SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Dori: Seattle’s new nanny law benefits unions, doesn’t help nannies, hurts families

Jul 25, 2018, 6:00 AM

domestic workers bill of rights...

A photo of a nanny and a child. (Photo:

As predicted, it was a unanimous vote to pass Seattle’s new nanny law — a bill of rights for domestic workers. You want to talk about a classic example of what government is all about around here? This will not help the nannies and the house-cleaners. It will certainly not help the residents who pay them. This is about two things and two things only.

The new nanny law requires employers to give nannies paid breaks. So if you hire a nanny for, say, a nine-hour day while you and your spouse are at work, you have to give them a half-hour lunchbreak and a couple of 10-minute breaks. That’s tough to do if you’re a nanny. If the kids are climbing on the roof, you say, “Sorry, I’m on my break, can’t do anything about it.”

By the way, if you’re sitting on the couch watching a DVD with the kids, that’s not break time, that’s working. You’ve got to get a break that’s not watching a DVD.

RELATED: Dori says teachers union doesn’t care about our kids

If you’re a nanny you can’t just leave the kids alone, so the way the law works is that the families have to pay the nannies for the breaks they didn’t take. So if these nannies make $15 an hour, and you’ve got to pay them for 50 minutes of break time they didn’t take, then that works out to about $12.50 a day. That’s more than $3,000 per year that you have to pay your nanny for nothing.

But here’s the thing — almost none of this goes to the nanny. It goes to taxes and it goes to union dues. The Service Employees International Union was pushing for this nanny law. The union gets rich off this — they get more members and more dues — and the politicians get more power. Because the unions support the whack-jobs on the Seattle City Council. It’s all about power, money, and control, and everyone else loses. The nanny gets virtually nothing extra, and the family has to pay $3,000 more a year in childcare costs.

This is the Seattle City Council unanimously deciding to jack up the cost of child care. They claim to care so much about working families, but clearly they don’t. Very few of the council members have kids. They don’t know what it’s like to raise a family and to try to make ends meet. You’ve got Mike O’Brien, growing up in Clyde Hill with a silver spoon in his mouth and not wanting for anything for a day in his life. These people have no problem adding thousands of dollars in childcare costs to the people of this city.

Oh, and as part of this new nanny law, five positions will be created to oversee the law at a total cost of $690,000 per year. So the Seattle City Council gets to give five of their cronies a $140,000-per-year gig to oversee the house-cleaner and nanny law. And the families of Seattle get royally screwed over in the process.

You are being screwed over at the city, county, state, and federal level. It’s all about the power of politicians — don’t ever forget that.

Democratic candidate for Texas governor Gina Hinojosa, third from the left, listens to Stephen Sand...

Associated Press

Democrats try to harness data center backlash that’s dividing rural Republicans in places like Texas

AMARILLO, Texas (AP) — When Gina Hinojosa, the Democratic nominee for Texas governor, began her campaign last year, candidates weren’t talking about — or hearing about — data centers. But with barely three months until November’s contest, the perceived threat to rural life, ranchland and dwindling water supplies could become a defining issue for her […]

1 hour ago

FILE - This photo made available by the Ramsey County Sheriff's Office shows Vance Luther Boelter, ...

Associated Press

Man who pleaded guilty to killing top Minnesota Democratic lawmaker and her husband to be sentenced

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — The Minnesota man who pleaded guilty to killing a top Democratic lawmaker and her husband is set to be sentenced in federal court Thursday. Vance Boelter, 59, agreed to plead guilty in June, almost a year after the Minneapolis-area attacks when he stalked and killed House Speaker Melissa Hortman and her husband […]

1 hour ago

FILE - Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr., listens during a Cabinet meeti...

Associated Press

FDA reviews peptide injections favored by RFK Jr. and wellness influencers

WASHINGTON (AP) — Health advisers begin meeting Thursday to review more than a half-dozen peptides, unproven substances that have become a growing wellness trend despite little evidence they are safe or effective. The two-day meeting hosted by the Food and Drug Administration has the backing of Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who has described […]

1 hour ago

Kimeona Kane rides with his nephew, Gabriel Shimaoka, and niece, Genesis Shimaoka, in the bed of hi...

Associated Press

Hawaii raises truck bed-riding age to 16 as roads get faster, testing a cherished island tradition

KAILUA, Hawaii (AP) — It’s common to see people riding in the beds of pickups in Hawaii, often along country highways sandwiched between towering verdant mountains and the glassy blue expanse of the Pacific. “It’s a cultural thing, especially in a small, agricultural community,” said Kimeona Kane, who would jump into the bed of a […]

1 hour ago

United States Navy personnel salute during the national anthem at a watch party in a fan village in...

Associated Press

Navy says it will no longer release sailors’ service history, another restriction on press access

WASHINGTON (AP) — The U.S. Navy is taking a major step to restrict press access to information about service members by no longer releasing information about any sailor’s service history — information that has been freely offered by the service for decades. The move, which officials say is being driven by increased security threats and […]

1 hour ago

Amish Shah, who is seeking the Democratic nomination for Arizona's 1st Congressional District, spea...

Associated Press

Amish Shah wins Democratic congressional primary in Arizona, a blow to the party establishment

PHOENIX (AP) — Amish Shah won the Democratic primary Wednesday in a hotly contested congressional district in Arizona, delivering another defeat to the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, which backed a rival, as more voters reject the preferences of party leaders in Washington. Shah, an emergency physician, will face Republican Jay Feely, a former NFL kicker […]

3 hours ago

Dori: Seattle’s new nanny law benefits unions, doesn’t help nannies, hurts families