SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

We need to take a long, hard look at our country’s immigration policy

Nov 27, 2018, 2:51 PM

Migrants tear gassed at the U.S. Mexico border...

Migrants run from tear gas launched by U.S. agents, amid photojournalists covering the Mexico-U.S. border, after a group of migrants got past Mexican police at the Chaparral crossing in Tijuana, Mexico on Sunday. (AP Photo/Rodrigo Abd)

(AP Photo/Rodrigo Abd)

Sometimes an interesting thing happens when I publish my daily “What Are We Talking About Here.” It somehow begins to circulate online in circles that enjoy pouncing on my Twitter and Facebook feeds and blowing up the comments section, usually in a negative way.

Such was the case when I wrote about U.S. agents using tear gas against men, women, and children at the U.S. and Mexico border on Sunday.

RELATED: Tear gassing migrants isn’t the image I want for America

Usually it follows this pattern:

“Hey Ron, but what about this and what about that?”

Then, “those people are breaking the law, or they are a bunch of criminals, or what they’re doing is illegal. Therefore, they deserve everything that is happening to them.”

Next, “Ron — you’re stupid.”

Finally, “Ron — you’re stupid and you’re an idiot.”

Typically, I don’t respond, but I thought I’d make an exception this time, because I believe it’s at the very heart of why things are deteriorating so much right now.

Let’s start with the premise that immigration policy in the U.S. is currently broken and dysfunctional. I would agree with that wholeheartedly. I would also agree that the system has been abused in the past and needs to be overhauled. So far, I hope that most of us are on the same page.

So what we’re really talking about is methodology. How, when, and why should we allow people to enter the United States? This, I think is a much more interesting question.

Since at least WWII, the U.S. has had an official, legal process that evaluates whether a foreign person should be allowed to enter and live in the country. The real question is, do harsh deterrents work as an immigration policy?

This is where you need a clear policy that applies across the board. If only we had such a thing.

Oh wait, we do. It’s called the law. I get it if you disagree with the law, but there is a law on the books.

A few things are pretty clear.

As University of California lawyer and legal scholar Teri Kanefield pointed on Twitter, it’s not legal for the United States to launch a chemical agent into a bordering country, and there is a clearly defined asylum process already on the books.

When an asylum seeker reaches the border of the United States, even without any documents, they legally have several options: They can present themselves for admission at a port of entry, and claim asylum or “fear of persecution,” or they can enter illegally and present themselves to an official as quickly as possible and claim asylum or “fear of persecution.”

They then are legally entitled to a hearing to determine if they are eligible for asylum status. Therefore, when migrants “rush” to the border (if their intent is to seek asylum) they are within their rights.

So to all the people who are berating me online that these people should just follow the law, I would offer that two wrongs don’t make a right. If we expect immigrants to abide by the law, shouldn’t we expect the same of ourselves?

Please follow our Community Guidelines

Temporary fencing is seen at East Potomac Park, Saturday, Nov. 14, 2026, in Washington. (AP Photo/T...

Associated Press

Judge temporarily blocks Trump from moving ahead on Washington public golf course redevelopment

WASHINGTON (AP) — A federal judge on Saturday ordered a temporary stop to any work at a historic Washington public golf course not far from the White House, blocking for now President Donald Trump’s push to redevelop the site along the Potomac River into a championship-level venue. U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes issued the temporary […]

54 minutes ago

FILE - Richard Sterban of The Oak Ridge Boys performs during the All for the Hall concert, April 10...

Associated Press

Richard Sterban, member of the celebrated country and gospel group The Oak Ridge Boys, dies at 83

Richard Sterban, the bass vocalist of the Grammy-award winning gospel quartet The Oak Ridge Boys and a country music hall of famer, died Saturday, his family and the band said in a statement. He was 83. Sterban, who had been with the band since 1972, died in Hendersonville, Tennessee, due to complications from bronchitis and […]

1 hour ago

SpaceX's mega rocket Starship lifts off for a test flight from Starbase, Texas, Friday, Nov. 13, 20...

Associated Press

SpaceX’s Starship returns from orbit and is captured by launch pad arms in a dramatic first

CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. (AP) — SpaceX’s Starship made a triumphant return to Earth on Saturday, caught in midair by giant mechanical arms where its journey began 22 hours earlier. It was the grand finale that Elon Musk and his team hoped for — the first-ever capture of a Starship flying back from space. But with […]

5 hours ago

Associated Press

New Orleans port sues to get control of tanker that crashed into cruise ship on Mississippi River

Just hours after a tanker in New Orleans lost its steering and slammed into a docked river cruise boat, the city’s port sued to make sure federal investigators can seize the vessel that is owned by a subsidiary of a Chinese company. All 197 passengers and crew on the American Heritage cruise ship survived Friday […]

7 hours ago

The control tower is seen at Washington Dulles International Airport after the Federal Aviation Adm...

Associated Press

Why a problem on the ground can affect flights thousands of miles away among other issues

Regional U.S. air traffic control centers communicate using a complex network that’s “one of the largest telecommunications systems in the country,” and disruptions like those seen on Friday with an hourslong, nationwide grounding of flights can reverberate widely, according to an aviation expert. Michael McCormick, a former airspace manager with the Federal Aviation Administration, said […]

7 hours ago

Associated Press

At least 6 killed and 11 injured when bus overturns in southwestern Colombia

BOGOTA, Colombia (AP) — A bus overturned Saturday on a highway in southwestern Colombia, killing at least six people and injuring 11, the National Police said. A police report seen by The Associated Press said the driver may have briefly fallen asleep at the wheel, causing the incident. Videos shared on social media showed emergency […]

8 hours ago

We need to take a long, hard look at our country’s immigration policy