SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Asking Amazon to contribute is not the American Way

Oct 17, 2017, 1:35 PM | Updated: 2:22 pm

Amazon, tech hubs...

The Amazon Spheres in Seattle. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)

(AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)

As the deadline for Amazon’s HQ2 approaches, a new rallying cry is emerging. Civic groups are now saying that Amazon isn’t doing its fair share.

I’m a person that is driven by fairness, too, but let’s take a closer look at the logic of this argument.

RELATED: Let’s talk about the growing disparity in Seattle

A letter addressed to Amazon titled “Our HQ2 Wishlist” has been published. Advocacy groups can add their names to this document that divides their requests into three areas: Jobs; Great Communities; and Accountability and Transparency. These groups are from the areas bidding on HQ2.

I completely agree with the jobs part. That makes sense. But the other two categories seem new to me. Are we now saying that when a company becomes a certain size that the normal rules of business in America no longer apply?

These groups would like Amazon to forgo tax breaks, be responsible for transportation issues and affordable housing. They want Amazon to protect small businesses and be transparent and accountable to some outside group. They are asking the tech giant to be “fully committed to open-sourcing the process of reaching … our whole community.”

What are we talking about here? Since when has it been the responsibility of one company to do any of these things? Do a quick Google search — or Bing if you work in Redmond — on Fortune 500 tax breaks, and you’ll find this is the way things get done. Big companies get tax breaks. Builders build houses and municipalities build roads.

So why do cities give big companies like Boeing or Microsoft tax breaks? Because it’s good for the cities in the long run to have quality jobs available. Do you think that Microsoft paid for all those fancy improvements to Highway 520 over the years? Please. They have full-time employees whose entire job is to massage their relationship with government officials.

And affordable housing? What? One big company is now supposed to take on the burden of building housing? That sounds like the missing chapter to Orwell’s 1984. The giant company that sells everything and is in charge of your community, your transportation, and your housing.

Just stop. Businesses run their businesses and people take care of their communities. The American Way has always been to hire the best people you can find, and in turn, those people will create a vibrant community. It’s up to the people, not a company, to build the infrastructure of a community. This isn’t Russia or Cuba. America is built on competition and the free market.

Build your own community. Build your own transportation. Don’t single out one company because it’s successful. That’s not the American Way.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

This NOAA satellite image shows a tropical depression becoming Tropical Storm Hernan over the East ...

Associated Press

Tropical Storm Hernan forms in the Pacific while a different weather system could soak Hawaii

HONOLULU (AP) — Tropical Storm Hernan formed Thursday in the Pacific Ocean and wasn’t threatening land while a different storm system that could bring heavy rain and flooding this weekend moved toward Hawaii, forecasters said. Hernan was about 1,460 miles (2,350 kilometers) west of the southern tip of the Baja California peninsula of Mexico, the […]

3 minutes ago

President Donald Trump speaks as Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., right, ...

Associated Press

Trump’s vaccine plan would require millions of individual shots last used decades ago

WASHINGTON (AP) — Public health experts have been quick to condemn an executive order from President Donald Trump aimed at upending childhood vaccinations in the U.S., but the biggest obstacles may be the unprecedented financial and logistical challenges it would impose on parents, health providers and drugmakers. Monday’s announcement by the Republican president calls for […]

12 minutes ago

FILE - Friends practice volleyball at a local park in Gilbert, Ariz., March 15, 2020. (AP Photo/Mat...

Associated Press

Higher-income families more likely to enroll kids in organized sports, an AP-Ipsos poll finds

WASHINGTON (AP) — Americans overwhelmingly see major benefits to children playing organized sports, a new poll finds, but higher-income families are more likely to participate. Learning teamwork and reducing screen time are among the perceived benefits of youth sports, according to the AP-Ipsos survey. About half of U.S. parents with K-12 school-aged children say their […]

2 hours ago

Florida Democratic gubernatorial candidate David Jolly, speaks during a town hall meeting, Saturday...

Associated Press

Mission Improbable: A onetime Republican is trying to prove Democrats can win in Florida

LEESBURG, Fla. (AP) — Cyn Doyle is a self-described political cynic. So when David Jolly, the Republican-turned-independent who is now running for Florida governor as a Democrat, swung through this town dotted by lakes and Spanish moss, she had doubts. “How can you assure us,” the 71-year-old pressed, “that you won’t become another John Fetterman?” […]

2 hours ago

FILE - Franklin Fuentes searches for missing relatives in the collapsed building where they lived t...

Associated Press

Colombia’s earthquake is déjà vu for Venezuelans. The government response is anything but

BUENOS AIRES, Argentina (AP) — For the second time in two months, the ground was shaking in South America. Once again, families flooded social media with pleas for help finding missing loved ones under flattened buildings. Once again, governments across political divides and continents pledged aid. But in many ways, the contrast between Colombia’s 7.4-magnitude […]

5 hours ago

The exterior of the Kennedy Center is seen, Friday, July 31, 2026, in Washington. (AP Photo/Mark Sc...

Associated Press

Kennedy Center board set to vote on whether to move forward with closure

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Kennedy Center’s board is expected to meet Thursday to consider plans for the performing arts venue’s future after a federal judge blocked an earlier move for a two-year closure that would allow for substantial renovations. Ahead of the meeting, the Kennedy Center’s management said it would present the board with three […]

6 hours ago

Asking Amazon to contribute is not the American Way