MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Portland wants Seattle to adopt its CEO tax

Dec 16, 2016, 1:38 PM

CEO tax, howard schultz...

Starbucks Chairman and CEO Howard Schultz presents during the Starbucks 2016 Investor Day meeting, in New York, Wednesday, Dec. 7, 2016. (AP Photo/Richard Drew)

(AP Photo/Richard Drew)

The City of Portland is stepping forward with a first in the nation — a CEO tax. And it wants other cities to follow in its footsteps.

“There are about 540 publicly traded companies that do enough business in Portland that are subject to our local business income tax on profits attributed to Portland,” said Portland City Commissioner (council member) Steve Novick.

“What our bureau of revenue will do is look at the list of publicly-traded companies doing business in Portland, look at the Securities and Exchange Commission list (detailing incomes of CEOs and workers), and if the ratio is more than 100-1, then they will apply a 10 percent surcharge to the tax they would normally pay,” he said. “If the ratio is more than 250-1, they will apply a 25 percent surcharge.”

Portland mayor’s “hard message” for cities like Seattle

Starting in 2017, the SEC will begin requiring companies to disclose the ratio between their CEO’s compensation and their employee’s pay. Portland will use that list to implement its own CEO tax.

Even if a company is not based in Portland, it will still have to pay the tax if they do enough business in town to pay the local income tax. Novick points to Walmart and General Electric, for example. Now Portland wants other cities to implement their own CEO tax. But will it make a difference?

“Well if only Portland does it, then it won’t,” Novick said. “But if a lot other jurisdictions follow us, which I think might happen … then eventually the shareholders of America will have to recognize that the after-tax profits they get to divvy up is going down because they are paying their CEOs these outrageous amounts. And they will reduce their CEO’s pay and increase the typical worker’s pay.”

“The explosions of CEO pay is a relatively recent phenomenon,” he said. “It’s been going on 30 years, but when you look at the 1960s when the American economy was the envy of the world, the typical CEO made about 20 times what a typical worker made.”

The new CEO tax won’t be effective until 2017. Which means the taxes won’t be collected until 2018.

A Seattle CEO tax?

Portland wants other cities to follow, and if modeled after the Rose City’s legislation, companies such as Walmart, etc. could be paying more around the country, even in the Puget Sound region. But in the Emerald City, there’s a tech boom. Seattle is filled with high-paid tech employees, and company executives are no exception.

“In Portland, we know that at least 70 percent of people support the idea,” Novick said.

But could that support translate to Seattle?

According to the Seattle Times, the city’s top paid CEOs in 2015 were all from tech-related companies, aside from Starbucks.

• Dara Khosrowshahi, Expedia, $94,603,552 (cash pay of $3,750,000), 18,730 employees
• John Legere, T-Mobile, $24,457,987 (cash pay of $10,745,459), 50,000 employees
• Howard Schultz, Starbucks, $20,091,353 (cash pay of $5,505,000), 238,000 employees
• Satya Nadella, Microsoft, $18,294,270 (cash pay of $5,520,000), 118,000 employees
• Spencer Rascoff, Zillow Group, $16,881,235 (cash pay of $655,000), 2,204 employees

That’s just the top five. And of course, what matters is the ratio between the executive’s pay and the typical worker. So imagine the difference between Schultz’s $5.5 million cash pay, compared to the average barista. Consider Microsoft. CEO Nadella takes in $5.5 million in cash pay, but tech employees are known to earn higher pay. The median entry level pay for a software engineer in Seattle is around $93,984, according to PayScale.

Balancing power

KIRO Radio’s Dave Ross is quick to point out that labor markets often languish because of oversupply. And also, won’t companies just want to leave town if Portland puts a CEO tax in place?

“It’s not just a matter of a changing job market, it’s a matter of raw power,” Novick argued. “The richest 1 percent, especially the richest 1/10th of 1 percent, have far more wealth and income and power than they did 40 years ago. In fact, if you just restore the income share of the richest 1 percent to what it was in 1976, you would have enough money to give everybody in America in the bottom 90 percent a 20 percent raise”

“What’s happened is partly a change in culture — 50 years ago, people would think it’s unseemly for a CEO to make hundreds of times what the typical worker made,” he said. “But it’s also a reflection of the reduced power of workers, which has gone a long with the reduction in unionization – starting in the ’70s companies realized they could break unions without really a penalty.”

And does Novick think companies will leave Portland?

“They have not,” he said. “And that would be kind of silly. Ours is a tax that applies to their profits. And if they are still making profits in Portland, why would they close up shop?

MyNorthwest News

Digital...

Micki Gamez

How parents can help prevent children from falling victim to online sex crimes

Chances are, if your teen has a cell phone or tablet, they either know someone or themselves have been the victim of an online sex crime because kids as young as seven are online more than ever. My interest in this story began almost the same time last year when my daughter came home and […]

12 minutes ago

Pierce County Jail...

Bill Kaczaraba

Pierce County Corrections chief at odds with the employee guild

The Corrections Bureau's Guild has issued Patti Jackson a vote of 'no confidence,' as reported by The Tacoma News Tribune.

2 hours ago

Image: A Seattle Police Department vehicle seen during the day...

Sam Campbell

Security guard stabbed, suspect barricades inside Beacon Hill apartment

SWAT officers surrounded a complex in Seattle's Beacon Hill neighborhood after police said a man stabbed a guard barricaded himself inside.

3 hours ago

seattle indecent exposure...

Frank Sumrall

Seattle man arrested for 14 counts of indecent exposure, most near schools

A 34-year-old man was arrested by Seattle police (SPD) in connection to 14 counts of indecent exposure near Lake Forest Park.

3 hours ago

Federal Way shootings...

Bill Kaczaraba

Federal Way Police say two shootings are related

Police believe two shootings in Federal Way are related.

6 hours ago

Mulitple I-5 lanes shut down...

Frank Sumrall

I-5 fully open after person ‘ran around, threw traffic barrels’ on highway

An incident involving a person running around on Interstate 5 (I-5) forced multiple lanes to close just south of Madison Street.

7 hours ago

Portland wants Seattle to adopt its CEO tax