SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Dori: State Supreme Court ruled by ideology in gay wedding case

Jun 7, 2019, 4:55 PM

Seattle income tax, I-27, mccleary, I-940, state Supreme Court, youtube channel...

Washington State Supreme Court. (Harvey Barrison, Flickr)

(Harvey Barrison, Flickr)

Freedom is under attack here in Washington. The Washington State Supreme Court, as I’ve told you for a long time, does not rule by the state constitution; it rules by political and social ideology. And I cannot think of anything more dangerous.

Our attorney general is a pit bull attack dog against anything right of center or Libertarian or even in the center. But he will let his party, the Democrats, practically get away with murder. For instance, the City of Seattle is back in court trying to pass an income tax that is clearly in violation of the constitution. Bob Ferguson could have put a stop to this long ago, but because of his thirst to be governor, he allows the city to keep wasting millions of taxpayer dollars on this case. He will not do anything to upset the left, for whom an income tax is the Holy Grail.

Ferguson’s predecessor Rob McKenna, pre-empted the need for all of these expensive court cases by showing that an income tax is clearly not allowed under our state constitution.

Bob Ferguson also won’t go after Sound Transit for illegally calculating your car’s value. He twists the wording of the 405 toll lane regulations, which are operating illegally — they did not meet the standards that WSDOT promised to the voters. He is about the most dangerous political hack I have observed in my 24 years on the air.

Our state Supreme Court is cut from the same cloth because they do not rule by the law or by the state constitution. You see, laws have to be constitutional.

SCOTUS ruling could help Arlene’s Flowers case

The case with Arlene’s Flowers in the Tri-Cities is the perfect example. Florist Barronelle Stutzman owns Arlene’s Flowers and had a frequent customer with whom she became friends. This man happened to be gay, and when he asked her if she would do the flowers for his wedding ceremony, she politely told him that, unfortunately, she could not participate in a ceremony that violates her Christian view that marriage is between a man and a woman.

Under our state constitution, I think it is pretty unequivocal that she is within her rights to not participate in a ceremony that violates her religious beliefs. This is Article 1, Section 11:

Absolute freedom of conscience in all matters of religious sentiment, belief and worship, shall be guaranteed to every individual, and no one shall be molested or disturbed in person or property on account of religion.

Her business is her property. And they are disturbing her property because of her religion. I’m not a lawyer, but anyone can interpret this. The state constitution is very clear on this.

There were dozens of other florists who would happily have done the flowers, and Barronelle recommended some to her friend and customer. But Bob Ferguson wanted to make an example of her because she is Christian. The radical left despises people of faith. And so he has gone after her for years.

The state Supreme Court on Thursday ruled in favor of Bob Ferguson’s witch hunt against this woman’s Christian faith. Barronelle plans to appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, and I will bet money that the U.S. Supreme Court will overturn the decision made by the radical Washington State Supreme Court. Ferguson is citing a rule that says you have to sell your product to anyone who comes in. But that cannot override our constitution, the basis of our state, our foundational underpinning.

I get so frustrated because our educational system is so lacking. Most adults I’m sure cannot correctly say what kind of governmental system we live in. They would say it’s a democracy. It is not; it is a democratic republic. The tyranny of the majority cannot tear apart the constitution and what it protects. While we have made amendments to our federal constitution to give equal rights to people of color and women, our state constitution also gives protection to people of faith, to not be disturbed in their home or business because of their faith.

We truly are living in a state where tyranny is accepted. Bob Ferguson will go after anyone who does not agree with him, but he will give political protection like a mobster to the far left. The state Supreme Court will do anything for the teachers union that got them elected. The unions give the justices money for their campaigns, and then the justices are there to do their bidding. They don’t rule by our constitution. And because we have a bunch of leftist ideologues on our state Supreme Court, they would never rule in favor of a person’s faith under that provision of our state constitution.

FILE - People embrace near the scene of a shooting outside the Islamic Center in San Diego, May 18,...

Associated Press

Parents of San Diego mosque gunman say a mental health facility failed to heed FBI warning

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Just days before two teenagers carried out a mass shooting at a San Diego mosque, federal law enforcement officials warned the parents of one of the shooters that their son was making concerning comments about school shootings on the dark web, according to new details included in a recently filed lawsuit. […]

3 minutes ago

Venus Williams, left, and Serena Williams, of the United States, look on as they play against Hao-C...

Associated Press

Venus and Serena Williams put on a show in thrilling U.S. Open return, in photos

NEW YORK (AP) — The Williams sisters returned to the U.S. Open doubles court, thrilling a packed Arthur Ashe Stadium crowd with a three-set battle that came down to the final points. Venus and Serena Williams fell to Hao-Ching Chan and Maya Joint in a dramatic tiebreaker.

4 hours ago

President Donald Trump speaks in the Oval Office of the White House, Thursday, Aug. 27, 2026, in Wa...

Associated Press

Trump’s first major midterm money move: A $10M Texas Senate ad blitz

BRIDGEWATER, New Jersey (AP) — The political group associated with President Donald Trump is spending $10 million on television and digital advertisements in the Texas Senate race, according to a Saturday filing with the Federal Election Commission. This is the first significant spending in a premier general election contest by MAGA, Inc., and reflects how […]

6 hours ago

Associated Press

Robin Morgan, feminist, poet and editor, dies at 85

NEW YORK (AP) — Robin Morgan, a wholesome child star of the 1940s and ‘50s who grew up to become an all-American radical as a poet, essayist, editor and second-wave feminist, has died. She was 85. Morgan’s death was confirmed Saturday by the Women’s Media Center, an organization she cofounded with Jane Fonda and the […]

7 hours ago

The John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, is seen, Wednesday, Sept. 2, 2026, in Washingto...

Associated Press

Kennedy Center renews call for Trump-backed shutdown after part of a ceiling collapses

WASHINGTON (AP) — A chunk of ceiling fell inside a main hallway of the Kennedy Center, according to a spokesperson who said the damage underscores the need to shut down the historic arts venue for renovations sought by President Donald Trump. No one was injured when a piece of the ceiling inside the Kennedy Center’s […]

7 hours ago

Associated Press

Cubans and Afghans deported from US arrive in Guyana

GEORGETOWN, Guyana (AP) — Guyana ’s government said Saturday it has received the first of six deportees from the United States under the Trump administration’s third-country deportation system. Guyana’s Foreign Secretary Robert Persaud said the six nationals of Cuba and Afghanistan arrived on Friday after being vetted by his administration and found to have no […]

8 hours ago

Dori: State Supreme Court ruled by ideology in gay wedding case