SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Asking Amazon to contribute is not the American Way

Oct 17, 2017, 1:35 PM | Updated: 2:22 pm

Amazon, tech hubs...

The Amazon Spheres in Seattle. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)

(AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)

As the deadline for Amazon’s HQ2 approaches, a new rallying cry is emerging. Civic groups are now saying that Amazon isn’t doing its fair share.

I’m a person that is driven by fairness, too, but let’s take a closer look at the logic of this argument.

RELATED: Let’s talk about the growing disparity in Seattle

A letter addressed to Amazon titled “Our HQ2 Wishlist” has been published. Advocacy groups can add their names to this document that divides their requests into three areas: Jobs; Great Communities; and Accountability and Transparency. These groups are from the areas bidding on HQ2.

I completely agree with the jobs part. That makes sense. But the other two categories seem new to me. Are we now saying that when a company becomes a certain size that the normal rules of business in America no longer apply?

These groups would like Amazon to forgo tax breaks, be responsible for transportation issues and affordable housing. They want Amazon to protect small businesses and be transparent and accountable to some outside group. They are asking the tech giant to be “fully committed to open-sourcing the process of reaching … our whole community.”

What are we talking about here? Since when has it been the responsibility of one company to do any of these things? Do a quick Google search — or Bing if you work in Redmond — on Fortune 500 tax breaks, and you’ll find this is the way things get done. Big companies get tax breaks. Builders build houses and municipalities build roads.

So why do cities give big companies like Boeing or Microsoft tax breaks? Because it’s good for the cities in the long run to have quality jobs available. Do you think that Microsoft paid for all those fancy improvements to Highway 520 over the years? Please. They have full-time employees whose entire job is to massage their relationship with government officials.

And affordable housing? What? One big company is now supposed to take on the burden of building housing? That sounds like the missing chapter to Orwell’s 1984. The giant company that sells everything and is in charge of your community, your transportation, and your housing.

Just stop. Businesses run their businesses and people take care of their communities. The American Way has always been to hire the best people you can find, and in turn, those people will create a vibrant community. It’s up to the people, not a company, to build the infrastructure of a community. This isn’t Russia or Cuba. America is built on competition and the free market.

Build your own community. Build your own transportation. Don’t single out one company because it’s successful. That’s not the American Way.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

Marysville police...

MyNorthwest Staff

Marysville woman arrested after police say she threatened to shoot her daughter

A Marysville woman was arrested Saturday evening after police say she threatened to get a gun and shoot her daughter. Her arrest came after a SWAT standoff at the family's home.

14 minutes ago

Police work near the scene of a plane crash in Greenacres, Fla., Monday, Nov. 2, 2026. (AP Photo/Re...

Associated Press

Victims of Florida plane crash include a 20-year-old who got her pilot’s license as a teen

A 20-year-old woman with a pilot’s license was among nine people killed when a small jet crashed and exploded in South Florida, her family said. Camila Corteleti told the New York Post and New York Times that her daughter, Nathalia Gadelha Filgueiras, was the copilot flying a Learjet from Austin, Texas, to the Bahamas, Sunday […]

38 minutes ago

Election Ballot 2...

MyNorthwest Staff

Ahead of midterm election King County stands ready to battle federal government in court

On the eve of Election Day, King County Prosecuting Attorney Leesa Manion says the county is watching for federal interference in the election and is ready to go to court if needed.

42 minutes ago

snohomish shooting...

MyNorthwest Staff

1 killed, 1 wounded in overnight Snohomish shooting; suspect still at large

One 21-year-old man was killed, and another was injured in a shooting early Sunday morning in Snohomish.

42 minutes ago

FILE - The SS-25 well where the 2015 gas leak occurred is covered at the Southern California Gas Co...

Associated Press

Millions of dollars from the worst US gas leak are now available to help residents electrify homes

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Millions of dollars of settlement money from the largest known methane leak in the United States are now available to affected residents to replace gas-powered appliances with electric ones. Organizations involved in distributing the money say it will help create safer and cleaner homes. The announcement makes available the first $20 […]

1 hour ago

bird flu...

MyNorthwest Staff

Yakima resident dies after exposure to Bird Flu; third human case confirmed

A Yakima County resident who caught bird flu after being exposed to infected dairy cattle has died, the Yakima Health District announced Sunday.

1 hour ago

Asking Amazon to contribute is not the American Way