

“That would be quite an expansion of the federal role in our state-federal system, and the court should instead require the United States to show concrete imminent injury like any other litigant,” she said.

Republican Gov. Phil Scott allowed the bill to become law without his signature, saying he was concerned about Vermont taking on the oil industry alone. Since then, the idea has gained traction elsewhere. New York Gov. Kathy Hochul, a Democrat, signed a similar measure a few months after Vermont’s law passed. Other Democratic-controlled states are considering climate superfund laws. Some states are seeking damages from fossil fuel companies in state courts for harms caused by climate change.

Jennifer Rushlow, interim vice president for CLF Vermont, said the outcome of the Vermont litigation likely will influence other states.

“This is the first time that a state legislature has taken the gigantic step of pursuing polluters and holding them accountable to clean up the mess that they’ve made,” she said.

A Dartmouth College research team estimated the world’s biggest corporations have caused $28 trillion in climate damage. The researchers published a study last year with the estimated pollution caused by 111 companies, with more than half of the total dollar figure coming from 10 fossil fuel providers.

___

Ramer reported from Concord, New Hampshire, and McDermott reported from Providence, Rhode Island.

___

The Associated Press’ climate and environmental coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP’s standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at AP.org.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

National News

Associated Press

Classified communications network at the National Security Agency goes down, defense official says

WASHINGTON (AP) — An internal network the National Security Agency uses to communicate classified information was offline Tuesday after what one U.S. official described as “routine maintenance.” A defense official said that the problem affected NSANet, a classified internal network used by employees of the agency. A different U.S. official said that the NSA “experienced […]

44 minutes ago

FILE - Sen. Chris Van Hollen, D-Md., speaks during the Senate Subcommittee on Commerce, Justice, Sc...

Associated Press

Van Hollen’s bid to replace Schumer as leader is putting pressure on Democrats to take sides

WASHINGTON (AP) — Senate Democrats elect their leader every two years behind closed doors and on a secret ballot. But this year’s race has burst into the public eye as Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen mounts an insurgent bid against New York incumbent Chuck Schumer. The Dec. 1 contest has put Senate Democrats on edge […]

48 minutes ago

FILE - Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang listens as President Donald Trump speaks during an event at the U.S....

Associated Press

Jensen Huang breaks his silence. Read his full statement here

Jensen Huang was unseated last week from the top job at Nvidia, a company that is a linchpin in the booming artificial intelligence sector. Huang broke his silence Tuesday. The full statement, as posted on X, follows: Over the past week, I’ve been overwhelmed by the love and support of friends, industry colleagues, and people […]

60 minutes ago

Federal Aviation Administrator Bryan Bedford, left, with Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, speak...

Associated Press

Congress agrees on civilian plane locator mandate after deadly American Airlines-Black Hawk crash

Congress has agreed to require airliners and other civilian aircraft to carry systems that help pilots locate nearby aircraft. But lawmakers still have to resolve the provisions that apply to the military. Senators Ted Cruz and Maria Cantwell announced the agreement Tuesday at a demonstration on the lawn outside the Capitol building. A group representing […]

1 hour ago

Palestinians ride past the rubble of buildings destroyed during the Israel-Hamas war in Gaza City, ...

Associated Press

Board of Peace delivers bleak report on Gaza, warning of ceasefire collapse without immediate action

NEW YORK (AP) — The body overseeing the U.S.-brokered ceasefire in Gaza delivered another bleak report Tuesday on its progress to the United Nations Security Council, warning diplomats of a collapse of the fragile agreement if steps are not taken for full implementation. The Board of Peace report — its first annual assessment — calls […]

1 hour ago

FILE - Pages from the Anthropic website and the company's logos are displayed on a computer screen ...

Associated Press

Anthropic forges ahead with its IPO even as AI fears mount and markets wobble

NEW YORK (AP) — Investors fearing an AI bubble are getting jittery. Financing costs are rising. Democrats are vowing to crack down on the industry. It’s not an ideal time for an artificial intelligence company to sell stock, but Anthropic is pressing ahead with its blockbuster initial public offering anyway. No ordinary sale, the Claude […]

2 hours ago

Vermont defends its landmark climate superfund law against Trump administration lawsuit