SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

New live-action ‘Beauty and the Beast’ is a worthy remake

Mar 17, 2017, 7:58 AM | Updated: 8:03 am

Warning: Potential spoilers below.

It can’t possibly match the Disney animated classic, but this new live-action version of “Beauty and the Beast” is still a worthy remake.

The 1991 original is about as honored as an animated film gets. It was the first animated film to ever be nominated for a Best Picture Oscar and a mere decade later was selected for preservation in the Library of Congress’s National Film Registry. It was a huge critical and commercial success.

Messing with a much-loved classic brings enormous risk. The first question is: “why bother?” Making a live action version of something that worked brilliantly animated is hardly justification enough unless all you care about is the box office bottom line. If it’s going to be a slavish imitation, what’s the aesthetic point? It inevitably will be compared note for note to the original and could easily be found wanting.

And secondly, does it have anything to say that wasn’t already said perfectly the first time around? Can it offer something new without being so radically different that it risks alienating its core audience?

More movie reviews by Tom Tangney

Disney and director Bill Condon aim for that very delicate balance between new and familiar, and it hits and misses in equal measure.

Let’s start with the “not too bad.” For example, our heroine Belle’s opening scene and song in the new film is pretty close to the original. And the visuals are remarkably similar too. This establishing scene doesn’t score many points for originality or inspiration, but if imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, the original must be very flattered.

Let’s call this comparison a draw.

Now we’ll move from a neutral re-creation to a bad re-do, or least to a re-creation that doesn’t measure up to the original, the blowhard villain Gaston. The animated Gaston cuts a bigger-than-life figure and in the wittiest song in the film, his toady Le Fou sings of his master’s exploits, until Gaston himself joins in on the bragging.

In the new version, the clever lyrics are muddied and Gaston’s voice simply can’t compare. Try as he might, Luke Evans just can’t compete with his cartoon counterpart.

A YouTube video offers a comparison of the two songs. The video can be found here.

If this was typical of how the entire movie compared, this remake should never have been made.

But happily, the live-action version actually improves on its predecessor in one key scene, and because that key scene is the dramatic climax of the film, it more than justifies the movie.

As the fairy tale goes, when the last rose petal falls, the Beast will have lost his last chance at redemption. He will never regain his human form and instead will forever be a beast.

That spell also holds true for all his servants who’ve been turned into inanimate objects like a candelabra, a clock, a teapot, and a feather duster.

This new version does a great job of revealing the pathos of these objects recognizing, with dread, that their human lives are, indeed, about to be lost forever as well. This poignant moment doesn’t register much at all in the original.

And this is just preliminary to an even more moving moment about to come, a moment whose resonance is also missing from the original.

Both films, of course, have the same happy ending: the Beast and all the servants eventually regain their humanity. In the original version, that transformation is standard stuff, everyone is turned into generic animated versions of people.

But in the live-action take, it’s a much more powerful transformation because these inanimate objects not only turn into real flesh and blood actors, they turn into very recognizable actors. Most everyone will recognize these actors and that drives home the potential loss of their humanity all the more.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

Seattle News Archives & Features

Fire crews respond to a helicopter hard landing after the aircraft's engine reportedly lost power n...

Tom Brock

Two aircraft emergencies in Pierce County Saturday

Two aircraft emergencies in Pierce County Saturday resulted in injuries to one pilot. 

12 days ago

This NOAA satellite image shows the magnitude of the storm moving inland from the Pacific Ocean. (P...

Ted Buehner, KIRO Newsradio Meteorologist

What to expect as Western Washington’s first big fall storm arrives Saturday night

The fall season’s first strong weather system will sweep through Western Washington tonight, bringing strong winds and rain.

13 days ago

Associated Press

3 dead, including suspect, and 2 deputies critically injured in eastern Washington state

SPOKANE COUNTY, Wash. (AP) — A shooting and subsequent firefight with responding officers left three people dead, including the suspect, and two deputies critically wounded in eastern Washington state Tuesday. Deputies responded to a home in Spokane County, which borders Idaho, around 2:30 p.m. after a woman told her neighbor that she had been shot […]

16 days ago

Sedro-Woolley medications missing...

KIRO 7 News Staff

Student medications found missing or diluted at Sedro-Woolley schools

Students’ medications are missing or diluted at multiple schools across the Sedro-Woolley School District, according to a district statement.

30 days ago

In this photo taken with a smartphone, Mike Herrington, the FBI special agent in charge, speaks to ...

Associated Press

Washington resident charged with conspiracy in Canada shool shooting is ordered detained

SEATTLE (AP) — A Washington state resident charged with conspiracy in one of the worst school shootings in Canada’s history has been ordered detained pending further hearings in the case. Melody Bryant, also known as James Cody Bryant, of Bellingham, Washington, was charged this month with conspiring to murder people in a foreign country. Investigators […]

1 month ago

The location of the Vertical Evacuation Tower will be near the Westport Marina. It will be the thir...

Tom Brock

Rising above the risk: Westport breaks ground on Washington’s newest tsunami refuge

The city of Westport broke ground Saturday on what will become Washington state's latest tsunami-safe location: a new vertical evacuation tower.

2 months ago

New live-action ‘Beauty and the Beast’ is a worthy remake