SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Dori: If judge had kept alleged dog thief in jail, he would still be alive

Nov 26, 2019, 8:54 AM

dog thief, Black Diamond...

Alleged car and dog thief Anthony Chilcott was identified by police from this surveillance video. (KIRO 7 TV)

(KIRO 7 TV)

By now, I’m sure you’ve heard the story of Monkey the poodle, who was stolen with a nearly brand-new truck from a gas station in Black Diamond on Friday. Thankfully, Monkey was reunited with his loving owners, but the alleged dog thief was fatally shot by officers after leading police on a chase on Monday.

Now that the stolen dog is safe, the story shifts dramatically. Now we need to talk about how unbelievably messed up our judicial system is.

I’m so infuriated at this story. The man who stole this truck and dog was allegedly the same man who was in custody just 13 days ago with a $5,000 bond. Anthony Chilcott, 36, has no known address. He’s a vagrant who has been walking around Black Diamond pretty much his whole adult life. Everybody in town knows who this guy is, as we’ve been hearing.

This suspected dog thief violently resisted arrest less than a month ago, according to Black Diamond Police Commander Larry Colagiovanni. He caused thousands of dollars of damage to a police vehicle, and cops had to use a Taser to restrain him.

Dori: Judge Veronica Alicea-Galvan endangers us with social justice rulings

This judge decided to ignore the $5,000 bond on Chilcott. The judge let this guy walk free on personal recognizance. Chilcott was supposed to be in court on Tuesday of this week. Did the judge really think Chilcott was going to show up to his court date?

The judge knew this suspect’s long, violent criminal history, and could have easily predicted that this man would go on to commit more crimes once being set free.

And sure enough, less than two weeks later, he was clearly identified through surveillance video as stealing a truck with a dog inside of it.

We heard from the dog’s owner that the suspect dragged the detectives down the street with the truck. That is assault with a deadly vehicle.

What would have happened if, during the two high-speed chases that occurred Monday, an innocent person driving down the road had been wiped out by this violent dog thief? He was in an incredibly powerful Ford F-150 Raptor. If someone had been hurt, would they have been able to sue the judge who let him walk free?

The answer is no. Our legal system gives judges tremendous protection for the consequences of the decisions they make.

Does the judge feel guilty over this suspect’s death? Or is the judge so wrapped up in their liberal activism that they actually believe they did the right thing 13 days ago when they put this violent guy back out on the streets? This guy walked free … right to his death.

Does the judge pause and reflect and think, “If I had kept this guy locked up on the $5,000 bond, he’d be a lot safer now?” Or will they high-five their fellow activist judges as they follow their social justice agenda?

I would love to talk to one of these judges. But they never talk to us.

There was a big story in the Seattle Times on Monday that the Seattle City Council is going to push for letting more criminals who commit property crimes walk free. What about getting help for all the victims? When are we going to have a legal system that cares about the victims one-fiftieth to the extent that it cares about the criminals?

These activist judges want to rehabilitate people rather than punish them. People ask me, should the justice system be about rehabilitation or punishment? It should be about both. If we send a message that you will not be punished when you commit crimes, you will keep committing crimes. If we are interested in rehabilitation, then that needs to come at the end of the punishment. But we have to get back to the idea that there are consequences for your actions.

This guy should have gotten a year or two in jail if convicted of resisting arrest and vandalizing the police vehicle. And then at the end of that year or two, we should have offered him every service available. But bypassing punishment and going straight to services is not working. Just look at what is happening on the streets around here.

Please spare some of your prayers for the cops involved, who had to fire their weapons. Cops don’t ever want to shoot. And they have to live with the consequences of making life-or-death decisions.

A judge put those cops in that unimaginable situation.

We have to keep the pressure on.

Listen to the Dori Monson Show weekday afternoons from 12-3 p.m. on KIRO Radio, 97.3 FM. Subscribe to the podcast here.

FILE - Dr. Anthony Fauci, former director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Disea...

Associated Press

Anthony Fauci again faces questions from Senate Republicans about pandemic origins

Dr. Anthony Fauci, the U.S. scientist who helped lead the nation’s COVID-19 pandemic response, is set to face off — again — with a Republican senator probing the origins of the coronavirus. Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky subpoenaed Fauci to appear before a Senate committee Wednesday. It’s part of Paul’s yearslong accusations that the now-retired […]

1 hour ago

Associated Press

Russia charges Telegram founder Pavel Durov with aiding terrorism and puts him on wanted list

Russia’s main domestic security agency said Wednesday that Pavel Durov, founder of the messaging app Telegram, has been charged with “aiding terrorism” and put on an international wanted list. Telegram’s administration has not removed “numerous channels, chats and bots” that are “actively used by Ukrainian intelligence agencies, terrorist, and extremist organizations to prepare and coordinate […]

3 hours ago

A variety of robots are displayed at the World AI Conference in Shanghai, Friday, July 17, 2026. (A...

Associated Press

US bans foreign-made humanoid robots, targeting China over national security

HONG KONG (AP) — The Federal Communications Commission in the U.S. said on Tuesday it would ban the import of foreign-made humanoid robots in a move that targets China, arguing they pose a national security risk. The decision could strain bilateral relations as the technology race between the two world leaders advances. China makes substantially […]

4 hours ago

The border between Syria and the Israeli-controlled Golan Heights town of Majdal Shams is seen Tues...

Associated Press

Fringe Israeli settler group is sneaking into Syria to try to claim land for a Jewish outpost

NAHARIYA, Israel (AP) — The Israeli military was about to launch a nighttime strike on a group of men in southern Syria when the soldiers noticed the long curls dangling from the temples of their targets. The troops held their fire. These were not Syrian militants attempting to breach Israel’s border but religious Jews who […]

5 hours ago

This satellite image provided by Planet Labs PBC on July 27, 2026 shows smoke rising from the Saudi...

Associated Press

Jordan intercepts Iranian missiles as US and Saudi Arabia launch strikes against militias in Iraq

CAIRO (AP) — Jordan’s air defenses intercepted five missiles launched from Iran early Wednesday, the country’s military said, hours after the U.S. military said it had knocked down an Iranian missile barrage launched against American forces in the Middle East, shattering a brief pause in fighting. The Jordanian military said the missiles had been “intercepted […]

5 hours ago

Patrick Clancy, the father of Cora, Dawson and Callan Clancy testifies for the prosecution against ...

Associated Press

Lindsay Clancy’s ex-husband set to resume testifying about the day she killed their 3 children

PLYMOUTH, Mass. (AP) — The former husband of a Massachusetts woman on trial for killing their three young children is expected to return to the stand Wednesday, continuing his testimony about a day that began with art projects and playtime in the snow and ended with him coming home to find the bodies. Prosecutors say […]

6 hours ago

Dori: If judge had kept alleged dog thief in jail, he would still be alive