SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Dori: Seattle’s new nanny law benefits unions, doesn’t help nannies, hurts families

Jul 25, 2018, 6:00 AM

domestic workers bill of rights...

A photo of a nanny and a child. (Photo:

As predicted, it was a unanimous vote to pass Seattle’s new nanny law — a bill of rights for domestic workers. You want to talk about a classic example of what government is all about around here? This will not help the nannies and the house-cleaners. It will certainly not help the residents who pay them. This is about two things and two things only.

The new nanny law requires employers to give nannies paid breaks. So if you hire a nanny for, say, a nine-hour day while you and your spouse are at work, you have to give them a half-hour lunchbreak and a couple of 10-minute breaks. That’s tough to do if you’re a nanny. If the kids are climbing on the roof, you say, “Sorry, I’m on my break, can’t do anything about it.”

By the way, if you’re sitting on the couch watching a DVD with the kids, that’s not break time, that’s working. You’ve got to get a break that’s not watching a DVD.

RELATED: Dori says teachers union doesn’t care about our kids

If you’re a nanny you can’t just leave the kids alone, so the way the law works is that the families have to pay the nannies for the breaks they didn’t take. So if these nannies make $15 an hour, and you’ve got to pay them for 50 minutes of break time they didn’t take, then that works out to about $12.50 a day. That’s more than $3,000 per year that you have to pay your nanny for nothing.

But here’s the thing — almost none of this goes to the nanny. It goes to taxes and it goes to union dues. The Service Employees International Union was pushing for this nanny law. The union gets rich off this — they get more members and more dues — and the politicians get more power. Because the unions support the whack-jobs on the Seattle City Council. It’s all about power, money, and control, and everyone else loses. The nanny gets virtually nothing extra, and the family has to pay $3,000 more a year in childcare costs.

This is the Seattle City Council unanimously deciding to jack up the cost of child care. They claim to care so much about working families, but clearly they don’t. Very few of the council members have kids. They don’t know what it’s like to raise a family and to try to make ends meet. You’ve got Mike O’Brien, growing up in Clyde Hill with a silver spoon in his mouth and not wanting for anything for a day in his life. These people have no problem adding thousands of dollars in childcare costs to the people of this city.

Oh, and as part of this new nanny law, five positions will be created to oversee the law at a total cost of $690,000 per year. So the Seattle City Council gets to give five of their cronies a $140,000-per-year gig to oversee the house-cleaner and nanny law. And the families of Seattle get royally screwed over in the process.

You are being screwed over at the city, county, state, and federal level. It’s all about the power of politicians — don’t ever forget that.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

President Donald Trump, center right, and first lady Melania Trump, right, greet China's President ...

Associated Press

Trump’s state dinner for Xi to feature sea bass and a long list of tech titans

WASHINGTON (AP) — A tech-heavy guest list, the fashion choices of those on it, who sits where, their body language throughout the night and what’s on the menu: these are the softer — often and glitzier — details of diplomacy. They will be closely scrutinized at Thursday’s state dinner, offering potential clues about where things […]

5 minutes ago

Brazil's President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva speaks during the 81st session of the United Nations ...

Associated Press

In their words: From across the world, leaders call for action on climate change at the UN

NEW YORK (AP) — U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said the world cannot “allow countries and cultures to vanish beneath the waves” on Thursday as the General Assembly approved its first declaration on sea-level rise. This statement is meant to shift the international response to the rise in sea level driven by humans from fragmented initiatives […]

6 minutes ago

Oregon hospital baby...

Gee Scott

Gee: ‘Wait, what?!’ Oregon hospital told parents to drive their dead baby home — something can be legal and still be heartless

A Seattle family says an Oregon hospital told them to drive their dead 8-month-old home. Gee Scott says legal isn't the same as humane.

11 minutes ago

FILE - The Supreme Court is seen on Capitol Hill in Washington, Aug. 25, 2026. (AP Photo/J. Scott A...

Associated Press

Trump administration asks the Supreme Court to allow quick third-country deportations

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump’s administration asked the Supreme Court on Thursday to again clear the way for continued quick deportations of immigrants to third countries where they have no ties. The appeal comes after lower courts found that people must have the chance to object before the U.S. government deports them to countries […]

27 minutes ago

President Donald Trump and China's President Xi Jinping walk along the Colonnade of the White House...

Associated Press

Trump relishes showing Xi his Marine One chopper and new White House helipad

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump showed off some of his favorite things at the White House for the visiting leader of communist China on Thursday — bringing him inside his Marine One helicopter and exhibiting a new granite landing pad he built for it, along with the hulking, nearby construction site that will one […]

27 minutes ago

boeing strike engineers...

Lexi Herda, KIRO 7 News

Engineers, technical workers ready to vote on Boeing’s contract offer

16,000 Boeing engineers and technical workers are preparing to vote on a new contract offer from the company.

36 minutes ago

Dori: Seattle’s new nanny law benefits unions, doesn’t help nannies, hurts families