SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Dori: Time for Councilmember Kshama Sawant to apologize

Dec 12, 2017, 5:45 AM

Sawant, Charleena Lyles, Seattle police...

Kshama Sawant. (Seattle Channel)

(Seattle Channel)

A multi-member Force Review Board explained why the two Seattle Police officers who shot and killed Charleena Lyles on June 18 had no other viable options.

RELATED: Let’s not let Charleena Lyles’ death be in vain

And now it is time for Councilmember Kshama Sawant to apologize.

Sawant, who has been sued for slander by two police officers involved in another shooting, wants the courts to assume her innocent until proven guilty. This standard that she expects — that we all expect — is one that she continually refuses to grant to police officers in this city.

She has sharply criticized the Seattle Police Department for their actions surrounding the Charleena Lyles shooting, well before all the facts came out. She has manipulated the emotions surrounding the tragic death of Lyles to drum up public hatred for Seattle cops.

The Force Review Board’s report, which The Seattle Times reported was even longer and more exhaustive than usual, explains in detail why Tasers, pepper spray, and batons were not appropriate alternatives to using lethal force against Lyles.

Neither officer involved had a Taser. Steven McNew was not assigned one. Jason Anderson’s had a dead battery. But even if both officers had working Tasers, the report states they likely wouldn’t have been effective because the devices don’t work through baggy clothing. Lyles was wearing a puffy jacket.

Pepper spray also would have been unsuccessful. Given the small size of the apartment, pepper spray might have disabled Lyles. But it also might have disabled the police officers themselves, making them even more vulnerable to attack.

Although both officers were carrying batons, the apartment space was too small to draw and use them effectively. And because Lyles was wielding a knife, the officers were not to engage in hand-to-hand combat.

The report states, “One well-placed slash or stab wound can cause an individual to rapidly bleed out.”

The fact of the matter is that cops have to rely on training, policies, guidelines, and experience. The nobility of the job calls them to risk their lives for all of us.

I will call out cops who do wrong and I often have, but the Charleena Lyles shooting, as horrible as the outcome was for her and her family, was not the fault of the two police officers involved. They couldn’t back out with children at risk in the apartment. Any option less lethal would have been in violation of their training.

It’s time to ditch the running narrative that all Seattle police officers are out to shoot, rather than protect.

It’s time for Councilmember Sawant to apologize.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

shon barnes katie wilson seattle city hall rally...

John Curley Show

‘City council would rather blame the mayor’: Saul Spady argues 7 of 9 seats are up, nobody wants fingerprints on the crisis

Quality of Life Coalition founder Saul Spady said the Seattle City Council is letting Mayor Katie Wilson absorb all the public anger while doing nothing itself.

34 minutes ago

e-bike er visit child...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘All of the e-bike answers are bad ones’: KIRO hosts question the premise of e-bikes as child ER visits surge nationwide

KIRO hosts debate e-bikes' safety as child ER visits increase, highlighting concerns over regulation and social pressures on young riders.

34 minutes ago

carbon program wa cost...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘Get rid of the damn thing’: Gee blasts WA’s carbon program for costing too much, delivering too little

Washington's carbon program faces backlash for high costs and low impact as it moves toward merging with California and Quebec.

34 minutes ago

seattle ranking cities...

MyNorthwest Staff

Seattle earns 4th-highest ranking in the world in new study of 1,000 cities

A new study ranks Seattle 4th globally, highlighting governance, economics, and quality of life among cities.

35 minutes ago

This combination photo shows Rebecca Bennett, a Democrat candidate for New Jersey's 7th Congression...

Associated Press

Kean returned to Congress after an unexplained absence. Now it’s time for his first and only debate

Tom Kean Jr., the Republican congressman from New Jersey whose four-month absence from the House this year went unexplained until he disclosed that he was being treated for depression, and Democrat Rebecca Bennett are readying for the first and only campaign debate Sunday night in their closely contested race. The approval rating is deeply underwater […]

36 minutes ago

Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, questions Dr. Heidi Overton during her nomination hearing to become th...

Associated Press

Supreme Court vote shadows Maine Sen. Susan Collins in her first bid after abortion rights decision

GORHAM, Maine (AP) — For years, Planned Parenthood’s endorsement of Susan Collins was enough to persuade Erin Evans to vote for Maine’s longtime U.S. senator, believing that the moderate Republican would protect abortion access. Evans is now “just furious with myself” for those votes. The 56-year-old from Portland described Collins’ critical vote to confirm Brett […]

40 minutes ago

Dori: Time for Councilmember Kshama Sawant to apologize