SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

“Lincoln” is fascinating but flawed

Nov 9, 2012, 7:46 AM | Updated: 7:57 am

In the wake of the presidential election, the timing couldn’t be better for a film about arguably America’s greatest president, Abraham Lincoln. And Stephen Spielberg delivers with a fascinating but flawed “Lincoln,” starring the brilliant Daniel Day Lewis.

First and foremost, it stands as a nice corrective to all those misty-eyed “mythic” portrayals of him that we’ve grown accustomed to. This is not the Log Cabin Lincoln or the Great Debater Lincoln. This movie is also not much about the travails of the Civil War or the eloquence of the Gettysburg Address.

Instead it’s about the nitty-gritty work of passing legislation. Spielberg’s Lincoln is one “great man” who wasn’t afraid to get his hands dirty for a good cause. As a one-time rival and admirer says in the film, rarely has more corruption been done in the name of an honorable man.

The focus of the film is Lincoln’s behind-the-scenes struggle to convince Congress to pass the 13th Amendment abolishing slavery. But an equally pressing issue also demanded his attention: the Civil War was coming to an end.

The question for the President was which issue should take precedence. As fascinating as that decision is, the extent to which Lincoln was willing to go to pass the Amendment is equally enlightening. And the source of much debate among his supporters.

Patronage jobs and cold hard cash were doled out liberally. The politics may indeed have been dirty back then, but for Lincoln apparently, politics was not a dirty word.

So much for the fascinating aspect of this film. As for its flaws, we can begin and end with the storytelling. It’s dramatically hit or miss. When it misses, it’s either wooden or schmaltzy.

Lincoln’s very first scene, for instance, in which he interacts with a handful of soldiers, seems awkwardly staged, more like a photo-op gone bad than any kind of real exchange. And his lengthy discourse to the Cabinet on the ambiguities of the War Powers Act – although interesting content – comes off as unnatural and dramatically flat.

As for the schmaltz, John Williams’ score is at times so heavy-handed that it undercuts rather than supports the emotional thrust of the film. (At the climax of the film, I wrote in my notes – “Did a Broadway musical just break out?”) And at the film’s end – when Lincoln magically appears inside a single lamp flame reciting his Inaugural Address – I realize Spielberg means for it to be stirring. But it just made me cringe.

These flaws don’t ruin the movie, they just limit its emotional power. And nothing can hurt the performances of Daniel Day Lewis as Lincoln – his high-pitched voice is off-putting at first but apparently accurate – and Tommy Lee Jones as the firebrand abolitionist Thaddeus Stevens who ends up being Lincoln’s best ally in the House. Don’t be surprised if both men win Oscars this year. And Sally Field may very well got nominated for her turn as the President’s wife Mary Todd Lincoln

Please follow our Community Guidelines

Seattle News Archives & Features

Fire crews respond to a helicopter hard landing after the aircraft's engine reportedly lost power n...

Tom Brock

Two aircraft emergencies in Pierce County Saturday

Two aircraft emergencies in Pierce County Saturday resulted in injuries to one pilot. 

12 days ago

This NOAA satellite image shows the magnitude of the storm moving inland from the Pacific Ocean. (P...

Ted Buehner, KIRO Newsradio Meteorologist

What to expect as Western Washington’s first big fall storm arrives Saturday night

The fall season’s first strong weather system will sweep through Western Washington tonight, bringing strong winds and rain.

13 days ago

Associated Press

3 dead, including suspect, and 2 deputies critically injured in eastern Washington state

SPOKANE COUNTY, Wash. (AP) — A shooting and subsequent firefight with responding officers left three people dead, including the suspect, and two deputies critically wounded in eastern Washington state Tuesday. Deputies responded to a home in Spokane County, which borders Idaho, around 2:30 p.m. after a woman told her neighbor that she had been shot […]

16 days ago

Sedro-Woolley medications missing...

KIRO 7 News Staff

Student medications found missing or diluted at Sedro-Woolley schools

Students’ medications are missing or diluted at multiple schools across the Sedro-Woolley School District, according to a district statement.

30 days ago

In this photo taken with a smartphone, Mike Herrington, the FBI special agent in charge, speaks to ...

Associated Press

Washington resident charged with conspiracy in Canada shool shooting is ordered detained

SEATTLE (AP) — A Washington state resident charged with conspiracy in one of the worst school shootings in Canada’s history has been ordered detained pending further hearings in the case. Melody Bryant, also known as James Cody Bryant, of Bellingham, Washington, was charged this month with conspiring to murder people in a foreign country. Investigators […]

1 month ago

The location of the Vertical Evacuation Tower will be near the Westport Marina. It will be the thir...

Tom Brock

Rising above the risk: Westport breaks ground on Washington’s newest tsunami refuge

The city of Westport broke ground Saturday on what will become Washington state's latest tsunami-safe location: a new vertical evacuation tower.

2 months ago

“Lincoln” is fascinating but flawed