SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

‘Downton Abbey’ is flawed, but fans of the show won’t mind

Sep 23, 2019, 6:31 AM | Updated: Sep 24, 2019, 6:34 pm

Downton Abbey is the much anticipated cinematic follow-up to the acclaimed British TV series about an upper-crust family and its lower-class servants, which all takes place in a plummy aristocratic English mansion nearly a century ago.

Fans will no doubt melt into their seats when they hear the familiar strains of the Downton Abbey theme music. This new movie version of the hit TV series is strictly for its legions of fans. And yes, I consider myself one of them.

‘Ad Astra’ feels like a sci-fi version of ‘Apocalypse Now’

The film makes no concessions to newcomers. You either know these characters or you don’t. What makes it hard for the uninitiated is certainly not the ability to follow the storyline. It’s as simple as simple gets. It’s just that it’s not a very interesting plot for those with no predetermined love for the characters. The premise of the movie is that the King and Queen of England are visiting Downton Abbey for an overnight stay and, of course, the Crawley family and its downstairs staff is all atwitter. Crises arise and are averted at a nice clip.

Screenwriter Julian Fellowes deserves credit for crafting a script that allows for at least 20 cherished characters from the Downton Abbey household to deliver lines and still have enough space left over to introduce five new characters as well.

But sometimes putting small-screen stories on the big screen exposes some of the weaknesses and flaws of the original material — this is indeed true of Downton Abbey, the movie.

‘IT Chapter 2’ has plenty of chills, but three hours worth is tiring

Even fans like me fully acknowledge some of the series’ shortcomings — ridiculously miraculous recoveries, melodramatic criminal matters, etc.  This is all set amidst the appealing historical context, the fascinating sociological strains, and the gossipy personal crises of the well-to-do Crawley family and its servants.

It’s just that the flaws were usually overwhelmed by the constant and rapid-fire developments of hours-and-hours of programming made possible by long-form television. In a two-hour film, the plot contrivances stand in starker relief. Even the famed witticisms of Maggie Smith’s Countess of Grantham come off as a little too staged in the film.

At one point, the Countess counters a crack made by her son, the Earl of Grantham, with a curt dismissal: Sarcasm is the lowest form of wit. Likewise, one might say big screen versions of top-drawer television shows are the lowest form of cinema, to which Downton Abbey fans might say, “Who cares?”

Please follow our Community Guidelines

Associated Press

Asian shares are mostly higher and Mideast tensions push Brent crude past $96

BANGKOK (AP) — Asian shares were mostly higher on Thursday, while the intensifying war with Iran pushed Brent crude past $96 a barrel. South Korea’s Kospi rose 3.7%, to 7,028.66 as investors’ appetite for stocks related to artificial intelligence revived despite a retreat on Wall Street. Samsung Electronics gained 3%, while memory chipmaker SK Hynix […]

38 minutes ago

Democratic candidate for Texas governor Gina Hinojosa, third from the left, listens to Stephen Sand...

Associated Press

Democrats try to harness data center backlash that’s dividing rural Republicans in places like Texas

AMARILLO, Texas (AP) — When Gina Hinojosa, the Democratic nominee for Texas governor, began her campaign last year, candidates weren’t talking about — or hearing about — data centers. But with barely three months until November’s contest, the perceived threat to rural life, ranchland and dwindling water supplies could become a defining issue for her […]

2 hours ago

FILE - This photo made available by the Ramsey County Sheriff's Office shows Vance Luther Boelter, ...

Associated Press

Man who pleaded guilty to killing top Minnesota Democratic lawmaker and her husband to be sentenced

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — The Minnesota man who pleaded guilty to killing a top Democratic lawmaker and her husband is set to be sentenced in federal court Thursday. Vance Boelter, 59, agreed to plead guilty in June, almost a year after the Minneapolis-area attacks when he stalked and killed House Speaker Melissa Hortman and her husband […]

2 hours ago

FILE - Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr., listens during a Cabinet meeti...

Associated Press

FDA reviews peptide injections favored by RFK Jr. and wellness influencers

WASHINGTON (AP) — Health advisers begin meeting Thursday to review more than a half-dozen peptides, unproven substances that have become a growing wellness trend despite little evidence they are safe or effective. The two-day meeting hosted by the Food and Drug Administration has the backing of Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who has described […]

2 hours ago

Kimeona Kane rides with his nephew, Gabriel Shimaoka, and niece, Genesis Shimaoka, in the bed of hi...

Associated Press

Hawaii raises truck bed-riding age to 16 as roads get faster, testing a cherished island tradition

KAILUA, Hawaii (AP) — It’s common to see people riding in the beds of pickups in Hawaii, often along country highways sandwiched between towering verdant mountains and the glassy blue expanse of the Pacific. “It’s a cultural thing, especially in a small, agricultural community,” said Kimeona Kane, who would jump into the bed of a […]

2 hours ago

United States Navy personnel salute during the national anthem at a watch party in a fan village in...

Associated Press

Navy says it will no longer release sailors’ service history, another restriction on press access

WASHINGTON (AP) — The U.S. Navy is taking a major step to restrict press access to information about service members by no longer releasing information about any sailor’s service history — information that has been freely offered by the service for decades. The move, which officials say is being driven by increased security threats and […]

2 hours ago

‘Downton Abbey’ is flawed, but fans of the show won’t mind