SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Seattle teacher allegedly compares Trump election to 9/11

Feb 13, 2017, 4:15 PM

A spokesperson for Seattle Public Schools says the district launched an investigation following an allegation against a Seattle teacher. It further expressed the district’s stance that classrooms should be free of political opinions.

KIRO Radio’s Dori Monson received an email about Brad Smith, described as a popular music teacher at Nathan Eckstein Middle School, who allegedly told a class of students that Trump’s election is “worse than the Terror Attacks on 9/11.”

Related: Seahawks’ Jermaine Kearse calling out absent students

Smith did not return Dori’s request for comment, however, the concerned parent forwarded Dori the following email allegedly sent by the Seattle teacher to about 200 people:

Dear Families,

Recently the subject of politics came up during class time and I shared my own political opinion. I recognize the importance of keeping the classroom free from personal political opinion to ensure a safe learning environment for all students. I will ensure this happens in the future.

Best regards,

Brad Smith

The show also reached out to the principal at Eckstein, who referred them to the District. SPS Spokesperson Luke Duecy said that the District can’t speak about human resources situations, but said that school district families received a letter of an apology from the principal. Duecy later clarified that it was Smith, not the principal who sent the letter.

“When the district became aware of the situation we launched an investigation and we followed our HR process,” Duecy wrote. “The school’s principal sent a letter home to all families explaining the situation and steps the school and the district are taking. As an educational institution Seattle Public Schools does not take political sides or positions. We cannot comment further on HR issues.”

Seattle teacher criticism

This is not the first criticism that some Washington educators are overstepping their bounds, allowing political or social views to bleed into the curriculum. A Kingston teacher received backlash for a “tone-deaf” comment on her Facebook page concerning the death of Reginald “Jake” Gutierrez, the Tacoma police officer who was killed in the line of duty; about 2,000 Seattle teachers wore “Black Lives Matter” T-shirts to their schools in October in a call for racial equity; and a Kennewick teacher compared a student’s ‘build the wall’ shirt to a swastika.

Dori, a high school basketball coach, is critical of a hypocrisy among teachers who espouse the importance of diversity in schools and anti-bullying — except, he argues, when it comes to thought diversity. He also didn’t view Smith’s letter as an apology.

“I think its absolutely outrageous if indeed, as has been alleged, a teacher compared a presidential election to a terror attack in which 3,000 Americans were slaughtered,” Dori said. “I’d love to find out if the teacher is old enough where he remembers people jumping from the 101st floor of the World Trade Center, sailing through the air and thudding below because they had a choice of either jumping or burning to death. I’d love to know if that teacher would say the same thing to the family members of The Falling Man at 9/11. That’s the state of our schools.”

Dori also floated an idea that he believes would improve the “transparency” of what is happening and being taught inside schools.

“We should have cameras in every public school classroom, where parents can access and monitor what the teachers are saying,” Dori said. “… I’ve never taken a tone, or said or done anything that I’d be embarrassed to have a parent hear.”

Please follow our Community Guidelines

FILE - People embrace near the scene of a shooting outside the Islamic Center in San Diego, May 18,...

Associated Press

Parents of San Diego mosque gunman say a mental health facility failed to heed FBI warning

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Just days before two teenagers carried out a mass shooting at a San Diego mosque, federal law enforcement officials warned the parents of one of the shooters that their son was making concerning comments about school shootings on the dark web, according to new details included in a recently filed lawsuit. […]

3 hours ago

Venus Williams, left, and Serena Williams, of the United States, look on as they play against Hao-C...

Associated Press

Venus and Serena Williams put on a show in thrilling U.S. Open return, in photos

NEW YORK (AP) — The Williams sisters returned to the U.S. Open doubles court, thrilling a packed Arthur Ashe Stadium crowd with a three-set battle that came down to the final points. Venus and Serena Williams fell to Hao-Ching Chan and Maya Joint in a dramatic tiebreaker.

7 hours ago

President Donald Trump speaks in the Oval Office of the White House, Thursday, Aug. 27, 2026, in Wa...

Associated Press

Trump’s first major midterm money move: A $10M Texas Senate ad blitz

BRIDGEWATER, New Jersey (AP) — The political group associated with President Donald Trump is spending $10 million on television and digital advertisements in the Texas Senate race, according to a Saturday filing with the Federal Election Commission. This is the first significant spending in a premier general election contest by MAGA, Inc., and reflects how […]

9 hours ago

Associated Press

Robin Morgan, feminist, poet and editor, dies at 85

NEW YORK (AP) — Robin Morgan, a wholesome child star of the 1940s and ‘50s who grew up to become an all-American radical as a poet, essayist, editor and second-wave feminist, has died. She was 85. Morgan’s death was confirmed Saturday by the Women’s Media Center, an organization she cofounded with Jane Fonda and the […]

9 hours ago

The John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, is seen, Wednesday, Sept. 2, 2026, in Washingto...

Associated Press

Kennedy Center renews call for Trump-backed shutdown after part of a ceiling collapses

WASHINGTON (AP) — A chunk of ceiling fell inside a main hallway of the Kennedy Center, according to a spokesperson who said the damage underscores the need to shut down the historic arts venue for renovations sought by President Donald Trump. No one was injured when a piece of the ceiling inside the Kennedy Center’s […]

9 hours ago

Associated Press

Cubans and Afghans deported from US arrive in Guyana

GEORGETOWN, Guyana (AP) — Guyana ’s government said Saturday it has received the first of six deportees from the United States under the Trump administration’s third-country deportation system. Guyana’s Foreign Secretary Robert Persaud said the six nationals of Cuba and Afghanistan arrived on Friday after being vetted by his administration and found to have no […]

11 hours ago

Seattle teacher allegedly compares Trump election to 9/11